In this circuit, is it possible to switch a BC547 Transistor with a 2n2222a Transitor?

Janis59

Joined Aug 21, 2017
1,894
RE:""Could you define exactly what you mean by "better" please?""
As the Multivibrator concept works well practically on EVERY kind of components, from 1950 elaborated russian MP14 until high-power 2N3055 (bit adjusting the resistor values), from russian kt315, 361, 3107, 3102 to beta factor variable 2n2222 or 300 MHz able BC547, low noise BC549, and this list may include even thousands of any other immagineable bjt~s or even jFET~s/MOSfets. More, this circuit works well even at so high as 100 MHz with proper F(T) transistor or more. It works well even at minutes long pulses, with proper jfet and electrolytes, it works well even at 1200 Volt Vcc if harsh need and is capable to work even from 1 Volt Vcc if germanium. Actually much more productive ought be questions - do there at all exist a transistor with which this circuit is unable to work.
 

recklessrog

Joined May 23, 2013
985
RE:""Could you define exactly what you mean by "better" please?""
As the Multivibrator concept works well practically on EVERY kind of components, from 1950 elaborated russian MP14 until high-power 2N3055 (bit adjusting the resistor values), from russian kt315, 361, 3107, 3102 to beta factor variable 2n2222 or 300 MHz able BC547, low noise BC549, and this list may include even thousands of any other immagineable bjt~s or even jFET~s/MOSfets. More, this circuit works well even at so high as 100 MHz with proper F(T) transistor or more. It works well even at minutes long pulses, with proper jfet and electrolytes, it works well even at 1200 Volt Vcc if harsh need and is capable to work even from 1 Volt Vcc if germanium. Actually much more productive ought be questions - do there at all exist a transistor with which this circuit is unable to work.
I was asking be80be to quantify what he meant by the statement "output is better." How is it "better" what does "better" mean???
 

ericgibbs

Joined Jan 29, 2010
21,641
hi,
Moderation:
The TS has not posted back since Monday.
I would say that we all have our own preferences for using a particular transistor type in a project, when any number of transistor types would do the job just as well.

I would suggest rather than using the TS's Thread to discuss this Topic in more detail, one of the posters Creates a new Thread.?

Eric
 
Last edited:

be80be

Joined Jul 5, 2008
2,396
LOL
The output to my scope with the diodes is cleaner

The 2n3904 looked better to with the parts theTS posted the 2n2222 was picking up noise from my monitors
 

nivar

Joined Jan 21, 2011
1


I am currently trying to build this oscillator circuit for a project at school, but we don't have any BC547 transistors available. We do however have many 2n2222a transistors. Can I switch the transistors or modify the 2n2222a's to make the circuit work?
Yes it should work perfectly . I think any NPN transistor which is having a 'beta' more than say 30 should work without any problems . You can use 2N2222, 2N3904 etc . Judging by the RC time constant of your circuit I presume it is a low frequency multivibrator only and it should readily work with any of the above NPN transistors.
 

OBW0549

Joined Mar 2, 2015
3,565
Actually much more productive ought be questions - do there at all exist a transistor with which this circuit is unable to work.
That's a good point; I can't think of any.

I do recall that about ≈50 years ago I considered using some high-voltage silicon transistors (RCA made them, IIRC) in one design, but abandoned the idea because their hFE was extremely low-- somewhere around 5. But among today's transistors, I think it would be extremely hard to find one that wouldn't work.
 
Top