Working on an RFPD (Radio Frequency Power Detector)D, but I have zero experience designing a circuit board.

Thread Starter

ekarls

Joined May 26, 2026
6
Hi all, I've had some experience putting together a prefab circuit board, like real simple stuff and aiding friends or classmates soldering. However, I am here today because I was picked for a fellowship over summer to get more hands on learning at my university.

The issue: I've been tasked with designing a passive RFPD circuit, and the grad student talked kinda fast and I understood the words he was saying, but I feel completely out of my depth in building this circuit from scratch. I wrote everything kind of jumbled in my phone notes (my mistake) so it's not a lot to go on. Basically, i'm supposed to take input(s?) from a coherent locking field and a 2nd side-band (probably things I should look up to understand what they mean), and the circuit itself is looking for a peak (meaning graphically?) at a specific MHz, ultimately to, from what I could understand, I could be completely wrong, pick up a beat note. I am unsure if the MHz i'm looking for is the beat note or just the input. The circuit is to have it's own volt supply 5-10V. I am just starting today, so research is my main goal for the next week, as well as familiarizing myself with Python - zero and LTspice for modeling. The output will eventually go to a VCO to go a cavity if it is in the specific MHz.

***Side note he did state that what I have to use to build the circuit is restricted to what is in the circuit lab on campus, so I will have to finagle stuff if they don't have what I end up modeling as what would work if that makes sense, though he did say I could build my own inductor (thats not a problem, I am a geriatric student who used to work at a vape shop when mech mods were still a thing, my coil wrapping skills excellent)

Any help, advice, starting points, resources I'd seriously, seriously appreciate. Thank you to anyone who takes the time to read this and respond, I want to know how to do these things and I want to also understand so I could do my own future projects for funsies.
 

Irving

Joined Jan 30, 2016
5,195
Firstly, welcome to AAC.

Sounds like you might have been thrown in the deep end here. I started my career as a RF design engineer and I'm struggling to make a lot of sense out of your description.

We need to know what RFPD actually stands for? RF phase detector, RF peak detector, or ?...I've never heard of a Radio Frequency Photo Diode and secondly, the actual frequency in question is critical as doing something at 1MHz is very different to doing it at 100MHz or at 10GHz!

If the circuit has a power supply it can't be passive.

A coherent lock is forcing an oscillator to track the frequency and phase of a reference so their relative phase difference stays constant (or follows a controlled ramp) as part of a phase-locked loop (PLL).

Not sure where the side band fits in to this unless it's a reference to the necessary rolloff of the filter to focus on the primary signal.

Too many unknowns to start advising you. You need the detail.
 

Irving

Joined Jan 30, 2016
5,195
Found this info that might be relevant:

Optical Phase-Locked Loop (OPLL)
  • Beat note between master and slave lasers measured on a fast photodiode.
  • Phase detector and high-bandwidth feedback to laser current and fast actuators.
  • Used to lock slave laser phase/coherent offset to master for heterodyne, interferometry, and coherent communications.
 

Thread Starter

ekarls

Joined May 26, 2026
6
Firstly, welcome to AAC.

Sounds like you might have been thrown in the deep end here. I started my career as a RF design engineer and I'm struggling to make a lot of sense out of your description.

We need to know what RFPD actually stands for? RF phase detector, RF peak detector, or ?...I've never heard of a Radio Frequency Photo Diode and secondly, the actual frequency in question is critical as doing something at 1MHz is very different to doing it at 100MHz or at 10GHz!

If the circuit has a power supply it can't be passive.

A coherent lock is forcing an oscillator to track the frequency and phase of a reference so their relative phase difference stays constant (or follows a controlled ramp) as part of a phase-locked loop (PLL).

Not sure where the side band fits in to this unless it's a reference to the necessary rolloff of the filter to focus on the primary signal.

Too many unknowns to start advising you. You need the detail.
Radio Frequency Photo Diode is the exact description of what I got, from another students project it is possible! It is a detector AND a filter of sorts, the clarification I received today: 6.5 MHz, creating a sort of passive system with inductors and capacitors, trying to dampen the noise below 6.5 MHz, and get a reaction when the beat note is at 6.5 MHz, I don't have to do anything with the next part. But if the beat note is not 6.5 MHz then it passes to a VCO to change the voltage of the system. The grad student is actually unsure how to control the 2nd band, it is some sort of effect after the CLF interacts with a green laser at a certain voltage output? So roll off sounds correct? He's not sure how to calculate or control it, so he's trying to see the effects of it when looking at the beat note. If the beat note is in fact 6.5 MHz it'll pass onto a mixer, of which I also am not going to be working on.
 

Thread Starter

ekarls

Joined May 26, 2026
6
Found this info that might be relevant:

Optical Phase-Locked Loop (OPLL)
  • Beat note between master and slave lasers measured on a fast photodiode.
  • Phase detector and high-bandwidth feedback to laser current and fast actuators.
  • Used to lock slave laser phase/coherent offset to master for heterodyne, interferometry, and coherent communications.
These are good jumping off points for research, thank you!
 

Sensacell

Joined Jun 19, 2012
3,789
I would edit the title of the post - "RFPD" is almost meaningless.
I could be an expert in this- but I would skip it because... Just spell it out.
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
28,561
I would edit the title of the post - "RFPD" is almost meaningless.
I could be an expert in this- but I would skip it because... Just spell it out.
"RFPD" is almost meaningless. Certainly RIGHT!!! My first guess is Radio Frequency POWER DETECTOR! I have seen circuits for those in HAM RADIO publications! They are used for checking to see if a transmitter device is functional. Of course, it could also be a "Reliable Female Puppy Detector, an item used by dog breeders.

Of course, I have also, within the past year, come across an article describing a scheme to measure the difference in frequency of two separate beams of light. It was intended for use with laser devices. That was a college level engineering project that was published a while back.
 

Thread Starter

ekarls

Joined May 26, 2026
6
"RFPD" is almost meaningless. Certainly RIGHT!!! My first guess is Radio Frequency POWER DETECTOR! I have seen circuits for those in HAM RADIO publications! They are used for checking to see if a transmitter device is functional. Of course, it could also be a "Reliable Female Puppy Detector, an item used by dog breeders.

Of course, I have also, within the past year, come across an article describing a scheme to measure the difference in frequency of two separate beams of light. It was intended for use with laser devices. That was a college level engineering project that was published a while back.
Apologies for using the acronym, I wrongly assumed from the start it was more common than it is. Measuring the difference in two beams of light from a laser is on par with what I'm tasked to do. They know by calculations what the expected value is, and I believe they want something to certify that.
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
28,561
I saw an academic paper on that process a few weeks ago. My first question is why is it important?? Especially, pushing for such high resolution?? IF there is something to be proved?? or what?? Dtermining the wavelengths of light in a beam was done many years ago, and that it was not simple.
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
28,561
IF the TS is requested to develop a scheme to measure the frequency difference between two two coherent light beams, that is quite a brutal challenge. I do not have numbers for the frequency, but look at the wavelength difference between light colors.
Now it is "LATER", and after more thought, measuring the frequency difference of monochrome light beams has been done a while back. My recollection is that it was far from simple, in both tha optical portion and the electronics portion.
The obvious scheme is to direct both beams thru a non-linear (at that wavelength) material and then accurately measure the frequency of the intensity variations. THAT is only simple in the basic theory realm, it becomes difficult in practical reality.
 
Last edited:

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,341
I saw an academic paper on that process a few weeks ago. My first question is why is it important?? Especially, pushing for such high resolution?? IF there is something to be proved?? or what?? Dtermining the wavelengths of light in a beam was done many years ago, and that it was not simple.
I'm inferring quite a bit here, but it sounds like this is a student project (and, if so, should be in Homework Help) in which the goal is to measure (control???) the wavelength of a light source by measuring the beat frequency of the signal when both that source and a reference source of known wavelength are superimposed on a sufficiently fast photodiode.
 

Irving

Joined Jan 30, 2016
5,195
I'm inferring quite a bit here, but it sounds like this is a student project (and, if so, should be in Homework Help) in which the goal is to measure (control???) the wavelength of a light source by measuring the beat frequency of the signal when both that source and a reference source of known wavelength are superimposed on a sufficiently fast photodiode.
Not sure it's homework as such. TS has been requested to build something for a bigger project that's outside his knowledge area. Agreed it's part of a student project, but he's not the student, more like a lab tech. I think your 'inference' is correct based on the original info and the limited research I've done and posted above. It's definitely an optical phase locked loop but what's not clear to me still is whether this is part of the transmitter or, more likely, part of the receiver. I'm guessing that the incoming beam will be mixed with a lower power local laser (the LO effectively) to regenerate the original 6.5MHz modulating carrier as a beat note which can be used to extract the (phase) modulation and control the VCO to lock the loop.
 
Top