Triangle wave generator without using op amp

Thread Starter

10_catalin

Joined Nov 1, 2024
10
Hi i am new here, i need the circuit of a triangle wave generator without using op amp for homework and i can t find one, everyone uses op amp, is here someone who has the circuit schematic? I can only use R,C,bipolar tranzistor/t-mos,diode, zener diode, no L.
 

crutschow

Joined Mar 14, 2008
38,316
Can it be sawtooth or does it have to be a triangle (equal positive and negative slope) waveform.
 
Last edited:

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,667
Hi i am new here, i need the circuit of a triangle wave generator without using op amp for homework and i can t find one, everyone uses op amp, is here someone who has the circuit schematic? I can only use R,C,bipolar tranzistor/t-mos,diode, zener diode, no L.
Hi,

Generally, the way that has been done for ages and ages is to use a constant current circuit (bipolar for example) and have it charge a capacitor. That creates a voltage ramp because v=i*t/C with 'i' constant and 't' the charge time. You then use some digital logic to get it to switch at regular intervales which may involve another circuit for the discharge. They even used this in black and white TV sets long time ago.
You can even fake it if you do not need absolute precision or a textbook theoretically ideal generator. That's because when a capacitor starts to charge through a resistor powered by a voltage supply, the initial ramp is almost linear up to maybe 1/2 to 1 time constant. That's an approximation to a ramp, and then you work out the discharge in a similar manner.

It sounds like you have to design it yourself though, so you have to look up first how to design a constant current circuit using one or more bipolar transistors. If an approximation is good enough, look up how a capacitor charges through a resistor fed from a constant voltage supply.
 
Last edited:

atferrari

Joined Jan 6, 2004
5,001
Get the datasheet of the ICL8038 where a simplified schematic shows how it works.

A late member of this forum even produced a simulation of the whole chip in LTSpice. I recall claiming that a search for any post of members that passed away is imposible using their nickname! They are ignored by the software, ridiculous as it is.

I experienced this when trying to look for exactly that simulation.

Will try to retrieve it from my laptop if you tell you are still interested.
 

Thread Starter

10_catalin

Joined Nov 1, 2024
10
Hi,

Generally, the way that has been done for ages and ages is to use a constant current circuit (bipolar for example) and have it charge a capacitor. That creates a voltage ramp because v=i*t/C with 'i' constant and 't' the charge time. You then use some digital logic to get it to switch at regular intervales which may involve another circuit for the discharge. They even used this in black and white TV sets long time ago.
You can even fake it if you do not need absolute precision or a textbook theoretically ideal generator. That's because when a capacitor starts to charge through a resistor powered by a voltage supply, the initial ramp is almost linear up to maybe 1/2 to 1 time constant. That's an approximation to a ramp, and then you work out the discharge in a similar manner.

It sounds like you have to design it yourself though, so you have to look up first how to design a constant current circuit using one or more bipolar transistors. If an approximation is good enough, look up how a capacitor charges through a resistor fed from a constant voltage supply.
Thank you for your reply, it was helpful.
 

Thread Starter

10_catalin

Joined Nov 1, 2024
10
Get the datasheet of the ICL8038 where a simplified schematic shows how it works.

A late member of this forum even produced a simulation of the whole chip in LTSpice. I recall claiming that a search for any post of members that passed away is imposible using their nickname! They are ignored by the software, ridiculous as it is.

I experienced this when trying to look for exactly that simulation.

Will try to retrieve it from my laptop if you tell you are still interested.
If you can retrieve it, it might help me a lot in this process, thank you!
 

DickCappels

Joined Aug 21, 2008
10,661
We are not allowed to do your homework for you but we are allowed to help you with your understanding of the assignment and give you some hints if needed.

What is your idea for a good solution to this problem?
 

Thread Starter

10_catalin

Joined Nov 1, 2024
10
We are not allowed to do your homework for you but we are allowed to help you with your understanding of the assignment and give you some hints if needed.
What is your idea for a good solution to this problem?
By using op amp the triangle waveform looks perfect, but in this simulation the line is not perfect

1234.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Thread Starter

10_catalin

Joined Nov 1, 2024
10
Can you post the text of the requirements you have been given instead of dropping them on us one by one?
adjustable oscillation frequency in the range 2.4-48khz, output load 24kohm, control of the oscillation amplitude in the range 2.4-12V, the possibility of adjusting the up/down ramps of the triangular signal,operating temperature range 0-70
 
Top