Zener Diode Wattage Suggestions

ebeowulf17

Joined Aug 12, 2014
3,307
I think I was misunderstood. T1 grounds all the current through the relay coil when the gate receives a very small amount of current from the IC. I wanted to limit the current to T1 since it doesn't need much. I'm trying to limit current to or from the relay.
How much current does the relay coil need?

What is the hfe of your chosen transistor?

I always hear a rule if thumb saying that to use a bjt as a saturated switch you should set base current at 10% of your required current. You may not need to go that high depending on transistor specs, but why take chances?

If you're just worried about current through the MCU, you could use a logic level MOSFET instead of a bjt.
 

Thread Starter

mattd860

Joined Jan 9, 2016
58
Transistor 2N3704 on www.digikey.com (2N3704CS-ND).

I tested the resistance using trial an error using 1,000 ohms at a time. The transistor circuit worked well up to 5.1k ohms but after that it stopped working. Everything is working as it should and working very well (including the Arduino sketch code) but I was just trying to beef up the circuitry to prevent any future meltdowns or burn ups. Apparently I was way over doing it and I'm glad we determined this because now the finished product will need a lot less soldering :)
 

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
One actual result is worth a dozen theories.
In other words, doing the work to find the limit is good, just don't expect this to function properly in a dozen copies of the same circuit. Transistors aren't all that identical, even with the same part number. That's why we just blast the base with 1/10th of the collector current...it always works.
 

Thread Starter

mattd860

Joined Jan 9, 2016
58

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
From post #17: 5V 200 ohms means 25 ma to fire the relay. The base current should be 2.5 ma.
5V - 0.6V = 4.4V
4.4V/0.0025 amps is 1760 ohms.
So, 1.5K is a good thing for reliability.

I also checked your transistor. It's in the fat part of its gain curve at 25 ma so, good to go.
 

Thread Starter

mattd860

Joined Jan 9, 2016
58
From post #17: 5V 200 ohms means 25 ma to fire the relay. The base current should be 2.5 ma.
5V - 0.6V = 4.4V
4.4V/0.0025 amps is 1760 ohms.
So, 1.5K is a good thing for reliability.

I also checked your transistor. It's in the fat part of its gain curve at 25 ma so, good to go.

Wow - as always I get more than I ever expected on this forum. Thank you very much!
 

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
as always I get more than I ever expected on this forum.
Just remember to keep an open mind. There are some serious wizards here.;)
We can throw decades of experience at your problem in a matter of minutes.
Sometimes that means you have to forsake a belief you arrived with.:(
 
Top