Compatible MP3 converter search

Thread Starter

B-JoJo-S

Joined Jan 3, 2026
606
I drive a Toyota with apple play. I have an iMac computer. I've tried a few different programs for copying CD's to a memory stick for playing in the car. For instance, I just bought Fleetwood Mac CD and converted the files to MP3 format but only two out of 20 songs will play. The rest are unrecognized.

Does anyone have a similar situation and have a good CD converter that works in my situation they could recommend?
 
Before switching software, worth comparing the two that play with the ones that don't. Select one of each on the Mac and do Get Info, then look at the Kind and the bit rate. If the ones that fail turn out to be AAC or encoded differently, that's your answer.
Also, a Mac writes hidden "._" files next to every song when it copies to a USB stick. Some car head units list those as tracks and call them unrecognized, so it can look like most songs fail when it's really the hidden copies. Worth checking how many files the car thinks are on there
And the Music app on the Mac can rip a CD straight to MP3 if you change the encoder in its import settings, no extra program needed.
 

panic mode

Joined Oct 10, 2011
5,463
what do the MP3 files look like? what settings did you use to rip/convert the tracks?
my old car would not play anything over some 45Mb so i had to split some audio books and comedy shows.
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,531
what do the MP3 files look like? what settings did you use to rip/convert the tracks?
my old car would not play anything over some 45Mb so i had to split some audio books and comedy shows.
Are you talking to me?

$ sudo apt install abcde lame eyed3 cdparanoia

$ abcde -o mp3:"-b 320"

Encodes 320 kbps.

Other common options:

GoalCommand
Default MP3 (usually ~128–192 kbps)abcde -o mp3
320 kbps MP3abcde -o mp3:"-b 320"
Specify drive (if needed)abcde -d /dev/sr0 -o mp3:"-b 320"
Non-interactive (auto-accept first CDDB match)abcde -N -o mp3:"-b 320"
Faster encoding (use 4 cores)abcde -j 4 -o mp3:"-b 320"
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,531
There is also a program called "mp3gain" (again command line) that I used to use to normalize the output level over any number of .mp3 files so that they all play at the same volume.
 

Thread Starter

B-JoJo-S

Joined Jan 3, 2026
606
Before switching software, worth comparing the two that play with the ones that don't. Select one of each on the Mac and do Get Info, then look at the Kind and the bit rate. If the ones that fail turn out to be AAC or encoded differently, that's your answer.
This would sound right but here's the rub: 20 songs ripped but only three will play
Also, a Mac writes hidden "._" files next to every song when it copies to a USB stick. Some car head units list those as tracks and call them unrecognized, so it can look like most songs fail when it's really the hidden copies. Worth checking how many files the car thinks are on there.
Yep! Hidden files. But I know how to remove hidden files by "show all files" command. Can't think of it right now but it's easy enough to find on YouTube. I've done that too but still only three songs play. There's a LOT of songs I have on the stick that never get looked at, just passed over. Song number 433 (for example) will play, then the next song is number 451 or something like that. Supposedly I have over 1800 songs on the stick. It can take a month to play all songs but there are songs I want to hear that never play.
And the Music app on the Mac can rip a CD straight to MP3 if you change the encoder in its import settings, no extra program needed.
That's something I've not heard before. Thanks. I'll look into that soon. I have other things that take precedence. But for now since I'm convalescing I figured I'd ask and learn something.
what do the MP3 files look like? what settings did you use to rip/convert the tracks?
my old car would not play anything over some 45Mb so i had to split some audio books and comedy shows.
Can't answer that right now but I don't think it's that large. I'd have to do some investigating. But I'll keep that in mind. Thanks.
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,531
This would sound right but here's the rub: 20 songs ripped but only three will play

Yep! Hidden files. But I know how to remove hidden files by "show all files" command. Can't think of it right now but it's easy enough to find on YouTube. I've done that too but still only three songs play. There's a LOT of songs I have on the stick that never get looked at, just passed over. Song number 433 (for example) will play, then the next song is number 451 or something like that. Supposedly I have over 1800 songs on the stick. It can take a month to play all songs but there are songs I want to hear that never play.

That's something I've not heard before. Thanks. I'll look into that soon. I have other things that take precedence. But for now since I'm convalescing I figured I'd ask and learn something.

Can't answer that right now but I don't think it's that large. I'd have to do some investigating. But I'll keep that in mind. Thanks.
Oh! You're on a Mac? You should be able to run abcde directly from a terminal window. You'll need to search to learn how to install it.
 
The 1800 songs might be the real clue. A lot of car head units only index up to a certain number of files or folders on a stick and quietly skip the rest, which would fit with it jumping from 433 to 451.
Easy test when you get a minute: put just that Fleetwood Mac album on an empty stick and try it in the car. If all 20 play, the rip is fine and it's the stick being too full for the radio. The USB section of the owner's manual for the audio unit usually lists the limits and the formats it supports.
Hope the recovery's going well
 
Top