R11 is too large. It should be about 2k.
There may be a problem with the inductor.
Since you are using an unknown inductor it's difficult to determine what it's doing.
If the inductance is too small it could give the results you are seeing.
Run the simulation with a 100μH inductor to see what I mean.
So you may need a larger inductor, or operate the circuit at a higher frequency (which is limited by the op amp frequency response).
Try reducing the value of R5 (to around 5kΩ or so) to increase the frequency and see if that has any effect.
There may be a problem with the inductor.
Since you are using an unknown inductor it's difficult to determine what it's doing.
If the inductance is too small it could give the results you are seeing.
Run the simulation with a 100μH inductor to see what I mean.
So you may need a larger inductor, or operate the circuit at a higher frequency (which is limited by the op amp frequency response).
Try reducing the value of R5 (to around 5kΩ or so) to increase the frequency and see if that has any effect.