I'm working on a moderately dense board with a few power components (a couple of MOSFETs and a buck regulator) and trying to predict junction and board temperatures before committing to a layout and enclosure.
I can go two routes and I'd value the community's experience on where each is worth it:
A few specific questions:
Trying to avoid both over-engineering the cooling and discovering a hotspot after the boards are made.
I can go two routes and I'd value the community's experience on where each is worth it:
- Hand calculations using datasheet θJA / θJC and copper-area guidelines — quick, but I'm wary that θJA is so board- and airflow-dependent that the number can be misleading.
- Thermal/CFD simulation of the board + enclosure — more realistic for airflow and copper spreading, but more setup time.
A few specific questions:
- For early design decisions (copper pour size, whether I need a heatsink or vias under the pad), how far do hand calcs actually get you before they break down?
- At what point (component power, density, enclosure) do people find simulation genuinely necessary rather than nice-to-have?
- How well has θJA-based estimation matched your real measured temperatures in practice?
Trying to avoid both over-engineering the cooling and discovering a hotspot after the boards are made.