MisterBill2
- Joined Jan 23, 2018
- 18,502
Every source has an effective resistance, defined by it's voltage to current ratio. R=V/I Measuring may be a bit tricky, but that is what it is.
The signal doesn't see the open until the time it takes to reaches the end of the coax.But what i cannot understand is how there is voltage divider if the other end of the conductor is not grounded?
Let me repeat this slowly. Circuits with transmission lines ARE NOT EQUIVALENT to circuits with lumped parameters. Lumped parameter analysis only works on circuits that are "small" with respect the wavelength of the signals in them. The rising edge of a step function has considerable high frequency content (equivalent to very short wavelengths) as would be evident from a Fourier analysis. For some period of time after the rising edge of the step function, what is at the other end is completely unknown and unknowable. For that period of time the unterminated coax behaves as if it was terminated with its characteristic impedance which is equal to the distributed impedance along the cable.But what i cannot understand is how there is voltage divider if the other end of the conductor is not grounded?
When open ended, the equivalent circuit will be like the one on top, correct? A circuit wired this way will give you 5V as there is no ground reference.
View attachment 268227
The simulation in Post #16 shows another feature of transmission lines and impedance discontinuities. An incident wave can do all or part of each of three things at a discontinuity: it can be transmitted, it can be reflected, or it can pass through. In our case of an unterminated line substantially all of the incident energy will be reflected back to the source. In practice this is normally a situation you want to avoid, because depending on the power levels the source may be damaged by the returning signal power. The situation you normally want is for the signal power to be transmitted through or be absorbed by the discontinuity.The signal doesn't see the open until the time it takes to reaches the end of the coax.
Before that, the signal sees the 50 ohm impedance of the coax.
When the signal reaches the end it jumps to 5V, which then travels back down the line until it reaches the near end where the signal at the generator 50Ω load then goes to 5V.
This is shown in my post #16 simulation.
Systems governed by partial differential equations can have many surprising and counter intuitive properties.Really, it IS a lot more complicated than one might guess based on a DC analysis.
It is not a divider. It is a subtracter.But what i cannot understand is how there is voltage divider if the other end of the conductor is not grounded?
How so?It is not a divider. It is a subtracter.
Experimented with this back when I was building a TV station. Three cable groups: multiple cables in a bundle with wire ties, multiple cables together but unbundled, laying in an overhead raceway, and individual cables not near anything. All cables were one of two types of precision 75 ohm video coax. Lengths varied between 50' and 250'. The capacitance measurement method worked pretty well, always less than 5% error. The errors were both short and long, so the average over one 30-cable bundle was close to zero. We found no significant accuracy differences among the three groups.I do wonder about the effect of the surroundings on the results, though.
by Jake Hertz
by Jake Hertz
by Aaron Carman