I have been looking at DC contactors and they do not appear to be cheaper than SCR or MOSFETS. The advantage I can see is power dissipation. I will keep looking into it.
I have found that indeed manufaturers of polarity reversing power supplies use the dual SCR configuration after each secondary pole.
Picking up a few books on power electronics. Knowing more can never hurt.
Thanks , everyone, for your information and suggestions so far, it has really helped!
The DC contactors we used had a "blowout coil" incorporated in the stationary contact. Just a "large" coil of about ten turns in air and had an "arc chute" to break up any arc. The field on breaking contact would force the arc upwards and into the arc chute to break it up.
Regarding contact life and usage, these contactors were used on DC cranes in steel works and had a pretty hard life with motors being continually run in forward and reverse and sometimes "plugged" ie switched to reverse while still rotating forward.
The silent electronic reversal seems more appealing. The annoying clunk of biggish contactors in action 2000 times a day might be hard for the workers to tolerate.
Given the low working voltage and high currents involved if it was me I would be leaning towards the SCR approach.
Its going to be your most efficient and cost effective method of doing this.
Being you already have some sort of massive rectification systems in place you would especially just be replacing the present diode devices with a SCR packages of the same device design.
We have been looking at the lifetime of DC contactors and it doesn't seem they are suitable (in the best case scenario they can last around 100k cycles, that's a couple of months in our particular case).
But those numbers are when switched under full load, so with no load the lifetime should be much better.
Also I imagine that the SCRs will have some voltage drop, so unless you redesign the power supply you will not get the full voltage to your load.