Quote: "Note the 'old' technique is probably good enough for many things, so the 'new' method is more of an improvement on the old technique"

Mr Al - I like to propose another way for clarifying problems in connection with the subject under discussion:

1.) As you say that the "old techique" (as described in all books and used since decades for teaching electronics) has some weak points, please tell us where this well-proven method (Dc anylysis for DC conditions and AC analysis for dynamic properties like gain) is not acurate enough.
(Quote; "my difference is because i solved for perfect topologies in order to get a more accurate result").

2.) To clarify all misunderstandings about your "new method" it would be best to demonstrate this method in detail (with numbers) using the transistor circuit under discussion.

Thank you and regards
LvW

 

Mod Note:
As the TS has not posted since his opening post and the Thread has moved from the TS's Topic, this Thread is Closed for further replies.
E

 

Mods Note:
Please be careful when you (all helpers) join the discussion on this forum (Homework Help forum), you (all members and the moderators included) can't provide any direct answer (or complete answers) for the TS, otherwise you may inhibit to join this forum (Homework Help forum) to discuss, but you still could view the contents of any thread on this forum, all members try to help only can be provide the guidance, no direct answer (or complete answers), and the TS (students) also can't ask the helpers to give you the direct answer (or complete answers), thank you all for your help.

PLEASE READ - Posting Questions in the Homework Help Forum -- see post #2.