Sanity Check on FE Practice Problem Solution

Thread Starter

JimAnvil1234

Joined Apr 14, 2026
3
Hi all,

Studying for the FE Exam and I have found the "FE Electrical and Computer Practice Problems" study guide by Michael Lindeburg very helpful thus far. I am near the end, and this is the first problem I am a bit stuck on the solution and just want to make sure I am not misunderstanding, as these darn semiconductor circuits have been one of my weaker areas.

I have posted the full problem and solution for problem 9.

My hang up is on how they find the gate-to-drain voltage. I am fine up to VGD = VGS - VDS, but I also know VGS = VG - VS and VDS = VD - VS. VS is connected to the positive terminals of both sources. That to me seems to imply VGS would be 2V and VDS -1.9V, but the solution has that flipped and ends up with VGD = -3.9V. Could somebody help explain if the solution is correct, what I am overlooking.

Thanks!
 

Attachments

panic mode

Joined Oct 10, 2011
5,466
i don't see why would anyone need Vgd. what matters is Vgs and Vds.

one can pick top side of the circuit as a reference and go from there. or, if negative values and p-type are confusing, flip everything and use what you are more comfortable with (flip circuit upside down, change fet for N-type, flip polarity of both sources).

does this make things more palatable?
1792698631377.png
 

Thread Starter

JimAnvil1234

Joined Apr 14, 2026
3
Sort of, but now I'm also a bit more confused. If you go through the solution, VGD is needed to confirm what operating mode the circuit is in. I get VGD of -3.9V as does the solution when oriented like you've shown, but I'm still confused because for the sake of my original question, I'm trying to understand why VGS is -2V and VDS is 1.9V in the original circuit. IF VGS is VG - VS and in the original orientation VS is what's connected to the positive terminal, does that not imply VGS would be -(-2V) or +2V?
 
Last edited:

panic mode

Joined Oct 10, 2011
5,466
you are correct...

Convention is that Vab=Va-Vb so Va is the "positive"/"higher" potential.
But if you look at Vgs you see that Vgs = - E1, (negative terminal connects to gate, positive to source)
therefore Vgs=-(-2.0V)=+2.0V

when computing voltage in circuit one need to choose reference point.

assuming you choose Drain as "0V" (Vd=0V), we can choose how to get the Gate from your reference point:
1792712889267.png

i drew that path i chose (blue arrow) going through E2 and then through E1. Arrow goes in same direction as E2 (increases from - towards +) but then goes against E1 (from + towards -)

that means we get
Vgd= E2 - E1 =1.9V - (-2.0V) = 3.9V

Vdg is simply the opposite Vdg=-Vgd
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,891
Hi,

If I understand this correctly, the only confusion is what to do about sources that are shown to have a negative value like that -2v.
The simplest way to understand this I think is to simply flip the source from -2 to +2, then ALSO flip the terminal markings: minus changes to plus, and plus changes to minus.
When we do that in the schematic shown in post #4 it is clear that we end up with two sources that are BOTH positive (easier to work with intuitively) and they are in series, so the voltages must add. Since the lowest source has it's minus terminal connected to ground (0v), the total voltage is v1+v2 which is 1.9+2=3.9 volts and that makes the gate positive by 3.9v (Vgs=+3.9v) since the gate is also grounded at 0v.

So we turned this into a simple case of two 'batteries' in series which are series aiding (their voltages add).
 
Top