steady DC signal measurement changes when I change volts/div.

Thread Starter

Mrdouble

Joined Aug 13, 2012
107
My new oscilloscope is throwing me for a loop. When I measure a steady DC signal, the level changes when I change the volts/div. The software and graticle measurements both change to reflect the same results when I change volts/div. It seems to me, irrespective of the volt/div setting the voltage should always be the same. Probes are stock rigol probes that came with scope. Probes are selected 10x. I should say all measurements have been done on channel 2 and haven't tried channel 1. I have given the scope a self calibrate but results are the same. Thank you in advance.

image1s_Mrdouble.jpg image2s_Mrdouble.jpg
image3s_Mrdouble.jpg
 

Jony130

Joined Feb 17, 2009
5,488
This is what my old Rigol 1052E shows when I measure a DC 5.056V at least this is what my fluake 87V is showing.

For 1V/div I have 5.05V

NewFile2.PNG

For 2V/div ----> 5.08V

NewFile3.PNG

For 5V/div ----> 5.7V

NewFile4.PNG

And finally surprise surprise for 100V/div Rigol measured 16V quite big error. And I do not know if this is normal or not.

NewFile5.PNG
 

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
It may be normal, but I say it's bad...like, "send it back" bad.
I can't tell you how to fix it or even where to look, but I sure can agree, it's completely unacceptable by my standards.
 

ScottWang

Joined Aug 23, 2012
7,409
You didn't compress the image, three files spent over 10 minutes to download, too much file size will affecting the connection speed for the forum, it is unnecessary, and it will also affecting the members to join to the discussion, I already compressed them from about 1.8MB reduced to 80KB, please compress the file resolution to about 800x600 or 1024x768 before you upload them, it will enough for the most circuits or images, thank you.
 

DickCappels

Joined Aug 21, 2008
10,187
If you can't send it back, try to get the calibration or maintenance manual. As I recall on the old Tektronix CRT scopes that I used to calibrate there was a "balance" adjustment to the preamp for this very item. Maybe there is a procedure for your scope.

Have you run the automatic calibration routine yet? (if there is one)
 

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
I'm just too old to know this stuff. If my scope wanders, I clean the range switch.
How do you clean a digitally selected range switch? :confused:

Please let us know how this turns out. :)
 

dl324

Joined Mar 30, 2015
16,943
It seems to me, irrespective of the volt/div setting the voltage should always be the same. Probes are stock rigol probes that came with scope.
I'd say you were making some invalid assumptions.

On my Tek 7D20 (40 year old 70MHz digital scope plug-in for Tek 7K series analog scopes), the voltage readout is only accurate when the cursor is on a part of the waveform that's "on screen". When you change vertical sensitivity, you also change your resolution. For my scope, min resolution on the 5V/div scale is 200mV, on 2V/div it's 80mV, on 1V/div it's 40mV. When I switch vertical sensitivity, the displayed voltage is within the range resolution as long as the cursor is on screen. When it goes off screen, the reading is incorrect; but the solution is to select an appropriate range to display the waveform.

BTW, I rarely use the on screen readouts; I prefer to look at the waveform and measure the voltage myself. I only use the on screen readouts to remind me of vertical and horizontal settings. That's probably because I started out using analog scopes and don't have much use for most of the features of a digital scope; though I have a half dozen of them...

For my taste, your scope has too much information...
 

Thread Starter

Mrdouble

Joined Aug 13, 2012
107
If you can't send it back, try to get the calibration or maintenance manual. As I recall on the old Tektronix CRT scopes that I used to calibrate there was a "balance" adjustment to the preamp for this very item. Maybe there is a procedure for your scope.

Have you run the automatic calibration routine yet? (if there is one)
I did run the self calibration and I must say it looked quite exhaustive. By the looks of it, all 4 channeles were compared against each other and bouncing all over screen Took like 30 mins. I'm not kidding.
 

ronv

Joined Nov 12, 2008
3,770
I did run the self calibration and I must say it looked quite exhaustive. By the looks of it, all 4 channeles were compared against each other and bouncing all over screen Took like 30 mins. I'm not kidding.
It is difficult to see where ground is in your pictures. I think I would stat out making sure 0 volts is on the screen - then measure.
Also, what is "course" on the vots/div.?
 

Thread Starter

Mrdouble

Joined Aug 13, 2012
107
You didn't compress the image, three files spent over 10 minutes to download, too much file size will affecting the connection speed for the forum, it is unnecessary, and it will also affecting the members to join to the discussion, I already compressed them from about 1.8MB reduced to 80KB, please compress the file resolution to about 800x600 or 1024x768 before you upload them, it will enough for the most circuits or images, thank you.
These were strait off my phone
 

dl324

Joined Mar 30, 2015
16,943
And finally surprise surprise for 100V/div Rigol measured 16V quite big error. And I do not know if this is normal or not.
You just don't know how to use your scope:eek:

The resolution on your 100V/div range appears to be 12V. If that's the case, the 16V measurement would be within the resolution of the scope on that range.

A problem I see with digital scopes is that they give the appearance of more accuracy than one would reasonably expect.
 

Thread Starter

Mrdouble

Joined Aug 13, 2012
107
It is difficult to see where ground is in your pictures. I think I would stat out making sure 0 volts is on the screen - then measure.
Also, what is "course" on the vots/div.?
Course/fine movement of volts/div knob. Is that what you mean?
Not sure what you mean by ground in pic. Ground is below screen as indicated by arrow pointing down. Had to pull it low to fit signal on screen. I guess I could have just as easy used one volt signal lol
 

Thread Starter

Mrdouble

Joined Aug 13, 2012
107
You just don't know how to use your scope:eek:

The resolution on your 100V/div range appears to be 12V. If that's the case, the 16V measurement would be within the resolution of the scope on that range.

A problem I see with digital scopes is that they give the appearance of more accuracy than one would reasonably expect.
I understand the resolution on higher volt/div but can you explain why on lower?
 

ronv

Joined Nov 12, 2008
3,770
Course/fine movement of volts/div knob. Is that what you mean?
Not sure what you mean by ground in pic. Ground is below screen as indicated by arrow pointing down. Had to pull it low to fit signal on screen. I guess I could have just as easy used one volt signal lol
That may be the problem. Try it with ground on the screen and the 2 and 5 volt scale.
 

dl324

Joined Mar 30, 2015
16,943
I understand the resolution on higher volt/div but can you explain why on lower?
Can you describe how your scope handles vertical offset?

On my scope, the center of the graticle is 0V. When I apply a vertical offset, the digital voltage readout reflects that offset. For example, on the 1V range, if I move the trace to the bottom of the screen; no input gives me a readout of -4V. If I measure the 4V from the calibrator, I get a readout of 0V at the peak (it's a 1KHz square wave).
 

Thread Starter

Mrdouble

Joined Aug 13, 2012
107
Can you describe how your scope handles vertical offset?

On my scope, the center of the graticle is 0V. When I apply a vertical offset, the digital voltage readout reflects that offset. For example, on the 1V range, if I move the trace to the bottom of the screen; no input gives me a readout of -4V. If I measure the 4V from the calibrator, I get a readout of 0V at the peak (it's a 1KHz square wave).
Mines exactly the same
 

Thread Starter

Mrdouble

Joined Aug 13, 2012
107
This is what my old Rigol 1052E shows when I measure a DC 5.056V at least this is what my fluake 87V is showing.

For 1V/div I have 5.05V

View attachment 89566

For 2V/div ----> 5.08V

View attachment 89567

For 5V/div ----> 5.7V

View attachment 89568

And finally surprise surprise for 100V/div Rigol measured 16V quite big error. And I do not know if this is normal or not.

View attachment 89569
This is what my old Rigol 1052E shows when I measure a DC 5.056V at least this is what my fluake 87V is showing.

For 1V/div I have 5.05V

View attachment 89566

For 2V/div ----> 5.08V

View attachment 89567

For 5V/div ----> 5.7V

View attachment 89568

And finally surprise surprise for 100V/div Rigol measured 16V quite big error. And I do not know if this is normal or not.

View attachment 89569
with signal at 5.56v my error is 12v which makes sense after what DL324 said about resolution.
 
Top