How/Why do we choose an Z, Y, H or G model for a specific 2-port network when there is RL as a load?

Thread Starter

TarikElec

Joined Oct 17, 2019
147
Hello everyone,
I am learning the feedback topologies for 2-port network as we have:
-basic amplifier that is represented by 2-port network.
-feedback amplifier that is also represented by 2-port network.
There is a reference is in the link : feedback topology page 20 and up.
My question why on earth did he choose for example for a loading(means there is RL) a Series-shunt feedback (Voltage-Voltage basic amplifier) a G model and not a Z model?
1753956823238.png
1753956848410.png
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
27,164
I do not recall that in any of the higher level feedback control courses that a feedback system was treated in this manner. Is this method better, or just more complex??
 

Thread Starter

TarikElec

Joined Oct 17, 2019
147
I do not recall that in any of the higher level feedback control courses that a feedback system was treated in this manner. Is this method better, or just more complex??
I cannot say much as it is the first time for me to see it and they use it very much in analog ic design
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
27,164
Feedback systems for the real world are analog, even if it is a digital implementation of analog.And analog feedback systems mostly use real components, and so it is often handier to use models that translate into real world values the easiest. At least that has been my reasoning over the years. BUT I have not designed a fully digital feedback system, only analog ones. I have, however, donr the startup adjustments for digital emulations of analog systems. There is always an issue with the coefficients of the several variable parameters that must be set, because of unusual scale factors.
 
Last edited:

Thread Starter

TarikElec

Joined Oct 17, 2019
147
Yes, I understand that. In the lecture I provided, it is about analogue integrated circuit. I wanted to learn how to apply it and why he is using it
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
27,164
In many instances, including this example, the tool selected is the one that the user is most familiar with and thus requires the least effort to obtain accurate results.
 
Top