60 Hz AC system, change in direction of current

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tonyr1084

Joined Sep 24, 2015
9,744
Waveforms.png
In the above image I have 4Hz. If you have exactly 4Hz you have exactly 7 changes in direction. However, if you have a continuous 4Hz (for several seconds, minutes, hours, days - etc.) then there are 8 changes in the direction of current. So in theory, in absolutely only 60Hz there are 119 changes in direction. All on the assumption you start counting at zero degrees.

Incidentally I'm editing my statement in post #10 because it's not entirely correct. What I represented was the current into an inductor.
 

Thread Starter

Alchemy One

Joined Oct 5, 2019
217
If you start at the zero crossing then you must return to the zero crossing. Starts positive, changes to negative, then changes back to positive until it reaches the zero crossing again. Remember, a cycle is a complete 360 degree movement.

{comment removed due to inaccuracy of statement}
How many times did you say is the TOTAL?
 

Thread Starter

Alchemy One

Joined Oct 5, 2019
217
Assuming the power has been running for any given period of time before you start the count AND continuously after you stop counting - 120 times.
I don't know about you but I assume many other things besides that such as but not limited to you and me as conscious beings agree to it which incidentally I am in luck in regard to that.
I baseed my decision by the sheer definition of how we have collectively agreed to the meaning of a word/term in the use of words/language and secondly, I base it on logic/mathematics.
 

Tonyr1084

Joined Sep 24, 2015
9,744
I assume many other things besides that such as but not limited to you and me as conscious beings agree to it which incidentally I am in luck in regard to that.
What???

Never mind. I've given my answer regarding your question. I can add nothing more to it, nor will I attempt.

Have a good day. I'm officially un-watching this thread.
 

Thread Starter

Alchemy One

Joined Oct 5, 2019
217
View attachment 187964
In the above image I have 4Hz. If you have exactly 4Hz you have exactly 7 changes in direction. However, if you have a continuous 4Hz (for several seconds, minutes, hours, days - etc.) then there are 8 changes in the direction of current. So in theory, in absolutely only 60Hz there are 119 changes in direction. All on the assumption you start counting at zero degrees.

Incidentally I'm editing my statement in post #10 because it's not entirely correct. What I represented was the current into an inductor.
You are the first human being in a long long time that has inspired me. This is the kind of thing that makes my day. There is nothing more punishing to me than people who simply vomit what they are told. I guess critical thinking must be a sword most want to avoid because it would reveal how shallow you are and to me, it includes a vast majority in the sea of humanity.
 

Thread Starter

Alchemy One

Joined Oct 5, 2019
217
What???

Never mind. I've given my answer regarding your question. I can add nothing more to it, nor will I attempt.

Have a good day. I'm officially un-watching this thread.
Don't allow yourself to misunderstand me. :)
Your answer was golden. The one with 119 counts I think takes the cake.
It is very obvious you put so much thoughts into your answer. What a guy.
 
Last edited:

Reloadron

Joined Jan 15, 2015
7,977
In the diagram below, the blue arrows mark the start and end of one cycle of an AC waveform. The pink arrows mark the changes of direction. There are two changes of direction in each cycle.
View attachment 187950
So then we could say the voltage or current with a load changes 120 times per second, if we wish to look at it that way. I am good with that also. Certainly works with motor and generator RPM conversion to frequency.

Ron

You and I are both on the internet right now and we are reading it. I agree if it wasn't true they wouldn't be saying.
I believe in god, then the guy asked me which one?
I answered let me check with Ron. (just off the subject dry humor)

The only difference between you and me is this: the Internet is you and me and wait also these people. and these other people here and those........ and all of the ones everywhere. ....
https://www.quora.com/How-many-times-does-AC-current-change-its-polarity-in-one-second
The part about the Internet was tongue in cheek humor, I assumed that was a given but apparently not. So let's forget that and focus on why your comment or question? I also asked:
Maybe this would go better if you explained, in detail why you think this is false rather than have everyone else state why they feel it is true. This way people would better understand your exact, well defined, thinking on the frequency of AC current.
Now if your reasoning agrees with the above then fine but you have not said what your reasoning is based on? You have a similar game going in another thread.

Ron
 

Thread Starter

Alchemy One

Joined Oct 5, 2019
217
So then we could say the voltage or current with a load changes 120 times per second, if we wish to look at it that way. I am good with that also. Certainly works with motor and generator RPM conversion to frequency.

Ron



The part about the Internet was tongue in cheek humor, I assumed that was a given but apparently not. So let's forget that and focus on why your comment or question? I also asked:


Now if your reasoning agrees with the above then fine but you have not said what your reasoning is based on? You have a similar game going in another thread.

Ron
I don't know what your view is about what I am about to say.
Language is a strange business. I could be wrong about this but I think most people actually misunderstand the other. How often have you told another person, " That is not what I meant"?
As I got older I was forced to face that not as an opinion but as a matter of fact.
We even misunderstand the hidden unspoken part of communication which is termed as "intent".
It gets complicated. If I can help it I consider all of it. You can actually see it here, then again everywhere.
Chances are you may read me in a certain light and you are convinced about it, however, I have to give myself room that I could be wrong.
I know what this statement means when you say, " You have a similar game going in another thread".
I can interpret that as you perceive me as not being sincere, a game player, playing with people's time and energy, ruining their day.
It gets very interesting.
But one is certain, don't get used to it or you will suffer from boredom, whispering to oneself; " here is that guy again".
TonyR1084 didn't even catch my position in one reply but in my subsequent reply I let it be known with unequivocal clarity.

Here is my reasoning:
Imagine you have a very good video camera, one of them very expensive ones. You record your light bulb being on for one second.
Now you play what you recorded with very slow motion ( like the kind of camera the guy in smarter every day uses, this guy.
).
EVERY TIME THE LIGHT BLINKS I COUNT THAT AS CHANGE IN DIRECTION.
Not counting the ends because when the light comes on and goes off as no one defines that as a blink. And when you turn a light off no one defines that as blinks. People don't say blink on and blink off. And that is why I took my hat off to what TonyR1084 showed. It took me a bit to realize how much time he had spent on the sucker, checking and rechecking.
He went one step further, although his point was at my subconscious level lately, he simply threw it on my lap.
You can perceive the time I have spent painstakingly, typing and editing explaining myself as nothing but "games" and further feel convinced by it. Furthermore, you are perhaps convinced that the subject of my thread is insincere.
I can not accuse you of being insincere in your perception of me. Why? You really think I play games and I think it bothers you. It bothers you because you think you put yourself out there and I cleverly stay on the sideline.
Now show clear evidence for it unless you don't want to be inconvenienced.

MOD Note: Political statement Deleted, keep on Topic.E
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Reloadron

Joined Jan 15, 2015
7,977
The changes per cycle or second tell us nothing about the nature of electrical energy or its transmission. What is actually happening inside the wire with current and charges? Let's take the much simpler case of DC and follow it completely down the rabbit hole.

https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/relativistic-treatment-of-the-dc-conducting-straight-wire/
While interesting it has nothing to do with the topic and you have yet to address my question as to why you disagree with the voltage or current under a load changing 60 times per second?

Something I remember in every ad I ever saw my own company run and stress during interviews was the candidate must possess excellent verbal and written communication skills. So while I have seen "that's not what I meant" I never saw it in the workplace where excuses like that were unacceptable. Now answer my question.

Ron
 

Thread Starter

Alchemy One

Joined Oct 5, 2019
217
While interesting it has nothing to do with the topic and you have yet to address my question as to why you disagree with the voltage or current under a load changing 60 times per second?

Something I remember in every ad I ever saw my own company run and stress during interviews was the candidate must possess excellent verbal and written communication skills. So while I have seen "that's not what I meant" I never saw it in the workplace where excuses like that were unacceptable. Now answer my question.

Ron
Show me anywhere where I said this and I copy and paste your statement: "why you disagree with the voltage or current under a load changing 60 times per second?"

I thought you were asking why I disagreed as to the COUNT OF CHANGE IN THE DIRECTION of the current.

Furthermore, voltage is constantly changing at every point in time hince the value of RMS.
And the current depends on the load which may or may not fluctuate depending on lots of things.
These two values are a subject all of their own.
You may consider reflecting on your statement.
 
Last edited:

jpanhalt

Joined Jan 18, 2008
11,087
So I have an off the subject question:
I like to be able to delete my thread instead of it sitting here until the end of my days. Any idea how I go about it.
The other thread served its purpose.
I must admit I learned things I didn't know before. Heck, now I know how to split a phase, heck as many times as I want. :)
Just stop responding and "unwatch" the thread.
 

Thread Starter

Alchemy One

Joined Oct 5, 2019
217
Just stop responding and "unwatch" the thread.
Sure I get that. But will it delete the thread? There are threads that have been here for years and years.

I also noticed when I posted this thread, there was a section I believe I check marked close this post after so many days. But with my previous post, I do not recall check-marking that.
 

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,529
While interesting it has nothing to do with the topic and you have yet to address my question as to why you disagree with the voltage or current under a load changing 60 times per second?

Something I remember in every ad I ever saw my own company run and stress during interviews was the candidate must possess excellent verbal and written communication skills. So while I have seen "that's not what I meant" I never saw it in the workplace where excuses like that were unacceptable. Now answer my question.

Ron
The topic is IMO a dull veneer of nothing. AC or DC, at the free electron frame of reference the conductor is neutral with respect to the EM energy surrounding it so there is no charge separation along the wire transporting energy.. The energy we sense as alternating is actually the field surrounding the wire, not the direct movements of electrons

I didn't disagree with your answer or provide an direct answer to the OP's trollish question.
https://forum.allaboutcircuits.com/...-in-direction-of-current.163811/#post-1439629

Obviously there is only one polarity switch per cycle per the definition of frequency. What's a lot more insightful is there is a full rotation per cycle instead of the simple up/down of a harmonic oscillator.
 
Last edited:

jpanhalt

Joined Jan 18, 2008
11,087
Sure I get that. But will it delete the thread? There are threads that have been here for years and years.

I also noticed when I posted this thread, there was a section I believe I check marked close this post after so many days. But with my previous post, I do not recall check-marking that.
Why do you think you should have the authority to delete a thread? Not even our moderators do that with any frequency. At best, you could ask that the thread be locked.

The archival function of forums such as this is very limited, but it cannot be ignored
 

Reloadron

Joined Jan 15, 2015
7,977
How many times the direction of current change in one second in our so-called 60 Hz AC system?
Everybody seems to say it is 60 times a second.
I think it is false. What am I missing?
All I asked is why you think it is false and you have yet to answer that simple question. Why do you think it is a false statement? You have single evenhanded started two threads with each leading to little more than controversy. It is what it is.

Ron
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top