Why wont the capacitor discharge in the following case?

Tonyr1084

Joined Sep 24, 2015
9,744
True, but ••• a bit misleading.
Yeah, quite a bit over simplified. But for the sake of argument and keeping it stupidly simple, current is current. Stable or ever changing, it's still current. And in keeping with the thread, no current "Passes Through" a capacitor. Not AC, not DC.

The argument can be made that a capacitor acts as a conductor part of the time and as a resistor part of the time. The greater the charge approaches max the higher the resistance. The lower the charge the greater the current flowing into OR out of (not through).
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,886
Hi,

Very good, but to be complete in the circuit analysis view (and more with the thread originally) the current APPEARS to pass through the capacitor and so we say that it DOES because in the external world there is no difference to our measurements of current.

When a circuit is being analyzed there is sometimes a little arrow in the 'wire' (line) that connects the capacitor to the circuit and that arrow represents the direction of current flow, and we might even draw those arrows on both sides of the capacitor which means in both leads so externally it looks like current is passing right through the capacitor. Add to that we have the relationship:
dv/dt=i/C
for example, and note there is only ONE variable for current, NOT two. In other words, we take it to be one current through the cap and not a different one in each lead.

Of course what we are ignoring in all these cases is the field, but then who cares when the circuit analysis yields the same results either way :)

Theories are like that, yeah they are :) They seem contradictory sometimes but they appear to be like that because of the history of discovery and application. This has happened over and over again in the past in various fields and it will never stop.
There is another theory that indirectly says that an electron that enters the wire at one end is the SAME as an electron that leaves the other end regardless when this happens. That's because of the identity idea that the electrons can not be distinguished from each other. This may not be true in every case now though as quantum theory advances. I think now there may be a clause that would state something like if there was any measurable difference. Real life measurements play a big role in this stuff and so as measurements becomes more accurate and significant we see changes in the theories.
 
Last edited:

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,529
In the end 'Electronics' is the science of controlling electrical energy electrically. Like a 'Coal Train' the 'Train/Electron' is just an efficient means of energy transfer. It's the 'coal' that's needed to for system work, not the train. If we concentrate the microscopic details of electron movements in conduction currents we tend to miss the whole show passing by.
 

BR-549

Joined Sep 22, 2013
4,928
Not me. I couldn't care less.........whats in the cars. I want to see the train's propulsion and control.

I want to see the process of force. The work done is only an artifact.
 

RamaD

Joined Dec 4, 2009
328
No, it is not, which is what this whole semantic pissing contest is about. Allow me to explain and mention other semantic piss-points. If a DC source (***not*** DC current source, the C already stands for Current, so "DC current" means "direct current current") of some voltage is connected to a capacitor with a different voltage across its plates, there will be *transient* electron flow (***not*** current flow; current is the flow of electrons, so "current flow" actually means "electron flow flow") until the capacitor charges up to potential of the DC source voltage, at which time the DC component of the energy will be zero.

ak
Thanks for explaining. While I agree (no one can disagree though) "until the capacitor charges up to potential of the DC source voltage, at which time the DC component of the energy will be zero", I should admit that I am unable to understand the rest!
 
Top