board to power on/off my audiophile Hifi system

Ian0

Joined Aug 7, 2020
13,312
So in that case, does zero-current switching make any sense?

In case i have to build module using zero crossing SSR (solid state relay) ... could you advise on it a bit more? ie design part.

Thanks!
If you're going to switch it at zero crossing, get in a good supply of spare fuses.
 

Thread Starter

thor21

Joined Sep 29, 2024
435
If you're going to switch it at zero crossing, get in a good supply of spare fuses.
dont get it....?


@prairiemystic
would you mind to share a design?
and elaborate on this: Although I've read and seen the results with SSR's best switching inductive loads at lowest dV/dt, you need a "random phase" SSR and then switch it only at AC peak, opposite for turn on and off no net flux accumulation, etc. I am lazy and this is too much hassle. So I just live with the occasional high inrush event.

thx
 
Last edited:

Thread Starter

thor21

Joined Sep 29, 2024
435
Last edited:

Ian0

Joined Aug 7, 2020
13,312
@Ian0
.... You can buy zero crossing SSR (solid state relay) for controlling AC devices. ....

A zero-crossing SSR is an SSR to control an AC device that switches on when the load voltage is close or equal to zero.
That's what @MrChips said, and it is perfectly correct for most loads, as it reduces the interference from the switching transient, and on inductive loads where there is no switching transient it does no harm. The exception is a transformer ( see posts #6 and #8) unless it has been specifically designed to run at low flux to avoid saturation on switch-on.
Most audio manufacturers seem to have the misguided idea that an exceptionally low impedance transformer is the answer, so they wind it for the fewest number of turns, which is the maximum amount of flux.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
Is there any difference if someone push manual switch comparing switch is on constantly and you control input 230V circuit of the mains?
There can be a huge difference. I have zero idea about your particular components (and I'm not interested in researching it to find out), but it is not uncommon for a power switch to actually cause a sequence of things to happen so that, for instance, things power up in the correct order or only as certain conditions are met. That behavior may rely on power being applied to the unit and then the power switch being turned on, as opposed to happening the other way around. If you have the manual, it might give an indication of whether the unit should be plugged in before being turned on. If you don't, then you could always do a crude (and possibly misleading) test by simply trying it (but knowing that there is some small chance of damaging your equipment even with a single such event). Even if it seems to work, that doesn't mean that it can't be stressing components in ways that will cause premature failure at some point in the future.
 

Thread Starter

thor21

Joined Sep 29, 2024
435
@WBahn
in that case i assume there is no other way how to automate power on/off of these components.

I think if i open both components and can see that switches only connect/disconnect Phase from the main... then its the same as what i am trying to achieve... ?
 

Thread Starter

thor21

Joined Sep 29, 2024
435
That's what @MrChips said, and it is perfectly correct for most loads, as it reduces the interference from the switching transient, and on inductive loads where there is no switching transient it does no harm. The exception is a transformer ( see posts #6 and #8) unless it has been specifically designed to run at low flux to avoid saturation on switch-on.
Most audio manufacturers seem to have the misguided idea that an exceptionally low impedance transformer is the answer, so they wind it for the fewest number of turns, which is the maximum amount of flux.
i went thru #6 and #8 but i dont understand ... sorry as i said, i do not have theoretical background.
 

crutschow

Joined Mar 14, 2008
38,938
i went thru #6 and #8 but i dont understand
The transformer looks like an inductance, and the inductor magnetizing current is normally 90° out of phase with the current, so starting with the voltage at zero degrees with the transformer magnetizing current also at zero, will result in a theoretical initial current twice normal (which typically will momentarily saturate the transformer core, causing a high inrush current for the first cycle or so).
Thus for no high inrush current you want to energize the transformer at the peak of the input voltage, where the magnetizing current is normally zero.

But if your devices are already turned on with an internal relay, then using an external relay for that purpose should be fine.
I have been turning my TV sets and associated sound systems on and off with WiFi smart-plug relays for several years now to stop their vampire power, and have never had a problem.
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,677
Simple question. if you unplug the device, then turn on its power switch and plug it in, does it come on as normal? If not, you cannot simply switch AC power it with any type if switch or relay.
 

Thread Starter

thor21

Joined Sep 29, 2024
435
Thus for no high inrush current you want to energize the transformer at the peak of the input voltage, where the magnetizing current is normally zero.

But if your devices are already turned on with an internal relay, then using an external relay for that purpose should be fine.
@crutschow
but how to achieve to energize the transformer at the peak of the input voltage?

Well the box with transformers doesnt have any relays there.
 

Ian0

Joined Aug 7, 2020
13,312
The transformer looks like an inductance, and the inductor magnetizing current is normally 90° out of phase with the current, so starting with the voltage at zero degrees with the transformer magnetizing current also at zero, will result in a theoretical initial current twice normal (which typically will momentarily saturate the transformer core, causing a high inrush current for the first cycle or so).
Thus for no high inrush current you want to energize the transformer at the peak of the input voltage, where the magnetizing current is normally zero.
There’s a bit of a “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” scenario, because if you go for mains peak, the transformer doesn‘t saturates, but you hit the peak capacitor inrush. Somewhere on the descending side of the sinewave seems to be best.
Then there are NTC inrush suppressors, but they have a tendency to explode.
 

Thread Starter

thor21

Joined Sep 29, 2024
435
arent there some devices i can buy? i think there is lot of theory which i dont understand and i am not sure i will be able to design properly working device... not even to be able to choose correct peak-switching SSR...
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,677
this are not modern in terms of cheap electronic devices. They have proper manual switches for power on/off
If this is true, then switching it with an electro-mechanical relay will work just fine. Why is everyone making this so difficult?
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
@WBahn
in that case i assume there is no other way how to automate power on/off of these components.

I think if i open both components and can see that switches only connect/disconnect Phase from the main... then its the same as what i am trying to achieve... ?
My personal guess is that you will be just fine switching your equipment on with external relays. I'm just saying that it's impossible to guarantee that this is the case without knowing some fine details of your specific equipment.

Also, note that even if each individual piece of equipment can be powered up this way, there is the possibility that the collection of equipment can't because of needed sequencing. Again, my guess is that this isn't an issue, but some equipment doesn't like to have signals applied to its inputs when unpowered, and other equipment doesn't like to be powered unless it's inputs are not floating. I had a component stereo system that had the precaution that the power amplifier should be powered up last. The manuals for the individual components should indicate whether any such precautions apply to them. If so, it would still be possible to make a power strip that has the appropriate sequencing delays incorporated. And, again, I doubt this will be necessary.
 

Thread Starter

thor21

Joined Sep 29, 2024
435
@WBahn
what relay are you referring to? SSR or standard mechanical? yes all devices are powered on first, the amp the last one .. that will be managed by smart home ie sequence of poweron/off.
 
Top