MisterBill2
- Joined Jan 23, 2018
- 27,651
My 2017 Grand Caravan starts very well without touching the brake pedal. BUT it stays in park until I press the brake.2017 Tacoma, V6, 6 speed automatic. Can not take it out of park unless the engine is running. Can not start it unless the brake pedal is depressed. Don't know off hand if after it's been started and still in park whether you have to step on the brake to shift out of park or not; my guess is yes, you still have to. When in all shift-positions the driver has the ability to shut the engine off. Park, Reverse, Neutral, Drive (or manual shifting using the up/down shift lever). You can shut it off in neutral then restart it but ONLY if you step on the brake pedal. Same thing is true for the Toyota Venza. Wife drives a 2009.
I've never tried to shut the engine off while moving. There may be some feature that will not allow you to shut the engine off while driving and in gear.
"Brake to start" is a safety feature so that you don't accidentally start the car while in gear. If for some mechanical reason the transmission IS NOT in park (or neutral), starting with your foot on the brake pedal makes it very unlikely you will start the car and hit something directly in front or behind you; be it a car, a wall or another person. "Brake to start" is an idiot proofing method to prevent accidental damage or injury to person or property.
and every car since my 1958 Plymouth has had to be either in Neutral or in park to crank the engine. That feature makes sense. Requiring a foot on the brake is required because a few fools were starting in gear and causing damage and injuries.
But requiring applications of the brake to start in an automatic transmission vehicle is stupid!! It might make sense with a manual trans, but for those there is still a neutral sensor. Engines that are less than perfect have been known to die while rolling in traffic, and hitting the brake in heavy traffic can cause collisions. That can happen when running out of gas.
So requiring brake application to start an engine is just plain stupid. But considering some of the things that have been included in cars over the years, it is believable.