is-quantum-communication-faster-than-the-speed-of-light?

xox

Joined Sep 8, 2017
936
So why do you think Einstein called it Spooky action at a distance?
Because he thought it was rubbish. It violated the very cornerstone of Relativity, that nothing can exceed the speed of light.


Also, how do you explain the actual mechanism behind how the two particles are able to break down into the same state when they are very far away from each other?
Every mechanism of physics ultimately arises from the conservation of some quantity. In the case of "quantum entanglement" (a horrible misnomer IMO) that happens to be angular momentum. These conservation laws are ultimately just rules of symmetry which in turn can be described mathematically with Lie algebras.

The takeaway here is that entanglement occurs at the moment of interaction and any measurements made afterward will be perforce correlated. As with all of the laws of physics, it obeys symmetry. There is no "action at a distance" involved whatsoever.
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,677
@xox The mystery is not the correlation. It is the fact that a measurement on one of the particles changes the results of a subsequent measurement on the other one. It is way more complicated than you think.
 

xox

Joined Sep 8, 2017
936
@xox The mystery is not the correlation. It is the fact that a measurement on one of the particles changes the results of a subsequent measurement on the other one. It is way more complicated than you think.

The two particles are in a state of quantum superposition, meaning their wave functions add together as the terms of a Fourier series. And because phase/spin is necessarily symmetrically conserved it will therefore be governed by the some Lie algebra. In the case of the electric interactions, that would be the unitary circle group U(1). No measurement can violate the skew symmetry nor the Jacobian identity of that system. When you perform a measurement on either one of the two particles, the polarization of the other is revealed due to this very property of Lie groups.
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
The two particles are in a state of quantum superposition, meaning their wave functions add together as the terms of a Fourier series. And because phase/spin is necessarily symmetrically conserved it will therefore be governed by the some Lie algebra. In the case of the electric interactions, that would be the unitary circle group U(1). No measurement can violate the skew symmetry nor the Jacobian identity of that system. When you perform a measurement on either one of the two particles, the polarization of the other is revealed due to this very property of Lie groups.
Hi,

Thanks, but i dont think you are really explaining it here.
If there is water flowing into a 10 gallon tank we can say that for sure it can not hold more than 10 gallons so that is a limit. But that does not explain how or why the water is flowing, nor where the water is coming from.
If we had a 10 gallon tank that could expand with pressure, we could fit more water into that tank than the more standard tank.

By stating a limit, we simply assume that the new idea must observe that limit also. In the second case above it does not have to even though in the first it does, and must, and with no exceptions.
In general what we need is to know is the exact mechanism in which the 'apparent' communication (i am qualifying it because of the previous anti posts and because it may not be a settled issue yet) is happening.

Here is a link that is quasi related to what we were talking about previously but i think directly related to the main topic of this thread.
https://www.uni-goettingen.de/en/3240.html?id=6192
Briefly, i think the possibility of the use of solitons in FTL travel.
 
Last edited:

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
@xox The mystery is not the correlation. It is the fact that a measurement on one of the particles changes the results of a subsequent measurement on the other one. It is way more complicated than you think.
Hi,

I believe it must be as you say because if it were not why would anybody else be working on the study of this phenomenon.
 

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,530
Hi,

Thanks, but i dont think you are really explaining it here.
If there is water flowing into a 10 gallon tank we can say that for sure it can not hold more than 10 gallons so that is a limit. But that does not explain how or why the water is flowing, nor where the water is coming from.
If we had a 10 gallon tank that could expand with pressure, we could fit more water into that tank than the more standard tank.

By stating a limit, we simply assume that the new idea must observe that limit also. In the second case above it does not have to even though in the first it does, and must, and with no exceptions.
In general what we need is to know is the exact mechanism in which the 'apparent' communication (i am qualifying it because of the previous anti posts and because it may not be a settled issue yet) is happening.

Here is a link that is quasi related to what we were talking about previously but i think directly related to the main topic of this thread.
https://www.uni-goettingen.de/en/3240.html?id=6192
Briefly, i think the possibility of the use of solitons in FTL travel.
The energy requirements to only light speed are practically infinite as you would expect for mass moving at c. This paper is about sublight warp but at a absolute minimum, you have to cancel the mass of the ship to have any hope to go FTL so now you have an impossible negative energy requirement.
Currently, the amount of energy required for this new type of space propulsion drive is still immense. Lentz explains, “The energy required for this drive travelling at light speed encompassing a spacecraft of 100 meters in radius is on the order of hundreds of times of the mass of the planet Jupiter.
You just take a jump to the left... and then a step to the right.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2105.03079
Three very recent articles have claimed that it is possible to, at least in theory, either set up positive energy warp drives satisfying the weak energy condition (WEC), or at the very least, to minimize the WEC violations. These claims are at best incomplete, since the arguments presented only demonstrate the existence of one set of timelike observers, the co-moving Eulerian observers, who see "nice" physics. While these observers might see a positive energy density, the WEC requires all timelike observers to see positive energy density. Therefore, one should revisit this issue. A more careful analysis shows that the situation is actually much grimmer than advertised -- all physically reasonable warp drives will violate the null energy condition, and so also automatically violate the WEC, and both the strong and dominant energy conditions. While warp drives are certainly interesting examples of speculative physics, the violation of the energy conditions, at least within the framework of standard general relativity, is unavoidable. Even in modified gravity, physically reasonable warp drives will still violate the purely geometrical null convergence condition and the timelike convergence condition which, in turn, will place very strong constraints on any modified-gravity warp drive.
 
Last edited:

xox

Joined Sep 8, 2017
936
Thanks, but i dont think you are really explaining it here.

If there is water flowing into a 10 gallon tank we can say that for sure it can not hold more than 10 gallons so that is a limit. But that does not explain how or why the water is flowing, nor where the water is coming from.

If we had a 10 gallon tank that could expand with pressure, we could fit more water into that tank than the more standard tank.

By stating a limit, we simply assume that the new idea must observe that limit also. In the second case above it does not have to even though in the first it does, and must, and with no exceptions.

In general what we need is to know is the exact mechanism in which the 'apparent' communication (i am qualifying it because of the previous anti posts and because it may not be a settled issue yet) is happening.
That is a fairly weak analogy. What has it got to do with "spooky action at a distance" anyway? What you seem to be claiming is that a particle can somehow interact with its entangled twin instantaneously. Which implies that space itself is non-existent. Because indeed, if it takes no time at all to go from A to B then you must already be there!

But that is not what is happening here. The spin we are measuring can be manipulated with 2x2 unitary matrices which obey all of the properties of a Lie group. Apply a transformation and the result is still an eigenvalue of the system. That will always hold true.

Of course the act of measurement must be done carefully and requires very sophisticated equipment. You can't just measure the spin of an entangled particle miles away through air for example and then predict the counter-spin of its twin. A sensitive apperatus under the right conditions however could.

Here is a link that is quasi related to what we were talking about previously but i think directly related to the main topic of this thread.

https://www.uni-goettingen.de/en/3240.html?id=6192

Briefly, i think the possibility of the use of solitons in FTL travel.
These kinds of papers can't exactly be described as evidence-based science. It's science-fiction repackaged as some sort of meta-science. (The wierder the better?)

In addition, the solitons (warp bubbles) were configured to contain a region with minimal tidal forces such that the passing of time inside the soliton matches the time outside: an ideal environment for a spacecraft. This means there would not be the complications of the so-called “twin paradox” whereby one twin travelling near the speed of light would age much more slowly than the other twin who stayed on Earth: in fact, according to the recent equations both twins would be the same age when reunited.
Just dash aside Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity (which by the way has never been disproven AFAIK). We now have FTL travel with no time-dilation. You might as well throw in some unicorns! I mean really...
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
That is a fairly weak analogy. What has it got to do with "spooky action at a distance" anyway? What you seem to be claiming is that a particle can somehow interact with its entangled twin instantaneously. Which implies that space itself is non-existent. Because indeed, if it takes no time at all to go from A to B then you must already be there!

But that is not what is happening here. The spin we are measuring can be manipulated with 2x2 unitary matrices which obey all of the properties of a Lie group. Apply a transformation and the result is still an eigenvalue of the system. That will always hold true.

Of course the act of measurement must be done carefully and requires very sophisticated equipment. You can't just measure the spin of an entangled particle miles away through air for example and then predict the counter-spin of its twin. A sensitive apperatus under the right conditions however could.



These kinds of papers can't exactly be described as evidence-based science. It's science-fiction repackaged as some sort of meta-science. (The wierder the better?)



Just dash aside Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity (which by the way has never been disproven AFAIK). We now have FTL travel with no time-dilation. You might as well throw in some unicorns! I mean really...
Hi,

Ok thanks, but since you are disagreeing with all of his work i then am forced to ask, what research experiments have you done in the past?
Also, i dont think anyone is claiming to have done this already so you are disagreeing with a conjecture of a sort which just like the conjecture itself is always going to be speculative.
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
The energy requirements to only light speed are practically infinite as you would expect for mass moving at c. This paper is about sublight warp but at a absolute minimum, you have to cancel the mass of the ship to have any hope to go FTL so now you have an impossible negative energy requirement.

You just take a jump to the left... and then a step to the right.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2105.03079
Hello again,

Did you read the whole article? Wasnt he talking about not needing negative energy? And it was also mentioned that there would have to be found a way to lower the 'regular' energy requirement. I dont see how anyone can disagree with something that isnt actually done yet or stated as absolutely true.
If he says "maybe this will work" and you say "maybe it will not work" then you both said the same thing, glass half full vs glass half empty.
If on the other hand he says "maybe this will work" and you say "it will not work" then you really are psychic :) unless you did every possible experiment that can possibly come in the future and found that none of them work. You cant use the laws of the past you may miss something.


But i dont think we will ever agree 100 percent on this topic. That's just the way things are.
But if you have any independent research to add that would be good to hear about.
 

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,530
Hello again,

Did you read the whole article? Wasnt he talking about not needing negative energy? And it was also mentioned that there would have to be found a way to lower the 'regular' energy requirement. I dont see how anyone can disagree with something that isnt actually done yet or stated as absolutely true.
If he says "maybe this will work" and you say "maybe it will not work" then you both said the same thing, glass half full vs glass half empty.
If on the other hand he says "maybe this will work" and you say "it will not work" then you really are psychic :) unless you did every possible experiment that can possibly come in the future and found that none of them work. You cant use the laws of the past you may miss something.


But i dont think we will ever agree 100 percent on this topic. That's just the way things are.
But if you have any independent research to add that would be good to hear about.
This is going way off topic from QM information misconceptions.

You don't need to be psychic to know you would pick (others saw this crap long ago and dismissed it) a FTL paper from last year that's already been shown to be crap by others in the field.

Sure, that's what he said in the paper (I read the paper, not the also misleading article) but anyone who reads the paper realized it was a slight of hand designed for pop-sci distribution. He fine-tunes non-physical conditions to make a solution that requires unknown and undefined optimization to turn the results from impossible to merely ludicrous black-hole scale engineering. The soliton solutions are are capable of superluminal motion (nothing new here lots of things can have apparent superluminal changes) per his paper but since soliton solutions have no drive capabilities for physical objects with mass the actual ship goes nowhere or at best sub-light from some other power source.

From New Scientist:
Contrary to what its name may suggest, a warp drive isn’t really an engine. Rather, it is a bubble of space-time protected by a shell of matter in which the fundamental properties inside the shell can differ from those outside. Without an added mode of propulsion, warp drives don’t move through space on their own, but, in theory, some types could break the speed of light, moving faster than this by stretching and compressing space-time around them.
"I don't see how anyone can disagree with something that isn't actually done yet"
Is this is a joke? Could you could say the same for the EMdrive, that been proven, finally to be a fraud.

The real soliton solution.
https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Soliton_wave
1657808755892.png
 
Last edited:

xox

Joined Sep 8, 2017
936
Ok thanks, but since you are disagreeing with all of his work i then am forced to ask, what research experiments have you done in the past?
Well I did duplicate the double-slit experiment when I was around 13 or so. I also witnessed many interesting experiments growing up in the lectures halls of the U of H and also Rice University where a relative of mine taught. I've seen holograms generated by lasers (which by the way is a classic example of entanglement). I've even seen water converted to gas then burned as a fuel and then conclusive experiments conducted to prove that it cannot be done without an excess of input energy. (In other words, it is more efficient to power a device directly with electricity than it is to use that electricity to convert water to a burnable mixture of gases.)

So I am not by any means unfamiliar with the process. The double-slit experiment in fact solidified my agreement with De Broglie that "everything is wave". Particles are really just bundles of standing waves.

It was an incredible realization for me. I also played football at the time so imagine the awkwardness of getting into a debate with one of your teammates about whether or not everything is made of waves! It could really be frustrating sometimes. Outside of scouting and football, I was more inclined to listen to lectures or read a book. No interest in primetime television, smash hits radio, video games or the like. Even as a child my favorite shows were things like Mutual of Omaha's Wild Kingdom or something. (And for some odd reason, the MacNeil-Lehrer News Hour - I think I just enjoyed listening to their conversations.)

Also, i dont think anyone is claiming to have done this already so you are disagreeing with a conjecture of a sort which just like the conjecture itself is always going to be speculative.
That is the problem with taking a philosophical/metaphysical approach to physics (as many interpretations of quantum mechanics do). Too much speculation and not enough evidence.

If you were to measure an entangled particle and found that it was NOT correlated with the spin of its twin, then the properties of the Lie group would be violated. Try it yourself! Consider the Lie algebra over matrices of the following form:

| a b |
| c -a |

No matter what transformation you perform, the state will always be constrained to perfectly aligned eigenvectors.

In the same way, it is categorically impossible for the wave-functions of particles to NOT be correlated. Because if that were indeed the case, the foundations of physics would quite literally crumble to the sea. Noether's Theorem would be false and every single one of the laws of conservation would be called into question. My "conjecture" can be easily proven by way of induction and contradiction. If you disagree then please present a counter-argument which properly refutes what I have said.
 
Last edited:

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
Well I did duplicate the double-slit experiment when I was around 13 or so. I also witnessed many interesting experiments growing up in the lectures halls of the U of H and also Rice University where a relative of mine taught. I've seen holograms generated by lasers (which by the way is a classic example of entanglement). I've even seen water converted to gas then burned as a fuel and then conclusive experiments conducted to prove that it cannot be done without an excess of input energy. (In other words, it is more efficient to power a device directly with electricity than it is to use that electricity to convert water to a burnable mixture of gases.)

So I am not by any means unfamiliar with the process. The double-slit experiment in fact solidified my agreement with De Broglie that "everything is wave". Particles are really just bundles of standing waves.

It was an incredible realization for me. I also played football at the time so imagine the awkwardness of getting into a debate with one of your teammates about whether or not everything is made of waves! It could really be frustrating sometimes. Outside of scouting and football, I was more inclined to listen to lectures or read a book. No interest in primetime television, smash hits radio, video games or the like. Even as a child my favorite shows were things like Mutual of Omaha's Wild Kingdom or something. (And for some odd reason, the MacNeil-Lehrer News Hour - I think I just enjoyed listening to their conversations.)



That is the problem with taking a philosophical/metaphysical approach to physics (as many interpretations of quantum mechanics do). Too much speculation and not enough evidence.

If you were to measure an entangled particle and found that it was NOT correlated with the spin of its twin, then the properties of the Lie group would be violated. Try it yourself! Consider the Lie algebra over matrices of the following form:

| a b |
| c -a |

No matter what transformation you perform, the state will always be constrained to perfectly aligned eigenvectors.

In the same way, it is categorically impossible for the wave-functions of particles to NOT be correlated. Because if that were indeed the case, the foundations of physics would quite literally crumble to the sea. Noether's Theorem would be false and every single one of the laws of conservation would be called into question. My "conjecture" can be easily proven by way of induction and contradiction. If you disagree then please present a counter-argument which properly refutes what I have said.
Hi,

That sounds interesting and it's cool that you did the two slit experiment yourself. If you feel so strongly about this then you should really be notifying the person/people who reported that information in the last link i sent. If you have considered all things, then the person who talked about using other methods to do it would be proved wrong and so they should just go to bed.

But since you are so into it, do you have any theory on what the model for the collapse of the wave function might be? Or do you have your own model perhaps? Thanks.
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
This is going way off topic from QM information misconceptions.

You don't need to be psychic to know you would pick (others saw this crap long ago and dismissed it) a FTL paper from last year that's already been shown to be crap by others in the field.

Sure, that's what he said in the paper (I read the paper, not the also misleading article) but anyone who reads the paper realized it was a slight of hand designed for pop-sci distribution. He fine-tunes non-physical conditions to make a solution that requires unknown and undefined optimization to turn the results from impossible to merely ludicrous black-hole scale engineering. The soliton solutions are are capable of superluminal motion (nothing new here lots of things can have apparent superluminal changes) per his paper but since soliton solutions have no drive capabilities for physical objects with mass the actual ship goes nowhere or at best sub-light from some other power source.

From New Scientist:

"I don't see how anyone can disagree with something that isn't actually done yet"
Is this is a joke? Could you could say the same for the EMdrive, that been proven, finally to be a fraud.

The real soliton solution.
https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Soliton_wave
View attachment 271450

Hello again,

Well sometimes it seems like you are assuming more than i am or misconstruing what is being said. You have to remember that this can happen a lot on the web in forums. I'll quote both you and i here...

START QUOTES
Me: "I don't see how anyone can disagree with something that isn't actually done yet"
You: Is this is a joke? Could you could say the same for the EMdrive, that been proven, finally to be a fraud.
END QUOTES
The key word here is "finally". If that is true, then it took time to prove it was not something that was known immediately.
Not that it is a very bad point though, because some things we are hopeful about dont actually happen. In that context i can understand your concern. As i said to xox though, you should really be talking to the people who come up with these new ideas if you feel that strongly about it. Maybe contact the author of the link i provided. I dont think i could affect that so even if you outright proved anything to me using solid quantum mechanics and anything else you might come up with it would not change a thing. You'd have to tell them and hash it out with them. That would help i think as then other readers would be able to see both sides of the discussion.

BTW i have read about 'new' types of batteries for some years now but still havent seen one on the market yet that is viable for everyday use.
Also, electric cars are supposed to be so much better than gas vehicles yet there is a HUGE problem with charging stations that is not being addressed properly yet. Double lines of cars waiting to charge, broken chargers, etc. Will electric cars eventually bite the dust? It's hard to say there are hundreds of thousands of them being produced and shipped. All we can do is wait and see.
 

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,530
IMO there is no physical phenomenon that could be called the collapse (A Copenhagen Interpretation, “Wave function collapse” isn’t physics.). Imagine looking for a person somewhere on the Strip in Vegas. That persons wave function - that could have included possible positions at many other places - suddenly "collapses" because we learned about the persons position by some classical means of measurement like our eyes. It's all about what we know, when we know, there is no physical wave function collapse by some sort of divine intervention but you can take your pick of interpretations.

http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2013/01/17/the-most-embarrassing-graph-in-modern-physics/
The Most Embarrassing Graph in Modern Physics

1657885985443.png
 
Last edited:

xox

Joined Sep 8, 2017
936
Well sometimes it seems like you are assuming more than i am or misconstruing what is being said. You have to remember that this can happen a lot on the web in forums. I'll quote both you and i here...



START QUOTES


Me: "I don't see how anyone can disagree with something that isn't actually done yet"


You: Is this is a joke? Could you could say the same for the EMdrive, that been proven, finally to be a fraud.


END QUOTES


The key word here is "finally". If that is true, then it took time to prove it was not something that was known immediately.

When Einstein speculated that time itself is not absolute, before it had been proven, many people were very skeptical. But then it was verified by experiment and there was no question about it. So what you have presented is not one, but several extraordinary claims. What if I were to tell you that, right now Burt Bacharach is at your door playing a piano with a bear wearing an "MrAI Rocks!" hat? Surely each of those things are in and of themselves individually possible to one degree or another. But what are the chances of all those things happening at once? Same goes for soliton "theory". There just isn't much (if any) experimental evidence to back it up.


you should really be talking to the people who come up with these new ideas if you feel that strongly about it. Maybe contact the author of the link i provided. I dont think i could affect that so even if you outright proved anything to me using solid quantum mechanics and anything else you might come up with it would not change a thing. You'd have to tell them and hash it out with them. That would help i think as then other readers would be able to see both sides of the discussion.

Those authors most likely couldn't care less to hear that their theories might be wrong. They want to see their books on the shelves of Barnes and Noble, to charge $250 per guest to give a talk on quantum mechanics, to project the image that they are some kind of ambassador of quantum weirdness or something. The things which I have pointed out are well known in the scientific community. Analyzing the properties of Lie algebras however is frankly dry and boring. Talk about multi-dimensional holographic quantum computers and suddenly there is funding and promotion. Same goes for solitons. It's just more apt to "sell" ad content....


BTW i have read about 'new' types of batteries for some years now but still havent seen one on the market yet that is viable for everyday use.


Also, electric cars are supposed to be so much better than gas vehicles yet there is a HUGE problem with charging stations that is not being addressed properly yet. Double lines of cars waiting to charge, broken chargers, etc. Will electric cars eventually bite the dust? It's hard to say there are hundreds of thousands of them being produced and shipped. All we can do is wait and see.

Those issues IMO seem more a matter of refinement. We do need faster charging times and higher energy density. In time we will get there, in five to ten years perhaps.
 
Last edited:

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
When Einstein speculated that time itself is not absolute, before it had been proven, many people were very skeptical. But then it was verified by experiment and there was no question about it. So what you have presented is not one, but several extraordinary claims. What if I were to tell you that, right now Burt Bacharach is at your door playing a piano with a bear wearing an "MrAI Rocks!" hat? Surely each of those things are in and of themselves individually possible to one degree or another. But what are the chances of all those things happening at once? Same goes for soliton "theory". There just isn't much (if any) experimental evidence to back it up.





Those authors most likely couldn't care less to hear that their theories might be wrong. They want to see their books on the shelves of Barnes and Noble, to charge $250 per guest to give a talk on quantum mechanics, to project the image that they are some kind of ambassador of quantum weirdness or something. The things which I have pointed out are well known in the scientific community. Analyzing the properties of Lie algebras however is frankly dry and boring. Talk about multi-dimensional holographic quantum computers and suddenly there is funding and promotion. Same goes for solitons. It's just more apt to "sell" ad content....





Those issues IMO seem more a matter of refinement. We do need faster charging times and higher energy density. In time we will get there, in five to ten years perhaps.
Hello,

Well it's hard to make up a parallel argument and then say the degree of skepticism matches that of the actual real life predicament.
You probably heard the parallel argument about God vs The Flying Spaghetti Monster (ha ha) but let's not go there.
How about the one where a huge number of monkeys typing on a huge number of typewriters eventually type out the entire works of William Shakespeare, or just Hamlet.

I guess i have to say that after all is said and done by reviewing the way history has changed physics in the past, i believe it is not possible to use current understanding to predict what may come in the future. In fact i can draw up a relationship which i believe to be true for the most part.

That is, the more 'concrete' a property is today the longer it takes to revise it. This means that i would reject all arguments that try to predict anything that puts a limit on what can happen no matter how squarely they are set in theory. This means that i dont care if 1000 Einsteins and 1000 Richard Feynman's come up with 1000 theories that are accepted TODAY by every single physicist on earth TODAY i will still wait for the future to unfold in order to be sure, and since the future represents a very very long span of time, that means that even after 1 trillion years if i were to be able to be still alive and kicking, i still would wait a longer time.

So now maybe you can see what you are up against if you or anyone else on earth today wants to convince me of anything else that "could absolutely not happen". This is probably the only thing i am this stubborn about.
It could be in part because i have seen so many engineering examples where this and that can not be done, and then a week later it's done because somebody with a better idea came up with something that worked all of a sudden with no warning it was coming and thought to be completely impossible.
"Nothing can travel faster than the speed of light". So ok then double the transmission path and you double the data rate, speed of light becomes moot.

Within a timeless context "Impossible" is a property of the mind, not of the universe.
 

Thread Starter

Wendy

Joined Mar 24, 2008
23,869
I am surprised that measuring quantum entanglement survives Heisenberg's principle. It is indeed possible there is quantum entanglement was FTL it might run into that principle.

If trying to send information via quantum entanglement you might lose the entanglement.

Only time and further experiments will tell.
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,677
You do lose the entanglement once a measurement is done on both of particles. You need a new pair of entangled particles fir each bit transmitted.

About what we might discover in the future.

Lord Kelvin stated in 1897 that there was no new physics to be discovered. Which is pretty incredible since no one could explain why the sun had not yet burned out. The place you will find new physics is where we either we have no theory, or the theory does not agree with observations. Neither of these is the case with quantum entanglement and communication via it.
 

nsaspook

Joined Aug 27, 2009
16,530
I am surprised that measuring quantum entanglement survives Heisenberg's principle. It is indeed possible there is quantum entanglement was FTL it might run into that principle.

If trying to send information via quantum entanglement you might lose the entanglement.

Only time and further experiments will tell.
1657988187966.png
Where did you learn that?
https://flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf
As long as the two particles are entangled and described by a single wave function, it is impossible to do an experiment on two pieces of the system through which we can violate the uncertainty principle.
The sleight-of-hand is that the term "measurement" is never defined. Of course,
this is not news. The fact that measurement is such a crucial part of the theory
but is nowhere reflected in the mathematics has long been the cause of varying
degrees of uneasiness. Einstein, of course, was the most uneasy of all, demanding
through the EPR "paradox" to see what was in the magician's other hand [1]. John
Bell, in a stroke of uncommon genius, figured out how to open the magician's
hand to show that it was, in fact, empty [2]. The hidden variables had truly
disappeared. The QM magician was vindicated, the mysteries endure, and the
philosophical arguments over such things as whether cats qualify as conscious
observers endure along with them. But because philosophical dilemmas do not
challenge the scientific standing of the theory, and because matters as they stand
are the source of so much good clean fun, the world has been largely content to
obey the admonition to pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.
Unfortunately, it turns out that the story of QM has a fatal flaw. Not QM itself,
mind you, but the story, the patter that goes along with the theory. In particular,
the idea of measurement as described in the QM story leads directly to a physical
impossibility, specifically faster-than-light communication. To see this we have to
begin by reviewing the QM story
"Two monks were arguing about a flag. One said, "The flag is moving." The other said, "The wind is moving." The sixth patriarch, Zeno, happened to be passing by. He told them, "Not the wind, not the flag. Mind is moving.""

Most of the peer-reviewed published articles are about post-quantum cryptography because quantum cryptography 'uses' quantum entanglement to communicate via a classical securely. We don't need QM for unbreakable communications via a One-time pad but QM provides a capability to see if the OTP key has been compromised as any measurement (snooping) destroys the entanglement.
Quantum and post-quantum cryptography[edit]
A common use of the one-time pad in quantum cryptography is being used in association with Quantum Key Distribution (QKD). QKD is typically associated with the one-time pad because it provides a way of distributing a long shared secret key securely and efficiently (assuming the existence of practical quantum networking hardware). A QKD algorithm uses properties of quantum mechanical systems to let 2 parties agree on a shared, uniformly random string. Algorithms for QKD, such as BB84 are also able to determine whether an adversarial party has been attempting to intercept key material, and allow for a shared secret key to be agreed upon with relatively few messages exchanged and relatively low computational overhead. At a high level, the schemes work by taking advantage of the destructive way quantum states are measured to exchange a secret and detect tampering. In the original BB84 paper, it was proven that the one-time pad, with keys distributed via QKD is a perfectly secure encryption scheme.[25] However, this result depends on the QKD scheme being implemented correctly in practice. Attacks on real-world QKD systems exist. For instance, many systems do not send a single photon (or other object in the desired quantum state) per bit of the key because of practical limitations, and an attacker could intercept and measure some of the photons associated with a message, gaining information about the key (i.e. leaking information about the pad), while passing along unmeasured photons corresponding to the same bit of the key.[26] Combining QKD with a one-time pad can also loosen the requirements for key reuse. In 1982, Bennett and Brassard showed that if a QKD protocol does not detect that an adversary was trying to intercept an exchanged key, than the key can safely be reused while preserving perfect secrecy.[27]

There also exists a quantum analogue of the one time pad, which can be used to exchange quantum states along a one-way quantum channel with perfect secrecy, which is sometimes used in quantum computing. It can be shown that a shared secret of at least 2n classical bits is required to exchange an n-qubit quantum state along a one-way quantum channel (by analogue with the result that a key of n bits is required to exchange an n bit message with perfect secrecy). A scheme proposed in 2000 achieves this bound. One way to implement this quantum one-time pad is by dividing the 2n bit key into n pairs of bits. To encrypt the state, for each pair of bits i in the key, one would apply an X gate to qubit i of the state if and only if the first bit of the pair is 1, and apply a Z gate to qubit i of the state if and only if the second bit of the pair is 1. Decryption involves applying this transformation again, since X and Z are their own inverses. This can be shown to be perfectly secret in a quantum setting.[28]

The one-time pad is an example of post-quantum cryptography, because perfect secrecy is a definition of security that does not depend on the computational resources of the adversary. Consequently, an adversary with a quantum computer would still not be able to gain any more information about a message encrypted with a one time pad than an adversary with just a classical computer.
 
Top