That doesn't make sense because the second counter enables the 3rd and the 3rd enables the 4th.It was lighting up one of the LEDs on the second 4017 and then jumping to the fourth 4017 so a section in the middle went dark.
To troubleshoot, you just need to follow the reset/enable signals. What type of test equipment do you have?
You mean you unsoldered everything and started over?At that point I just started over which is probably for the best now that I know I was pushing too much amperage through the 4017s.
Routing wires over the IC's and not using sockets must have made replacing the counter a PITA.



