Which Semiconductor company writes the best IC datasheets?

MaxHeadRoom

Joined Jul 18, 2013
30,692
I still have just about all of my older reference books from the late 50s and 60s. e.g., Mullard ref for Transistor circuits, RCA Thyristor Manual for just a couple.
 

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,344
Good app notes were the norm, not the exception. And companies would compile them and publish them in handbooks, where one could learn not only about the semiconductor products themselves, but also lots of circuit techniques.

Members here have already discussed handbooks from National, Motorola, TI and others. But an absolute gem is General Electric’s “SCR Manual Including Triacs and other Thyristors”.

This almost 700-page thyristor encyclopedia would provide the most comprehensive treatise on these devices, including discussion of some extraordinary complex circuits like the cycloconverters and resonant-commutated choppers and very obscure semiconductors like the PUT, programmable unijunction transistor and the SUS, silicon unilateral switch.
I still have my well-used 1972 copy.
Even intel was good.
1755017119011.pngPXL_20250809_180752955.jpg
1755017426165.png
1755017508602.png
In the same vein.
1755017213544.png
 

dl324

Joined Mar 30, 2015
18,367
I think National Semiconductor is the best. I too prefer the older style of TI datasheets.

When I left my job as an R&D Technician at HP Labs, my boss told me to take whatever databooks I wanted with me. I took the NatSemi Linear + Applications + Voltage Regulators, Signetics Memory + Linear Applications, RCA CMOS, HP Optoelectronics + Applications Manual 1st Edition, Motorola Zener Diodes + CMOS + MECL, Intel Memory + Component Data, TI TTL (2 versions and a pocket reference) + Transistors + Power Transistors, and a few others.

I've pretty much read the NatSemi. Signetics, and HP Optoelectronics applications handbooks cover-to-cover.
 

Thread Starter

schmitt trigger

Joined Jul 12, 2010
2,108
I also have got the exact same copy of RCA’s Solid State Manual.

And a little further back, I also got RCA’s Receiving Tube Manual.
 

atferrari

Joined Jan 6, 2004
5,015
RCA CMOS – The first one I got when I started learning about digital; it was also the first I lent to a neighbor, who moved away a few months later and never returned it.
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,720
I know this is a trick question. One cannot compare the datasheet for a 555 to one from an advanced 32 bit microcontroller.
One would have to compare exactly identical ICs, sourced from a multitude of companies, including obscure and defunct ones, in all three continents. In other words, an ubiquitous, low cost, well known, easy to buy IC.

Off my head, I could think of a few candidates, 555, 741, 358, 7805. I am sure there are a few more. From these I chose the 358 because.....reasons.
I searched for the datasheets from 10 different companies, and took a screenshot of the front page, which I have attached. You will notice that I included two from Texas Instruments. TI has recently revamped its datasheet portfolio, and greatly expanded the datasheet information with all the myriad variants, but simultaneously becoming more verbose. I prefer their older style.

To me the best looking datasheets are (were) those from National Semiconductor. The font, the way schematics are drawn, the amount and arrangement of the parametric information and relevant circuit examples. To me at least, those datasheets are the gold standard. Of course, other people will have different opinions.
I am like most people I liked the National data sheets better than TI's.
I caught TI inflating the specs of some of the parts going from the National specs to the TI specs.

Also, TI got pretty slipshod on their newer data sheet on the TL074 and similar op amps. They seem to have mixed up the specs of the A, B, and C parts, and seem to be pushing the new H suffix part. Totally ignorant of them.
 

dl324

Joined Mar 30, 2015
18,367
RCA CMOS – The first one I got when I started learning about digital; it was also the first I lent to a neighbor, who moved away a few months later and never returned it.
I found the application notes handy. You can get a PDF version on bitsavers.org:
https://bitsavers.org/components/rca/_dataBooks/

They have the 1975 and 1980 versions. Mine is between those years and I prefer it for the application notes.
 
Top