Whether you circuit simulates or not it worn't work in practice since you have the NPN transistor upside down. In a real circuit the emitter base junction would avalanche at about 5V.That schematic doesn't work at all for me. This is what works for me. example1.asc
The problem is it only works when no current resistor is in place by the LED as it drops as much current as it takes to maintain its voltage, same with the one you gave me except yours didn't work in any situation.
Veracohr's simulation of my circuit works. Why do you say it doesn't?
It you keep insisting that correctly connected circuits don't work and incorrectly ones do. then we obviously can't help you since you apparently know more than we do.