Forbidden Region

Thread Starter

RdAdr

Joined May 19, 2013
214
In digital circuits, we have the voltage thresholds VIL, VIH, VOL, VOH.
And the noise margins are NM0 = VIL-VOL, NM1 = VOH-VIH

Also, there is a forbidden region. What is the use of this forbidden region?
What are the causes that led to defining this region?
 

Attachments

MikeML

Joined Oct 2, 2009
5,444
You want your input signal to swing through the "forbidden" region as quickly as possible, and not dwell there.
 

Thread Starter

RdAdr

Joined May 19, 2013
214
And I suppose this is because of noise, right?
For example, maybe the digital component has an NMOS transistor. And the forbidden region will be around the threshold voltage. So if the input signal is around Vt, then a little noise can bring it either to over Vt or below Vt, and this gives unpredictable output. So we have a forbidden region at the input.

And because we want noise margins we must also have a forbidden region at the output. Right?
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
25,930
It's not just a matter of noise, but of tolerances. In fact, even in the lack of noise, the forbidden region would still be necessary.

Let's say that there was no forbidden region (a better name would be the "indeterminate" or the "unspecified" region). That would mean that a manufacturer would have to design their parts so that their switching threshold, for every part, was exactly at that boundary. And it would have to stay at that boundary regardless of temperature variation, or supply voltage variation, or age, or anything else. Not possible to do.

V_IL is the highest voltage that the receiver guarantees to recognize as a low logic level. But in any given receiver the actual upper limit that it will recognize as a LO will be something above this. If you are a manufacturer of receivers, you know that your parts are ALL expected to recognize an input voltage that is equal to V_IL as a LO, and you know that you have production tolerances, so you design your parts to recognize anything below V_IL + V_something as a LO. You do the same for V_IH except that your receivers are designed to recognize anything below V_IH - V_something_else as a HI.

For a given part, there is only a very small input range that is truly indeterminate, But the location of this range within the forbidden region is unpredictable and it moves with temperature, supply voltage, age, and everything else. The wider the forbidden region, the easier it is to design parts and, hence, the lower the cost of those parts.
 

ian field

Joined Oct 27, 2012
6,539
Hello,

The "forbidden" region will give undefined levels.
Read the attached PDF for more info.

Bertus
The term is probably more along the lines of; "guaranteed transfer characteristic".

Whenever the logic level is in that forbidden region, the manufacturer makes no GUARANTEE what the output state will be.

Its a bit symantics - but that definition is good to keep in mind when fault finding "down to the metal".
 
Top