I will redo the steps as you suggested. I understand like you and crutschow suggest on being consistent in placing the probe in the same spot and with a similar pressure which we are trying our best to. I wanted to understand the theory behind the pressure affecting the measurement. Could you possibly help me understand more on that particular parameter?clean your probes and the contact surface on the resistance you are measuring. You might even have to sharpen the probes to obtain somewhat consistent readings, and as crutschow suggests, make sure you have the probes in the same place (and with similar pressure) for each measurement.
Measurements like what you are attempting are difficult to make repeatability. One technique that helped with a similarly impossible measurement problem is to take many measurements and then average them. This would then be useful in comparing with the average of several future readings.
I agree, averaging the measurements is a good choice to store the data adequately and compare them in future readings.