Low Power Schmitt Trigger with BJTs

Thread Starter

vandveuser16776

Joined Feb 21, 2026
121
Hi guys.
I have these solar cells that give me about 4v and 50mA to 80mA depending on the environment. They can go up to 200mA but that is not were I am using them. I need a circuit made of discrete components to start charging a Lipo battery (inside a wall clock) rated 1.2v and 800mA when the voltage goes down to 1 v and stop when it is 1.2v. Is it achievable? I dont mind using op_amps but I am afraid that the circuitry will hog all that tiny current.
 

crutschow

Joined Mar 14, 2008
38,316
What type of battery has a fully charged voltage of 1.2V?
For example, NiMh batteries go to about 1.6V fully charged.

Below is the LTspice sim of a window comparator circuit using the dual LM393 comparator IC driving an N-MOSFET to control the battery charging:
It turns the MOSFET ON when the voltage is 1V and OFF at 1.2V, as determined by the TLV431 1.24V voltage reference and the voltage dividers R1, R2, and R3.

The total circuit current (red trace) is <1mA, not including the battery charge current.

The transistor can be just about any logic-level type P-MOSFET with a Vgs max threshold of ≤1V.

1774836775190.png
 

Thread Starter

vandveuser16776

Joined Feb 21, 2026
121
Thank you! Is it a good practice to charge Lipo batteries to maximum? I hear a lot about that 60% to 85% is the best range to keep but I am not sure if it is a myth or truth. I just thought since it is a set-up-and-leave design, it would not be a hassle to keep the battery in that range, but with a cellphone, it is hard to keep the battry in that limited window. Thanks again for the design.
 

crutschow

Joined Mar 14, 2008
38,316
You can use the LM2903B.
It's a newer version of the LM393 with a wider temperature range.

But you should charge a NiMH battery to at least 1.4V for a decent charge (below is the circuit modified for that):

1774877868980.png
 

Thread Starter

vandveuser16776

Joined Feb 21, 2026
121
Thank you for design. I do not know where the issue is in my simulations, but I dont get that sharp corner when the voltage is at 1v. That may not be an issue in practice, but when I change the battery with any fixed voltage (1v, 1.2v 1.5v) I get the MOSFET's gat ON all the timeaaaa.JPGbbbbb.JPGccccc.JPGdddd.JPG
 

crutschow

Joined Mar 14, 2008
38,316
I dont get that sharp corner when the voltage is at 1v.
If you mean the slow rise-time of the signal, that's not a problem in this application.
when I change the battery with any fixed voltage (1v, 1.2v 1.5v) I get the MOSFET's gat ON all the time
The voltage needs to go slightly below 1V for proper switching.
 
Last edited:

Thread Starter

vandveuser16776

Joined Feb 21, 2026
121
Thanks. I meant if the voltage is above 1.2v, supposedly the battery inserted has more juice that 1.2v, say, 1.3v, then the circuit will glitch? Because that is what I see in my sims. In the first snippet I put a 1.5v battery and the MOSFET gate is 4v
 

Thread Starter

vandveuser16776

Joined Feb 21, 2026
121

Thread Starter

vandveuser16776

Joined Feb 21, 2026
121
So what is the reason for adding the diode, resistor and capacitor to the battery circuit noodle (not shown in any of your posted schematics), as that is fouling up the circuit operation?
Oh sorry, those things were added later to see if it makes any changes. Ok then I breadboard it with LM393 and will keep you posted. Thanks again
 
Top