Pin 2 and pin 4 is common on both if that helps?? So if it is an SCR how do I order a replacement?? or do I need to do more testing?I am going to go with Max's suggestion that it is a Littlefuse S4008R SCR. (The R option means that it is non-isolated, i.e. the tab is connected to pin-2.)
https://www.littelfuse.com/assetdocs/discrete-thyristors-sxx08xsxsxx08x-series-datasheet