MCB or conventional fuse to protect a 240 VAC circuit

Ian0

Joined Aug 7, 2020
13,313
The only "miniature" circuit breakers that I have used have indeed been snapped onto Din rails in control panels. Because they are WIRED on both supply and load side they are not at all suitable for application in a distribution panel at all, at least where I live. Distribution panel breakers are fed off of a bus-bar, which is protected by a Main Circuit Breaker, always with a greater current rating.
So the type of breaker utilized depends greatly on the application, at least where some regulations apply. And still, not calling them BRANCH circuit breakers, relating to the application, makes a lot more sense to me.
When you buy a “consumer unit” it comes with a copper bar like this, which joins all the MCBs together.
There are versions with two and three bars, and insulation between them which connect every other, or every third breaker to a common live.9AB8CFE2-1A3F-41F6-B488-DCE4BD774152.jpeg
It's also a very handy piece of copper if you want to put a high current bus on a pcb! The 18mm spacing is just about right for TO220 transistors.
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
28,561
The first and following uses of the term MCB that I have come across were in these forums and referencing what certainly fits the description of a distribution panel. Possibly that might be due to a misinterpretation of the TS, coupled with my very poor mind reading ability. That is entirely possible.
 

panic mode

Joined Oct 10, 2011
5,450
I have a 240 volt line wired to the load side of a contactor. Instead of using a conventional fuse to protect the circuit I figured I could use a 2 pole MCB coupled with a 2 pole RCCB both of which are rated L + N. The 240 VAC line wired to the contactor has 2 hots (L + L) and a ground - no neutral. The Chinese supplier selling the MCB and RCCB assured me the circuit will run just fine. Having limited knowledge though I cannot help but to be skeptical. Hopefully someone knowledgeable out there can shed some light.

Thanks
will it run - yes, and using two pole breaker instead of two pole fuse is preferred since thip in one leg would disable both...
will it trip in case of fault - it should, that is what is designed to do. since this is wired device, even few feet of wire will limit fault current to levels that this device should be able to handle.
will it be acceptable to local authority - no. this would be illegal since those parts are not independently tested and approved to meet Canadian (or UL) standards.

attached file is some 8-10 year old but it gives you an idea.

you may choose to go for it and just keep quiet about it. nobody is going to knock on your door and demand to do an inspection unless there was an accident or this is advertised/sold as a product.
 

Attachments

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
28,561
One question: As the load is controlled by a contactor, is it something used or operated by a person? Or is it a part of a system that operates without human involvement? Since the RCCB (GFI in my area) is for shock prevention, it may not be needed. Also, I have not seen any GFI device that has survived a short-circuit -to-ground event. Without exception, the unbalanced short circuit current has produced a voltage spike that has damaged the electronic circuit in the GFI device. Which is a rather expensive fuse.
So I am wondering if others have any experience with RCCB or GFI devices surviving a shorted circuit event of the type Line to Ground, rather than protected line to protected neutral?
 
Top