Strange situations where you weren't sure what the hell was going on?

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
@Hypatia's Protege
Thank you for answering. I only had to use a dictionary twice.:) Condolences on your acrophobia. I suffer the same weakness.:oops: Unless one would call it a vital evolutionary adaptation.:rolleyes: Babies will not cross a visual cliff, and I would have become paralyzed with fear before I got to a hundred feet.:eek: I consider the equation to be denial vs survival instinct, and I'm awfully good at denial, but I can't beat acrophobia.:( If you ever seek me on an airplane, you can narrow your search by looking for white knuckles. Then examine the eyes for signs of drug ingestion.:D

I see that a large part of the difficulty is that I believed you were writing for the audience HERE, and you can see several people are of the opinion that, if such were your goal, it isn't working. Might I suggest that legalese is the art of obfuscation? My mind wanders to a courtroom where you successfully defend against an injured party with a large dictionary and the legal theory that other people's illiteracy plus hubris is not your responsibility.:D

I have always believed that achieving precision with concision was called, "elegant" and a worthy goal. In fact, I have some vanity about my abilities in that endeavor, and it is an abiding goal in analog design. Yes, I tend to ramble in Off Topic, but when I have a technical target (within my abilities), I can hit it so concisely that some people perceive my response as criticizing them.:(

Much like my theory on the soils of Florida and Kentucky, I wish I could put your style and mine in a box, shake it up, and find the result precise, concise, and much more readable. I would not dare to pee in your literary soup, but I am allowed to wish for it.;)
 
and you can see several people are of the opinion that, if such were your goal, it isn't working.
For all that we have a good deal of positive feedback as well!:cool: -- That said 'negative feedback' (i.e. 'constructive criticism') is more important inasmuch as it directs us to areas in need of improvement!:)

If you ever seek me on an airplane, you can narrow your search by looking for white knuckles. Then examine the eyes for signs of drug ingestion.:D
Oddly, enclosed structures and even open aircraft are not a problem for me (Re: acrophobia in and of itself) -- Whereas open structures, cliffs, canyons or -horror of horrors- open elevator shafts -- are quite another matter!:eek:
:oops: -- that said I tend to be 'desensitized' by 'exposure' - albeit it only temporarily so:confused:...

As a possible point of interest, my 'species' of acrophobia presents as a 'fear of jumping' -- as opposed to 'a fear of falling' -- During my early 'teens' I assumed I was merely 'weird' -- But then I learned such presentation is shared by Ca. 40% of acrophobes! -- Inasmuch as I harbour no self-destructive tendencies (latent or manifest) whatever -- it seems EA Poe was on to something (Re: His short story The Imp of The Perverse):) --- @#12 -If it's not over-personal might I inquire as to your presentation?

Might I suggest that legalese is the art of obfuscation?
On the contrary! Legalese strives to limit interpretation to a single meaning and a single meaning only! -- Unfortunately language thus 'stripped' of liability to ambiguity tends to 'take on' an 'algorithmic' caste:rolleyes:

other people's illiteracy plus hubris is not your responsibility.:D
Where the trust (and, indeed, safety) of the reader is at stake - such 'goes with the territory' as Re: my self-appointed role of educator...


I have always believed that achieving precision with concision was called, "elegant" and a worthy goal.
Absolutely! Where practically realizable!:cool: -- Unfortunately such is all but impossible when reaching out to a diverse audience via concept! -- Elegance and, indeed, eloquence are the province of narrative prose and poetry -- Whereas a conceptual approach cannot and must not assume anything beyond the reader's high intellect (without regard to knowledge) -- hence the requirement of emphasis upon formality (drearily utilitarian though such may, at certain junctures, be)...

when I have a technical target (within my abilities), I can hit it so concisely that some people perceive my response as criticizing them.:(

Much like my theory on the soils of Florida and Kentucky, I wish I could put your style and mine in a box, shake it up, and find the result precise, concise, and much more readable. I would not dare to pee in your literary soup, but I am allowed to wish for it.;)
Respectfully, I feel you're over-complicating matters -- It's merely down to the 'range' of one's audience! -- Which is to say I concur with your views as applied to 'narrow' and/or highly 'targetable' readerships...
Perhaps we're at cross purposes? (My bad:oops:)

Very best regards
HP

PS -- In the interest of maintenance of topic (here) --- I suggest we continue this discussion on the 'EHT thread'... -- Thanks!:)
 
Last edited:

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
If it's not over-personal might I inquire as to your presentation?
I thought I covered that when I said, "paralyzed with fear". As my altitude increases, my muscles become more tense until I am stuck, like a cat in a tree. If I did not acquiesce to this warning, you would need to pull me off by the scruff of the neck and then check to see if any of my claws were still in the tree bark.
The Imp of The Perverse)
Ah, yes. IMW we call this, "getting your blisters". People repeatedly try the same thing, expecting different results, until they get enough blisters to quit doing that. It doesn't matter if they don't understand why they keep doing the same thing, it only matters that they figure out, "it hurts". It is usually about how they interact with other people. Fortunately, few are hanged in this century.:D

This comes from an old wives tale about children and hot stoves. It doesn't matter how many times you tell your children not to touch the stove, some of them will feel compelled to touch it (apparently by the imp of the perverse). They will continue this behavior until they get enough blisters. The parent is acting out of concern, trying to save the child from blisters the parent received many years ago, but the child needs first hand experience for the penalty to register as "real" in his mind. It's a bit like re-inventing the wheel, but it makes perfect sense to me. A million students have destroyed millions of transistors, but they needed the experience for the lessons to connect from theory to reality.
 

strantor

Joined Oct 3, 2010
6,875
This morning walking to my truck I felt something poking my foot inside my boot. Each step made it worse. It was like a splinter or metal shard was being forced deeper and deeper into my foot. Once I got in the truck I removed my boot and sock and much to my surprise what I found sticking out of my foot was a hair! A dog hair. This is the second time this has happened to me. I think my dog might have some porcupine DNA.
 

JoeJester

Joined Apr 26, 2005
4,390
My lack of vocabulary should not cause HP to change her's to suit me. I have no problem reaching, metaphorically speaking, for the dictionary (merrian-webster.com). I wont accept the contemporary definition without consulting the dictionary is I find anyone's usage in a sentence that could be interpreted multiple ways. At an earlier forum, not this one, some members hated that I wouldn't accept their view as the proper when interpreting a sentence written by their arch enemy. Why should one lower their standards? Well, if HP was writing children's books, she would not be a best seller IF she continued to write in the current manner.

Yes, it's a challenge. HP might be writing for a specific class of members and my challenge is to increase my vocabulary and expand my knowledge base.

Yes, the words can be trying, however, all things governing us in our particular jurisdictions, is also written that may seem confusing.
 
As a possible point of interest, my 'species' of acrophobia presents as a 'fear of jumping' -- as opposed to 'fear of falling'
Ah, yes. IMW we call this, "getting your blisters".
FWIW, In my case, it's to do with cognizance of the fact that, via the merest motion (i.e. jumping or merely 'letting go') I would, in the space of a few seconds, bear witness to solution of perhaps the deepest mystery 'hounding' humanity -- To wit: disposition of mind following dissolution of body -- But then, as @Aleph(0) is wont to point out, that particular revelation comes to each of us soon enough - sans 'assistance':(:rolleyes:

Very best regards
HP:cool:
 
My lack of vocabulary should not cause HP to change her's to suit me. I have no problem reaching, metaphorically speaking, for the dictionary (merrian-webster.com). I wont accept the contemporary definition without consulting the dictionary is I find anyone's usage in a sentence that could be interpreted multiple ways. At an earlier forum, not this one, some members hated that I wouldn't accept their view as the proper when interpreting a sentence written by their arch enemy. Why should one lower their standards? Well, if HP was writing children's books, she would not be a best seller IF she continued to write in the current manner.

Yes, it's a challenge. HP might be writing for a specific class of members and my challenge is to increase my vocabulary and expand my knowledge base.

Yes, the words can be trying, however, all things governing us in our particular jurisdictions, is also written that may seem confusing.
Thanks, @JoeJester! --- Indeed! In addition to the demands of precise communication, 'my style' is largely guided/driven by my refusal to 'talk'/teach down to others! -- Inasmuch as I detest finding myself on the 'receiving end' of condescension I'll not offer it to others under any circumstances!:)

Very best regards
HP:cool:
 

cmartinez

Joined Jan 17, 2007
8,887
HP might be writing for a specific class of members and my challenge is to increase my vocabulary and expand my knowledge base.
Man... you have no idea what she puts me through every time I read her posts... :D

To her credit, it's not quite her vocabulary that I find challenging, but rather the structure of her sentences... to me, it's like reading LISP! ... but I've gotten much better in the last months at understanding her meaning on my first read ;)
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
So have you ever had one of those strange experiences were you are still not sure what was going on? While sober that is. ;)
Although I learned the next day what was going on, the first time that I did a hydraulic system bleed on an F-15 I was up in the cockpit working the controls and as I had the rudder all the way to the right and full nose up all the control surfaces were where I expected them to be. As I pushed the stick to full nose down the rudder reversed direction and went full left even though I had the rudder pedals pushed to right all the way to the stops. The same thing happened with the rudder the other direction. After verifying that this was repeatable, I called it to the attention of the guys I was working with (all of whom were flight line guys while I was a shop-level puke). None of them could explain it. So I Red-X'ed the aircraft and wrote it up.

The next day I called back down to the hanger by the supervisor who wanted to know why I had Red-X'ed a perfectly good aircraft. He was a bit pissed. So I explained it to him. He pointed out that that is what is was supposed to do. I asked him to explain it to me and he did. The F-15 is so aerodynamically clean and so tail heavy with those big engines that, in a turning dive, the jet has a tendency to want to skid out and swap ends. So the control system has a bias built in to keep the tail back where it belongs. I can't help but wonder at what stage of the design process they discovered the need for that little hidden nugget.

He understood why I had done what I did and was actually grateful that I didn't just ignore it -- and at the same time more than a bit miffed at his flight line guys who had been ignoring the behavior despite obviously NOT knowing that it was what it was supposed to do.
 

JoeJester

Joined Apr 26, 2005
4,390
Man... you have no idea what she puts me through every time I read her posts...
I'll bet I do.

Sometimes I'm reminded of when I used grammar checkers back in the DOS days. I ended up having to review a lot of my elementary school english and grammar classes. The WTF moment came when the checker stated my writing was "esoteric, overstated, pretentious, using too many sesquipedailan words and wrote in the passive voice." Ok, the technical jargon dotted the landscape of my writing that particular piece. Those grammar checkers drove me insane .... LOL. Writing in the passive voice is non-committal.

If you read enough governmental materials, you'll find numerous times should and may being used. Those are suggestions. the wills and shalls are not suggestions.

In another forum, a bunch of Chiefs were talking about an upcoming instruction. Some were interpreting it as mandatory, even though the specifics were not released. I told them I'd wait for the instruction to see what it actually says. It was NOT mandatory. However, if you did not go to this training, it may be reflected in your performance evaluations, another non-mandatory statement. Officers on the other hand, would interpret that as mandatory and lower the hammer on the evaluations. However, when used in the manner for attending the training, the Officer could deny, as it was "should attend" not "shall attend." Classic catch-22.
 
Last edited:

JoeJester

Joined Apr 26, 2005
4,390
None of them could explain it.
I've seen that response too many times. Yes, there was numerous times that required instant training. One thing that slowed it down was when I showed the offender that they should have known the answer because it was part of his previous training as specified in his Personnel Qualification Sheet. I even asked them if I should review all of those areas to see what rate/grade they are qualified to wear. Reduction in rate(grade) for incompetence is something I really didn't want to do.

He understood why I had done what I did and was actually grateful that I didn't just ignore it -- and at the same time more than a bit miffed at his flight line guys who had been ignoring the behavior despite obviously NOT knowing that it was what it was supposed to do.
Well, I'll bet he was more than miffed.
 

cmartinez

Joined Jan 17, 2007
8,887
Although I learned the next day what was going on, the first time that I did a hydraulic system bleed on an F-15 I was up in the cockpit working the controls and as I had the rudder all the way to the right and full nose up all the control surfaces were where I expected them to be. As I pushed the stick to full nose down the rudder reversed direction and went full left even though I had the rudder pedals pushed to right all the way to the stops. The same thing happened with the rudder the other direction. After verifying that this was repeatable, I called it to the attention of the guys I was working with (all of whom were flight line guys while I was a shop-level puke). None of them could explain it. So I Red-X'ed the aircraft and wrote it up.

The next day I called back down to the hanger by the supervisor who wanted to know why I had Red-X'ed a perfectly good aircraft. He was a bit pissed. So I explained it to him. He pointed out that that is what is was supposed to do. I asked him to explain it to me and he did. The F-15 is so aerodynamically clean and so tail heavy with those big engines that, in a turning dive, the jet has a tendency to want to skid out and swap ends. So the control system has a bias built in to keep the tail back where it belongs. I can't help but wonder at what stage of the design process they discovered the need for that little hidden nugget.

He understood why I had done what I did and was actually grateful that I didn't just ignore it -- and at the same time more than a bit miffed at his flight line guys who had been ignoring the behavior despite obviously NOT knowing that it was what it was supposed to do.
Your supervisor was a wise fellow. I've seen tragic situations and accidents that could've been avoided if people had not been afraid to report or ask for details for fear of looking foolish.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
Your supervisor was a wise fellow. I've seen tragic situations and accidents that could've been avoided if people had not been afraid to report or ask for details for fear of looking foolish.
I wish he had been my supervisor -- he was the flight line supervisor and I was a shop-level guy. Unfortunately both my supervisor and my shop chief were NOT this way. My supervisor was a certifiable idiot (that caused hundreds of thousands of dollars of damage on three occasions while I was there and almost got a couple people killed on two others) and my shop chief was simply out of his league with the F-15 and refused to admit it. Fortunately, we had three extremely competent civilians and a few similarly competent military folks that took me under their wing.

I got off on the very wrong side of my shop chief my first day in the shop. He gave me a box of parts and the tech order for a locking actuator and told me to work on it. So I opened up the tech order and proceeded to overhaul the part and about an hour or two later went and got him to ask if he could check me out on the test stand so that I could test the part. He agreed to do it, telling me not to get my hopes up because those actuators are almost impossible to overhaul correctly (a statement that really puzzled me at the time). It passed with no problems. I thought he would be pleased. He wasn't, though he didn't say anything. He did similar things two more times in the next week or two (one was a utility reservoir and I don't recall what the third one was) and each time the part passed -- the tech orders are written at an 8th grade reading level and are usually (not always) more than adequate to understand how to do something as long as you paid attention to the basic skills taught in tech school.

It wasn't until a couple months later, as it had become painfully evident that he had something against me, that one of the civilians pulled me aside and explained that all three of those parts had been parts that he had taken on as personal challenges and had been struggling with for several weeks to overhaul and could never get them to pass. Apparently the first one really had been intended to just give me something to do and to learn some things, but the other two had been intended to put me in my place.

He got his revenge when my first APR came up. My new supervisor had given me a APR (Airman Performance Review) that was straight 9's except for an understandable ding because I was on the fat-boy program (i.e., was over the weight limit). The shop chief overrode it and gave me an 8-overall rating and specifically gave me a low rating in the area of ability to learn and apply technical knowledge, despite having aced my 5-level exams and also my FTD (Field Training Detachment) school and having never had a part that I overhauled fail inspection. I was still trying to get into the Air Force Academy at the time and that APR ended any chance of that (if it's not a 9 APR, it's a bad APR).

But this is not to say that the guy was a moron -- he was just out of his league. He came up as an F-4 technician and I worked with him on a transient F-4 one day and I was truly impressed -- he knew that aircraft's systems inside and out and did a masterful job troubleshooting it and also a very good job explaining what he was doing and why. I learned a lot that day and he was actually a joy to work with -- because he was in his element and felt secure in his competence.

He got his own, though, when it came time for him to reenlist at the 19.5 year mark (as the result of some early-reenlistment situation during Vietnam) and, because HE was overweight, he was ineligible to re-enlist and they wouldn't waiver him. So he ended up with ZERO retirement benefits (other than normal VA benefits). Even though I did not like the man at all, I thought that was chicken &^$% on the Air Force's part because the man had put in two decades of service and was relying on that pension.
 

cmartinez

Joined Jan 17, 2007
8,887
I wish he had been my supervisor -- he was the flight line supervisor and I was a shop-level guy. Unfortunately both my supervisor and my shop chief were NOT this way. My supervisor was a certifiable idiot (that caused hundreds of thousands of dollars of damage on three occasions while I was there and almost got a couple people killed on two others) and my shop chief was simply out of his league with the F-15 and refused to admit it. Fortunately, we had three extremely competent civilians and a few similarly competent military folks that took me under their wing.

I got off on the very wrong side of my shop chief my first day in the shop. He gave me a box of parts and the tech order for a locking actuator and told me to work on it. So I opened up the tech order and proceeded to overhaul the part and about an hour or two later went and got him to ask if he could check me out on the test stand so that I could test the part. He agreed to do it, telling me not to get my hopes up because those actuators are almost impossible to overhaul correctly (a statement that really puzzled me at the time). It passed with no problems. I thought he would be pleased. He wasn't, though he didn't say anything. He did similar things two more times in the next week or two (one was a utility reservoir and I don't recall what the third one was) and each time the part passed -- the tech orders are written at an 8th grade reading level and are usually (not always) more than adequate to understand how to do something as long as you paid attention to the basic skills taught in tech school.

It wasn't until a couple months later, as it had become painfully evident that he had something against me, that one of the civilians pulled me aside and explained that all three of those parts had been parts that he had taken on as personal challenges and had been struggling with for several weeks to overhaul and could never get them to pass. Apparently the first one really had been intended to just give me something to do and to learn some things, but the other two had been intended to put me in my place.

He got his revenge when my first APR came up. My new supervisor had given me a APR (Airman Performance Review) that was straight 9's except for an understandable ding because I was on the fat-boy program (i.e., was over the weight limit). The shop chief overrode it and gave me an 8-overall rating and specifically gave me a low rating in the area of ability to learn and apply technical knowledge, despite having aced my 5-level exams and also my FTD (Field Training Detachment) school and having never had a part that I overhauled fail inspection. I was still trying to get into the Air Force Academy at the time and that APR ended any chance of that (if it's not a 9 APR, it's a bad APR).

But this is not to say that the guy was a moron -- he was just out of his league. He came up as an F-4 technician and I worked with him on a transient F-4 one day and I was truly impressed -- he knew that aircraft's systems inside and out and did a masterful job troubleshooting it and also a very good job explaining what he was doing and why. I learned a lot that day and he was actually a joy to work with -- because he was in his element and felt secure in his competence.

He got his own, though, when it came time for him to reenlist at the 19.5 year mark (as the result of some early-reenlistment situation during Vietnam) and, because HE was overweight, he was ineligible to re-enlist and they wouldn't waiver him. So he ended up with ZERO retirement benefits (other than normal VA benefits). Even though I did not like the man at all, I thought that was chicken &^$% on the Air Force's part because the man had put in two decades of service and was relying on that pension.
It's too bad that the guy wasn't as objective as you seem to be... form what you're telling me, maybe his own emotional involvement into things hindered him more than once. Perhaps someone upstairs held a grudge and blocked him from reenlisting.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
It's too bad that the guy wasn't as objective as you seem to be... form what you're telling me, maybe his own emotional involvement into things hindered him more than once. Perhaps someone upstairs held a grudge and blocked him from reenlisting.
I suspected that that might have been the case, but I'm far from certain; the Air Force was really getting down on people over the weight limit. This was very shortly after the movie "Iron Eagle" came out and, completely aside from the fact that it was a retched movie in just about all respects, it depicted many Air Force personnel as being grossly overweight and that created image problems that the Air Force leadership became ultra sensitive to. I was hammered for being twenty pounds overweight despite the fact that when we did our annual 1.5 mile run my time was the second fastest in our entire squadron at a little over nine minutes (the guy that was first blew everyone away as he was an amateur marathoner).
 

tranzz4md

Joined Apr 10, 2015
315
On thread,

Yes. I suddenly found myself lying on my back with 2 guys over me, saying "you'll be OK", then getting carried into an Emergency room.

Immediately prior to this event I was sitting in an informal meeting at a church, chatting with someone.

I wonder still what I missed.
 
Top