LED based sun simulator

Thread Starter

abhaymv

Joined Aug 6, 2011
105
don´t the leds already have their own metal base to which you should attach the heatsink?
The SMD LEDs of Cree need to be soldered to MCPCB. But since even MCPCBs are a bit poor in heat sinking, we'd need to attach another heat sink. That's what I got from searching the internet anyway :D

So, would CPU heat sinks work? I'm thinking they ought to be some of the best, and combined with a cooling fan, should manage the temperature pretty well...
 

kubeek

Joined Sep 20, 2005
5,796
CPU heatsinks could work, but I don´t see enough info to judge this. IIRC you said you want to power it up in short bursts, so they will probably be enough. But still, you should get some info on the LEDs, the MCPCB and the heatsinks and do the thermal calculations first.
 

Thread Starter

abhaymv

Joined Aug 6, 2011
105
I would have done the thermal calculations if I had any idea what the thermal resistance of the CPU heat sink would be... And since its forced convection, wouldn't I need to consider air speed and all that detail?
 

kubeek

Joined Sep 20, 2005
5,796
If you take the typical pentium 4 and further heatsink like this , I would guesstimate that the ambient inside PC is 35°C, peak temperature of a CPU die is usually around 65°C, and the CPU typically has TDP of 65W (desing power for maximum load), so that gives ~ 0.5K/W with the fan fully on, so a 1K/W to be on the safe side.
Or you can bolt a transistor to it, put similar power into it and measure the temperature rise.
 

Thread Starter

abhaymv

Joined Aug 6, 2011
105
Thank you! Now,
Calculation time!

Cree XLamp XP-C ideal Junction temperature Tj=25°C
Maximum Tj = 150 °C
Junction to solder point thermal resistance
of red, Rjsr= 10°C/W
of Green, Rjsg=20°C/W
of Blue, Rjsb=12°C/W

Thermal grease datasheet does not seem to give thermal resistance, just says 'conductive'. So I'm assuming it to be zero.

Thermal resistance of MCPCB is near 5°C/W(Tmc)
Thermal resistance of heat sink: 1°C/W

Cree LED ratings: 4 X (0.77 W + 1.19 W + 1.115 W) by considering forward drops and maximum current.
4 heat sinks, so consider 3 LED per heat sink (12 in total)
Pdr=0.77 W
Pdg=1.19W
Pdb=1.115W
Where Pd is the total power dissipation.
Assuming ambient 30°C,

Tj=Ambient+ Rjs of each LED*its Power dissipated+ MCPCB temp. drop+heat sink drop

Tj=Ta+ Pdr*Rjsr+Pdg*Rjsg+Pdb*Rjsb+5°C (per LED, MCPCBs are individual)+(0.77W+1.19W+1.115W)*1°C/W
Tj=30°C + 74.88°C+5°C++(0.77W+1.19W+1.115W)*1°C/W
Tj=112°C
I guess I should be safe... Maximum is 150 °C
Or am I wrong?
 

Audioguru

Joined Dec 20, 2007
11,248
The surface-mount LED is soldered or glued to the aluminum STAR thermal substrate.
The thermal substrate is mounted on a heatsink or on a Metal Core Printed Circuit Board (MCPCB). The surface mount LED can also be soldered directly to a MCPCB by a soldering machine or an oven.

12 LEDs will produce about 30W of heat. I don't know if 4 small CPU heatsinks with fan can cool well enough.
 

Thread Starter

abhaymv

Joined Aug 6, 2011
105
Hi all!

I'd like to tell you all that the block level testing of our circuit was complete and successful!:D:D:D
It would never have been possible without all of your help!:)

On another note, how can I attach an MCPCB to the CPU heat sink without using screws? I want the MCPCBs to stick to the heat sink. I believe thermal grease is only an interface material, and thus cannot be used for the sticking purpose?

Can I use superglue? Will it melt away at high temperatures of MCPCB? Does it have a high thermal resistance? Could someone help me with an alternative?
 

Thread Starter

abhaymv

Joined Aug 6, 2011
105
I don't think I've seen that before, what do you call it? I don't know how to use that :(
You're talking about the small U shaped clip, right?
 

kubeek

Joined Sep 20, 2005
5,796
Yeah it´s mostly up to your ingenuity to make something that will hold the LEDs down. Could be a piece of plastic, a guitar string screwed to the heatsink.. basically anything that will allow you to exert some pressure on the pcb and withstand say 100°C.
 

takao21203

Joined Apr 28, 2012
3,702
This is how I cool components. Attaching them with silicone putty.

No more nails - is a brand from Henkel.
I am now testing a generic 2 Euro putty for the first time- 1/5 the price.

The adhesion depends on the finishing of the aluminium- it won't actually stick on a few types. Elox aluminium works unless the surface is closed up.

The good thing is it can be removed later on.
And also heat resistance is no problem.

LM723?

I run some LEDs directly from a 24v electronic transformer. It has a voltage adjust, so can be controlled exactly.

So to say, the regulator is already built in.

I'd suggest not to regulate individual LEDs, but to switch ON/OFF banks of LEDs to control overall brightness.

On a small VGA cooler you can attach 4x 3W LEDs with putty.
On a larger cooler, 20W or even 30W LEDs, or more 3W LEDs.

Why use screws and expensive heatsinks when you can get away without it?

VGA coolers are mass produced.
 

Attachments

takao21203

Joined Apr 28, 2012
3,702
I use NVIDIA coolers for 20W white LEDs. They do not even turn warm.
I have archieved a cost of 35 cents/Watt here.

Small scale, not bulk components.

There are no issues so far, I use the installation permanently.

Obviously, you need to use thermal grease all over the LED backplane.

These fans are tolerant, can run at higher voltage if need be.
Expected lifetime is 40,000 hours.

They mainly fail from dust accumulating between the magnet and the coils.
 

Attachments

Thread Starter

abhaymv

Joined Aug 6, 2011
105
That's definitely new info, thank you! Am I correct in assuming thermal grease alone wouldn't help in sticking? Also, if I cannot get a particular brand, what do I call silicone putty? What should I ask for, I mean?
 
Top