Ensuring SMD resistors wattage not exceeded

Thread Starter

sotpotatis

Joined Jun 25, 2022
5
Hey, I am changing out my PCB to use SMD resistors instead of THT resistors.
I am fairly new to electronics.

Schematics:
1754492008676.png

The SMD resistors I plan to use are different values of the JLCPCB Basic Part UNI-ROYAL 0805 resistors, for example this one: https://jlcpcb.com/partdetail/18159-0805W8F1500T5E/C17471.

The resistor I linked is rated at 125mW, I want to check that I don't exceed the maximum wattage rating.
I read on this website: https://www.electronics-tutorials.ws/resistor/res_7.html
"it is always better to select a particular size resistor that is capable of dissipating two or more times the calculated power". So I need to check that the power across my resistors are not greater than 75mW.

Circuit will be powered with 5V (USB-C).

To save the pain of needing to check all resistors, here is what I did:

I have some resistors (for example the pullup resistors) that will have a voltage drop of 5V.
So in worst case the voltage drop across a resistor is 5V.

As P=V^2/R where V is the voltage drop across the resistor: The only resistors that would need some more careful calculations (in terms of their actual voltage drop) are those with
R<=(5^2)/(75*10^-3)=333.3...
as the maximum power should be 75mW and the maximum voltage across any resistor would be 5V.

This means that I need to double check any resistor below about 333Ohm - I have 150Ohm (R2-R6) resistors and a 10Ohm resistor (R8) that are in the danger zone.

1) Calculations for R8
If we look at R8, voltage only passes through it when SW1 is closed. It passes from VCC=5V through R7 and R8:

I = 5/(R7+R8)

VR7 (voltage over resistor R7)=R7*I=R7*(5/(R7+R8))=2.2×10^3×(5)/(2.2×10^3+10)=4.977 V

So no need to worry about R8, the voltage over it is 0.02V - the power over it is (0.02^2)/10=0.04mW.

2) Calculations for R2-R6

Regarding this part of the circuit. I am using a technique called Charlieplexing, meaning at any instantaneous moment, I will only have ONE of the LEDs (D1-15) turned on at a time. Two of the PB0-1/PA7-PA5 pins are set to output high and the other to output low. Others are floating. Led forward voltage is min 1.8V.
Pin logic level is =VCC.

As the resistor values are the same, their voltage drop is also the same, so (5-1.8)/2=1.6V drop over each 150Ohm resistor.

So the power over each resistor (1.6^2)/150=17mW

Therefore no need to worry about the resistor wattage being exceeded.

My question is basically if my reasoning is correct and I indeed don't need to worry. I don't have enough electronics experience to trust myself.
 

MrChips

Joined Oct 2, 2009
34,778
You have three values, I, V, and R interrelated by Ohm's Law. You only need two of the three values to calculate power.

I is the current through the resistor.
V is the voltage across the resistor.
R is the value of the resistance.

Power = I x V
Power = V x V / R
Power = I x I x R

Multiply the result by 1.5 to 2 to find the appropriately sized wattage.

Here is a Resistor Wattage Chart. Choose the next higher wattage resistor than the one indicated by the chart.

1754494106419.png

Resistor values are shown along the straight lines on the chart.
For example, suppose R = 100 Ω (second straight line from the bottom)
Now suppose the voltage across R = 5V (see the vertical scale on the left side of the chart)
The current through the resistor = V / R = 50 mA
The power dissipation meets the ¼ W curved line.
Choose a ½ W resistor.

Now, if the current is less than 25 mA, i.e. voltage is less than 2.5 V, a 1/8 W resistor will be ok.
 

du00000001

Joined Nov 10, 2020
189
You are welcome to draw it in yourself.
I have newer used 1/16 W resistors when 1/8 W resistors and higher wattage work fine for me.
Some of my colleagues always go for the smallest parts available. Just to find out these suffer from overload :-(
I also had cases where I had to go for resistors rated less than 1/8 W - due to extreme space restrictions.
 

panic mode

Joined Oct 10, 2011
4,968
I am fairly new to electronics. ... My question is basically if my reasoning is correct and I indeed don't need to worry.
Your reasoning is fine. You will be ok...

Btw. since you are looking at JLC for parts, you must be using (or going to use) their assembly services. So keep in mind that resistors are dirt cheap so don't be shy to use two or even more of them as a substitute for single extended part.
for example if you needed 150 Ohm that is over 125mW, you could use two 75 Ohm resistors in series or two 300 Ohm resistors in parallel.

and same goes for capacitors. using more than one capacitor in parallel is commonly used in many cases - usually intentionally.
 
Top