Capacitors for a modern LDO

Thread Starter

makaron

Joined Dec 17, 2011
18
I wouldn't do that. Your bypass transistor still has to dissipate 7W, or more like 7V @1.5A = 11W

What are you using as your power source and what are you supplying with 5V @1.5A?
If you reduced the input supply to 7.5V and use a LDO regulator, you will be dissipating 1.5A @ 2.5V = 4W.
You will still need a heat sink though a smaller one.
This bypass transistor does not have to take the full current. It seems that Q1 kicks in after input current generates big enough voltage drop over R1. So for a certain current range, Q1 could act as a parallel current source and power is shared between linear regulator and the BJT.

Challenge for me is to calculate the proper R1 value.

And you have a good point, I'll see if can use lower voltage than 12V for the rest of the circuit.

My plan for now is to use LM340S in DPAK (TO-263) package and add the ability to include this bypass transistor when heat becomes an issue (add heat sink there). Also do a lot of vias to ground plane (for LM340S) and such fun.

But this is getting far away from the original topic.. should I start a new thread if want to continue this discussion?
 

ian field

Joined Oct 27, 2012
6,536
Thank you for the suggestions. Unfortunately I am afraid that they all suffer with one shortcoming (for my requirements).
In their datasheets they all mention "If adequate heat sinking is provided, they can deliver over 1.5-A output current."

For this project, the extra effort of big heat sink still makes me prefer LDOs.
!
Thank you for the suggestions. Unfortunately I am afraid that they all suffer with one shortcoming (for my requirements).
In their datasheets they all mention "If adequate heat sinking is provided, they can deliver over 1.5-A output current."

For this project, the extra effort of big heat sink still makes me prefer LDOs.
The only way an LDO achieves lower dissipation, is because you can get away with feeding less voltage to the input pin without it dropping out. VxA=W whether you use LDO or any other linear type.

A lot of novices make the mistake of believing that using a MOSFET series pass transistor in a linear PSU, will by some feat of magic be as efficient as a MOSFET in a SMPSU - all it actually accomplishes; is making the circuit slightly more complex.
 
Top