Control 12V brushless fan speed by varying the supply voltage?

meth

Joined May 21, 2016
327
I would say probably not effective, and if you go above 12V, after certain threshold not safe either.
Just get a 12V PWM module, those that cost 5-10$ would do just fine for ordinary speed control.. depending on your application of course...
 

meth

Joined May 21, 2016
327
According to me PWM is the way to go. But as I said, depending on your application, if you need to constantly reduce it for 15% maybe lower voltage would be OK. With PWM you can fine tune the speed with a potentiometer.
 

vandveuser16776

Joined Feb 21, 2026
232
I am using one now. It is for a fan that is supposed to run 24/7. It is rated 12v but I power it up with 9v. Speed is lower, but I think the fan's gonna live longer.
 

Thread Starter

AlbertHall

Joined Jun 4, 2014
12,663
According to me PWM is the way to go. But as I said, depending on your application, if you need to constantly reduce it for 15% maybe lower voltage would be OK. With PWM you can fine tune the speed with a potentiometer.
From google AI:
2-Pin or 3-Pin Fans (No Dedicated PWM Pin): Applying PWM directly to the power supply (chopping the DC voltage) is not recommended for standard brushless DC (BLDC) fans. Because BLDC motors have built-in commutation circuitry and capacitors, external power-pulsing can starve the internal controller, cause audible whining, increase ripple current, and damage internal components over time. Instead, use a variable DC voltage regulator or a proper 4-pin PWM-controlled fan.
 

meth

Joined May 21, 2016
327
As mentioned there are BLDC fans with 4 pins, where one of the pins is a PWM input, designed for speed control.
The other BLDC fans with 2 or 3 pins (the 3rd pin is sensor feedback) have a rated voltage (usually 12V) but you can play with the speed by adjusting the voltage. So it is up to you, depending of the rest of the circuitry, what type of control would be easier to implement.
 

Reloadron

Joined Jan 15, 2015
7,977
Is changing the supply voltage to a 12V, 80mm brushless fan effective and safe?
Below are some numbers for a 12 Volt 80mm typical fan:

VOLTAGE APPLIED
(VOLTS)
CURRENT DRAW
(mA)
FAN SPEED
(RPM)
12.078157.42,739
9.013115.22,139
6.02575.01,460
3.01131.3114 to 125

Generally I prefer using PWM to control fan speed but varying supply voltage works. Keep in mind using using a pot that at 9.0 volts a current draw is 115.2 mA you want at least a 2.0 watt pot allowing for some headroom.

Ron
 

ZhangSheng

Joined Sep 25, 2026
17
One distinction that matters here is that a brushless fan is not a plain DC motor with a supply across a winding. Inside the frame there is a small commutation controller, a Hall device and driver transistors, and that electronics has its own behaviour as the supply falls:

1. Start voltage is not the same as run voltage. Most of these fans have an undervoltage cut-out and need a higher voltage to start reliably than they need to keep turning once they are running. A fan that happily runs at, say, 5 V after being started at 12 V may sit still, twitch, or start only sometimes if it is switched on at 5 V - and starting gets worse with cold bearings, dust, a filter adding static pressure, or the fan mounted in its least favourable orientation. That hysteresis is why the suggestion to start at full voltage and then reduce it is sound practice rather than a nicety.

2. The lower end of the range is therefore not really usable control range. The speed/voltage curve is reasonably well behaved in the middle, then collapses quickly as the controller approaches cut-out, as the figures in the post above show at 3 V. In that region a small change in load or temperature is the difference between running slowly and stalled, with no useful airflow either way.

3. How the voltage is dropped matters. A series resistor or diodes drop a voltage that depends on fan current, and fan current changes with speed and load, so the setting drifts and the control interacts with the load. A linear regulator at least holds a voltage, but it dissipates the dropped voltage times fan current as heat and still leaves the start-up problem unsolved.

4. Chopping the supply is different from using a proper PWM input. On a 2-wire or 3-wire fan, PWM on the supply repeatedly powers the internal controller up and down; depending on frequency it can produce audible noise, unreliable starting, and a tachometer output that is meaningless during the off periods, because the circuit that generates the tach pulses is unpowered then too. A 4-wire fan avoids all of that because the supply stays at a steady 12 V and only the separate logic-level control input is modulated.

So, in practical terms: voltage reduction is effective and safe for slowing a 2-wire or 3-wire fan provided you never exceed the rated voltage, you stay well clear of the stall/cut-out region, and you test the worst case - a cold start, at the lowest voltage you intend to use, with the fan stopped, in its actual mounting and airflow conditions, several times in a row. If it must restart unattended after a power interruption, that start-up test, rather than the running speed, is what should set your minimum voltage.
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
28,552
My first question woud be"How much slower" do you want to run the fan?? In many cases reducing the voltage will slow an induction motor some, and will slow a series brushed motor quite well.
BUT it seems that the discusion is about a fan with a brushless DC motor. CERTAINLY reducing the voltage will reduce the power and the fan will run slower. Probably the speed reduction will not be linear with the voltage reduction. The question about it being "safe" is interesting. Since reducing the voltage reduces the power, that relationship is safe. Reducing the voltage to a level that lets the fan stall is pprobably not safe. BUT, that is only a guess of mine.
I am looking at a "THERMALTAKE" 12 volt computer fan that is marked for 12 volt operation. It also runs on 5 volts, but slower than on 12 volts.
 

MaxHeadRoom

Joined Jul 18, 2013
30,881
Is changing the supply voltage to a 12V, 80mm brushless fan effective and safe?
12v brushless fan covers a wide selection,
One, is it 3ph or BLDC.?
If BLDC, does it have the commutation internal?
Or is there comutation connections with external connections?
Some small PC fans just have 2 connections with internal commutation.
The technology type is required before any of these questions can be answered.
Another example is many modern HVAC furnace fan motors have internal commutation electronics.
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
28,552
Oh Wow!! I made the rash assumption that the fan in question was "a two-terminal unit fan" of the common variety that I see frequently. Those fans use either mains power or 12 volts DC.
 
Top