Replacement of electrolytic capacitors on laptop PCB by tantalum capacitors?

Thread Starter

Kevil

Joined Jun 28, 2020
224
I have an older laptop ASUS UX510UWK bought in January 2019. In about last 2 years I have random few seconds dropouts on my external 4K monitor connected over USB-C.

I think the problem maybe be caused in the lifetime expiration of electrolytic capacitors on the laptop PCB. I think their lifetime is about 3 000 hours. When I replaced one electrolytic capacitor 22 uF by a new tantalum capacitor, I measured the capacity of the old one just 7 uF of which is 32% of the full capacity.

Do you think it is worth to replace 10 electrolytic capacitors by tantalum capacitor?

Which tantalum capacitors to select to replace these electrolytic capacitors?
EAW25 330 2.5V
EAW41 220 6.3V
EAW42 22 25V
33EHS 286 (hybrid capacitor)
33_EHS_286.jpgEAW25_330_2.5V.jpgEAW41_220_63V.jpgEAW42_22_25V.jpg
 

crutschow

Joined Mar 14, 2008
38,321
Do you think it is worth to replace 10 electrolytic capacitors by tantalum capacitor?
I doubt your dropouts are due to capacitor failure, but it shouldn't hurt to replace them.

(A nit, but tantalum capacitors are also electrolytic. The common capacitors called electrolytics are aluminum electrolytics).
 

LowQCab

Joined Nov 6, 2012
5,101
"No User Serviceable Parts Inside"

Select a more modern Mother-Board, they're not all that expensive.
Computers need to be up-graded from time to time.
Besides that, you'll probably get a performance boost and more modern features.
.
.
.
 

Papabravo

Joined Feb 24, 2006
22,058
It seems unlikely that will do much of anything for 5-year-old capacitors. You do know that garden variety capacitors have a wide tolerance like +20% and -80% unless you are willing to pay extra for them to get a tighter tolerance and better temperature characteristics.
 

Thread Starter

Kevil

Joined Jun 28, 2020
224
I doubt your dropouts are due to capacitor failure, but it shouldn't hurt to replace them.
Can you advise me what type of tantalum capacitors I should buy?

The notebook is running well. I think the random dropouts of external 4k monitor are caused by insufficient power supply of USB-C to monitor caused by aged electrolytic capacitors.
 

Thread Starter

Kevil

Joined Jun 28, 2020
224
The monitor shows signal input source USB-C ->90W. "by insufficient power supply of USB-C to monitor" I mean just the power supply of USB-C line not actually the monitor itself.
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,463
It is highly unlikely that the USB output would be the only symptom of insufficient power. The amount of power used by the USB signal lines is minuscule compare to the laptop as a whole.
 

Thread Starter

Kevil

Joined Jun 28, 2020
224
We are a little off topic. My question was which type of tantalum capacitors to use for electronic capacitor replacement?
 

MrChips

Joined Oct 2, 2009
34,628
Tantalum capacitors are a type of electrolytic capacitors.
You don’t need tantalum capacitors. They will not correct dropout problems.
 

Thread Starter

Kevil

Joined Jun 28, 2020
224
Whilst MLCCs are susceptible to aging, polymer tantalums achieve long-term stability over an operational lifetime of 20 years
 
Top