Understanding the use of Dual PNP in this circuit

Thread Starter

fastbike

Joined Dec 29, 2020
120
I'm looking at a circuit and trying to understand the purpose of the dual PNP transistor.
I'm guessing the P Channel mosfet is for reverse polarity protection.

1695793321577.png
 

Alec_t

Joined Sep 17, 2013
14,005
I agree it's likely just a reverse-polarity protection arrangement, but don't see how the dual PNP adds anything useful to the normal arrangement with just a pull-down resistor (R17).
 

AlbertHall

Joined Jun 4, 2014
12,293
Could it function as a current limiter?
As the current increases, the voltage across the MOSFET will increase and this will change the relative collector currents in the BJT and so control the MOSFET gate.
 

Thread Starter

fastbike

Joined Dec 29, 2020
120
So now that I understand what it is doing I've got a follow on question.
My normal go-to for reverse polarity protection is based on Rod Elliott's app note #13, figure 3 using a P channel mosfet with a pull down resistor on the gate and zener protection to protect the gate.
https://sound-au.com/appnotes/an013.htm
1695833548843.png

What is the advantage of the original circuit in this thread (using the ideal diode) compared to the one shown here ?
This one has a lower BOM count and cost.
 

Thread Starter

fastbike

Joined Dec 29, 2020
120
The original circuit will block reverse current even if there is voltage on the left side.
The simple one won't.
Thanks - I'll stick with the design then :)Edit: on reflection that is important in case somebody powers up the Pi via an external power supply :(
 
Last edited:
Top