Microsoft creates new state of Matter Quantum Chip

ZCochran98

Joined Jul 24, 2018
351
The last two times Microsoft researchers claimed to have the topological qubit/quantum computer, their papers were criticized for being "incomplete and misrepresent[ing] the results" (see this summary, which already has the 2025 results mentioned), mostly failing to actually show any real evidence for Majorana modes. Personally, I'm holding out any excitement until this has gotten further or more widespread review from those with more expertise in this subject area.
 

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,275
https://www.scientificamerican.com/...mputing-breakthrough-but-some-physicists-are/

Vincent Mourik, a physicist at the Helmholtz Research Centre in Jülich, Germany, whose concerns helped to lead to the earlier retraction, is sceptical of the whole concept. “At a fundamental level, the approach of building a quantum computer based on topological Majorana qubits as it is pursed by Microsoft is not going to work.”

“As we perform more types of measurements, it will become harder to explain our results with non-topological models,” says Nayak. “There may not be one single moment when everyone will be convinced. But non-topological explanations will require more and more fine-tuning.”
 
Top