Does a Current Through a Resistor Cause a Voltage Across That Resistor or Does a Voltage Across a Resistor Cause a Current To Flow Though It?

I think since we are going to assume everything is semantics and some people are using personal definitions then this entire thread doesn't matter.

btw, the difference between emf and voltage is explained on countless articles on the web.
 
Last edited:

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,513
'Hey, Grok, Read this thread: https://forum.allaboutcircuits.com/...urrent-to-flow-though-it.211458/#post-2050114

What really comes first, voltage or current?

Personally, I think they are "flip sides of the same coin" and occur together simultaneously.'

**They are simultaneous — two descriptions of the same electromagnetic process.** Your “flip sides of the same coin” view is the right one.

### What the thread is arguing about
MrAl opened with the practical point: Ohm’s law \(V = IR\) is a *relationship*, not a cause-and-effect statement. The two quantities appear together (or so close together that ordinary measurement cannot separate them). He notes that field establishment along a wire takes finite time, but locally the effects are concurrent. For beginners he recommends just teaching the relation and letting people treat either quantity as the “independent” one depending on the circuit.

The replies split roughly into:
- **Voltage/field first** (LvW, Jerry-Hat-Trick, water-head analogies): an electric field is required to exert force on charges, so potential difference is the precondition for current.
- **Abstractions / neither first** (BobTPH, MrChips, kiroma): voltage and current are macroscopic aggregates of charge behavior. Maxwell’s equations treat \(\mathbf{E}\) and \(\mathbf{B}\) as coupled and simultaneous; asking which derivative “comes first” is meaningless.
- **Special cases** (AnalogKid, ElectricSpidey, capacitor examples): induced currents from changing magnetic fields, open-circuit voltage on a capacitor, solar cells, etc., show that you can have one without the other in particular situations.

MrAl’s later posts (especially the long one on page 2) push further: once the local field is present at a point, the charges respond without measurable delay. Macroscopic inertia analogies (compressing a brick before it moves) do not apply cleanly to electrons in a conductor.

### The physics
In the continuum electromagnetic description the situation is self-consistent and simultaneous:

- Voltage between two points is the line integral of the electric field.
- Current density in an ohmic material is \(\mathbf{J} = \sigma\mathbf{E}\) (or more generally the response of free charges to the local fields).
- The fields themselves are produced by the charges and their motions (Gauss, Ampère–Maxwell, Faraday).

When you close a switch, what propagates down the wires is an electromagnetic wave (at a fraction of \(c\)). The electric field, the surface-charge gradient that supports it, and the resulting drift of conduction electrons are all aspects of that single wave. There is no separable “voltage arrives, then current starts” or vice versa at the local scale. In the ideal lumped-circuit model we simply assume the quasi-static limit in which the relationship is instantaneous.

Edge cases exist (a charged capacitor has voltage with zero current; a superconducting loop can have persistent current with zero voltage; a changing external magnetic field can drive current via Faraday’s law), but they do not restore a universal temporal priority inside a resistor.

### Practical teaching view
For ordinary circuit work it is still useful to say:
- A voltage source or potential difference *drives* current through a resistor.
- Current through a resistor *produces* a voltage drop.

Both statements are correct *as descriptions of the relation*; neither is a deeper causal claim. That is exactly why Ohm’s law can be rearranged as \(I = V/R\) or \(V = IR\) without contradiction.

So your intuition matches both MrAl’s conclusion and the structure of Maxwell’s equations: voltage and current through a resistor are concurrent manifestations of the same electromagnetic interaction. The chicken-and-egg debate dissolves once you stop treating them as independent primitives.
 
Last edited:

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
### Practical teaching view
For ordinary circuit work it is still useful to say:
- A voltage source or potential difference *drives* current through a resistor.
- Current through a resistor *produces* a voltage drop.
Yes - of course, I agree. No doubt about it. For practical purposes it does not matter which view is applied - as lomg as we are using correctly the known relation (Ohm).
That`s what we are doing with success since many, many years.

However - as far as I understand, in this thread we are discussing the physical background between both quantities (voltage and current).

So your intuition matches both MrAl’s conclusion and the structure of Maxwell’s equations: voltage and current through a resistor are concurrent manifestations of the same electromagnetic interaction. The chicken-and-egg debate dissolves once you stop treating them as independent primitives.
Of course, I also agree that both (voltager, current) are "concurrent" phenomena in a closed loop with conductive elements. But answers this the question if current can exist without driving voltage?
Up to now - I didn`t see any physical illustrative explanation how a current through a resistor could develop a voltage across the resistor. Which effect then could be the cause of such a current?

Simple circuit: A voltage source Vo (battery) is connected to a resistor R.
We will have a current I=Vo/R.
Does it make sense to say that this current I would generate the voltage Vo ?
Or does such a view can only be applied to a series connection of at least two resistors? If yes, why?
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,513
I didn`t see any physical illustrative explanation how a current through a resistor could develop a voltage across the resistor. Which effect then could be the cause of such a current?
In the special case of a superconductor, a current can flow in the complete absence of an E field. In fact, it's a physical requirement, as dictated by the London equations. The current is driven by a steady-state B field, not an E field. Even impressing a strong E field on a current-carrying superconductor has no effect on the supercurrent.

The dual of this is a capacitor, where the voltage across the plates is established by the E field, in complete absence of a B field.

Simple circuit: A voltage source Vo (battery) is connected to a resistor R.
We will have a current I=Vo/R.
Does it make sense to say that this current I would generate the voltage Vo ?
Or does such a view can only be applied to a series connection of at least two resistors? If yes, why?
I like to think that the ohmic element impresses a back-emf (note: this is not a literal definition of back-emf!) such as to exactly counter the applied V.

In any case, B and E are very closely related -- in fact, they are orthogonal vectors of the same underlying electromagnetic field, and always self-interact simultaneously.
 

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
In the special case of a superconductor, a current can flow in the complete absence of an E field. In fact, it's a physical requirement, as dictated by the London equations. The current is driven by a steady-state B field, not an E field. Even impressing a strong E field on a current-carrying superconductor has no effect on the supercurrent.

The dual of this is a capacitor, where the voltage across the plates is established by the E field, in complete absence of a B field.
Thank you for your answer.
But excuse my question: Is this really the only example which can be presented to illustrate the subject of our dicussion?
Remember, the question was about simple practical circuits involving a voltage source and realistic conductive parts.
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,513
Thank you for your answer.
But excuse my question: Is this really the only example which can be presented to illustrate the subject of our dicussion?
Remember, the question was about simple practical circuits involving a voltage source and realistic conductive parts.
I think your question has been answered, from a deep, physical point-of-view. I'll let Grok provide the final answer, as it is more eloquent than I, but we are in complete agreement:

Thank you for the clarification. You’re right that the original question was about ordinary practical circuits (a voltage source and realistic resistive conductors), not the special case of a superconductor.

In those ordinary circuits the situation is simply this: Ohm’s law is a constitutive relation, not a causal one. For an ohmic resistor the local fields and the current density are locked together by \( \mathbf{J}=\sigma\mathbf{E} \) (or equivalently \( V=IR \)). When the circuit is completed, the electromagnetic wave that establishes the surface-charge gradient (and therefore the electric field) and the drift of the conduction electrons are aspects of the same process. Locally they appear together; there is no measurable delay that would let us assign temporal priority to one over the other.

In a simple battery–resistor loop it is therefore equally valid to say “the source voltage drives the current” or “the current produces the voltage drop across the resistor.” Both statements describe the same steady-state relation. Neither is a deeper physical cause. That is why circuit analysis works equally well with either quantity treated as the independent variable.

The superconductor was only offered as a limiting case that shows what happens when the linking relation \( \mathbf{J}=\sigma\mathbf{E} \) is removed (resistance → 0). In ordinary resistive circuits that relation is present, so voltage and current remain concurrent. For practical purposes the chicken-and-egg question has no further content once Ohm’s law is accepted as the governing relation.

I think that settles the issue for the circuits we actually use.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
Up to now - I didn`t see any physical illustrative explanation how a current through a resistor could develop a voltage across the resistor. Which effect then could be the cause of such a current?

Simple circuit: A voltage source Vo (battery) is connected to a resistor R.
We will have a current I=Vo/R.
Does it make sense to say that this current I would generate the voltage Vo ?
Or does such a view can only be applied to a series connection of at least two resistors? If yes, why?
How about thermal noise in a resistor? Charge carriers move randomly resulting in a random voltage signal. That's easy to explain as a current resulting in a voltage and hard to explain as some voltage from somewhere producing a current.
 

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
How about thermal noise in a resistor? Charge carriers move randomly resulting in a random voltage signal. That's easy to explain as a current resulting in a voltage and hard to explain as some voltage from somewhere producing a current.
I think, that's a completely different effect from the one being discussed here (see the thread title). The definition of the phenomenon we call “current” in electrical circuits is also different, isn't it?
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,513
I think, that's a completely different effect from the one being discussed here (see the thread title). The definition of the phenomenon we call “current” in electrical circuits is also different, isn't it?
Johnson noise is defined as an AC voltage source impressed across a resistor. How is this not equivalent?
 

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
:::::::::::::::::::::::::
In those ordinary circuits the situation is simply this: Ohm’s law is a constitutive relation, not a causal one.
No doubt about it!

For an ohmic resistor the local fields and the current density are locked together by \( \mathbf{J}=\sigma\mathbf{E} \) (or equivalently \( V=IR \)). When the circuit is completed, the electromagnetic wave that establishes the surface-charge gradient (and therefore the electric field) and the drift of the conduction electrons are aspects of the same process. Locally they appear together; there is no measurable delay that would let us assign temporal priority to one over the other.
It is certainly not a matter of semantics when I place importance on word choice and phrasing.
Of course, since both quantities (voltage and current in a closed circuit) are related, one could say that they are "aspects of the same process".
But answers this the question, if one is the necessary precondition for the other one?
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,513
No doubt about it!

It is certainly not a matter of semantics when I place importance on word choice and phrasing.
Of course, since both quantities (voltage and current in a closed circuit) are related, one could say that they are "aspects of the same process".
But answers this the question, if one is the necessary precondition for the other one?
I'm checking out.

I don't know what else to say without repeating myself.
 

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
Johnson noise is defined as an AC voltage source impressed across a resistor. How is this not equivalent?
Johnson noise is defined as an AC voltage source impressed across a resistor. How is this not equivalent?
And what about the currents? Are both currents really comparable in the sense of our discussiin here?
I am still waiting for an example involving practical and real circuits (includig resistors as mentioned in the thread title) which can demonstrate and explain (!) how a current can generate a voltage across a resistor R, similar to the - more or less exact - explanation which shows how and why the E-field enables the movement of charges within the device.
 

MrChips

Joined Oct 2, 2009
35,299
If the objective is to provide a beginner with a basic understanding of the relationship between current and voltage, the best advice I have to offer is: Don't be fixated with either model. Both models are used in circuit theory and analysis.

1794780252200.png
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
In this context, Einsteins words just came into my mind:
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler"

Is it really so complicated as outlined by you?

Would you please answer the following question?
* What is wrong with the following simple statement:
* For a current to flow through a resistor R, a force must act on it, which is generated by the electric field inside the resistor. The necessary condition for the existence of this field (and thus its cause) is an externally applied voltage.

Maybe it's because English isn't my native language and I can't fully follow your explanations - but I'm having trouble finding in your long reply a clear answer to the question you have posted.
* Does a voltage across R allow current to flow through R, or is it the other way around?
* Or is this a “chicken-and-egg” problem?



I have explained that already in post#3:
"From the physical point of view - does something like a "current source" really exist? Or is a device we call "current source" nothing else than a voltage source with a large source resistance (static or dynamic)."

That means: I think, such a circuit we call current source is in fact a voltage source which acts upon the series connection of a (static or dynamic) very large source resistance and a load.

In this context, can you present one illustrative example (circuit) for a constant current source wthout any driving voltage?

Thank you and regards
Hi again,

Thanks for being so cordial I will return the favor. This is interesting although it takes some very fine details to understand what we are working with.

Note that: "Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler" is a comparative statement. That means that "simpler" could be very very complicated and still meet the requirements of that statement. "We made the James Webb telescope as simple as possible".

First, if a current source does not exist then a voltage source does not exist. They are duals of each other, and even if we could not find an ideal source of either type we can theorize that there is such a thing and use that as the source. We also might need a way to describe how exactly we hook it up to the resistor. Using the principle of duality helps here.

So how do we connect a resistor to a voltage source. We close a switch that is in series with the voltage source. The switch provides us with a step change in voltage that gets to the resistor. The switch(s) are assumed to have infinite impedance when open and zero when closed.
Then how do we connect a resistor to a current source. Well, a switch in series is the dual of a switch in parallel, and a switch closure is the dual of a switch opening (NO vs NC switches), so we connect a current source to a resistor by opening the switch that is to start with shorting out the current source.
This means all the current flows through the switch to start with because the ideal switch is zero Ohms exactly, and the resistor is assumed to be non-zero Ohms. So we might have 1 amp through the switch and zero amps through the resistor, but once we open the switch we provide a step change in current through the resistor.
As pointed out before, the expressions would be I=(E/s)/R or E=(I/s)*R, and the time expressions show no time dependence (there is no C or L yet in the ideal cases).

The illustrative circuit for the current source is then an ideal current source in parallel with a switch so we can turn it 'on' at t=0 just like we turn the voltage source on at t=0.

If we go back to basics, we see there is no such thing as an ideal voltage source and of course no such thing as an ideal current source, but we can easily theorize about there being such a thing and work with that because we are looking at theory first and practice second.

I'll quote this for easy reading:
START_QUOTE
* What is wrong with the following simple statement:
* For a current to flow through a resistor R, a force must act on it, which is generated by the electric field inside the resistor. The necessary condition for the existence of this field (and thus its cause) is an externally applied voltage.
END_QUOTE
Remember I was talking about glossing over some of the details. That means making a statement without considering all of the aspects that are assumed to be important.
With the statement quoted above, I see the part: "which is generated by the electric field inside the resistor". My question is, what electric field and how did it get 'there'.
Nothing happens by pure magic. If there is a field present it must have gotten there through some mechanism. The mechanism I believe is wave mechanics.
Considering the resistor to be a simple wire, the wave travels down the wire and starts to establish a static field, but it's not static at first. If it was static already that would be the "field inside the resistor" which we don't get right away considering the speed of light being a limiting factor.
Since the field does not establish immediately, that gives us an opportunity to figure out what happens just before that, and to do that we need to look at very very short time periods such as immediately after the source is applied. It's almost like we take a really fast camera and take a snapshot at the moment of contact, and another snapshot an infinitesimally short time after that. We don't have to go any further than that I don't think, because if we can find out what happens at those two points in time we can know if there is anything happening first or second and thus perhaps settle the "chicken vs egg" problem. We also have to look at one point in space and assume that is the very first point of contact at t=0. We also want to look at one tiny instant just before t=0 which is t=0-.

What happens though is the field at that point is zero at t=0- and so the voltage and current are also zero. At t=0 it makes first contact, and the field is still zero and the voltage and current are both zero. At t=0+ the field starts to build, and in the simpler view the voltage starts to build and the current starts to build. In a more detailed view the charges start to move and the voltage beings to climb. If we look at that one point again and assume we only have one electron there, that electron would start to move, and that constitutes a current, and it can't move without there being a voltage. If the electron moved between two points, then the two points must have a voltage difference, and since the electron is not elastic in any way, it must start to move immediately (more about this again later). This means we have field, voltage, and movement all at the same time.

How do we get movement immediately rather than AFTER some force has been applied.
This is because pure inertia does not introduce any delay in movement. The movement occurs immediately as the force (as you prefer) is applied.
If we had a rough surface brick and tried to push it across the floor, when the force was first applied it would compress slightly because the sticking friction prevents it from moving right away. If we remove that friction though, we are left with pure inertia, and that means the brick would move immediately. We could imagine the brick on a rough surface floor vs on the ice on a frozen over lake. A tiny force can get the brick moving on ice but never on the floor. In fact, with zero friction even the tiniest of forces 1e-12 Newtons would make the object start to move immediately and it would accelerate constantly leading to faster and faster speeds with just that tiny force. This is how some future space travel is thought to be able to accelerate a craft to a very high velocity to reach places far out in space.

In conclusion, this means there is no "chicken and egg" paradox, the real truth is "chicken with egg" or just that the chicken and egg came about at the same time.

If you still have a problem agreeing with any of this, is it because you do not believe that some object can start to move immediately when a small force is applied? This can be a brick, a car, a marble, jumbo jet, a spaceship, anything I guess that is at rest to begin with. Also an interesting note is that Einstein's idea of the lack of simultaneity involves two points in space not just one.
 

ericgibbs

Joined Jan 29, 2010
21,642
First, if a current source does not exist then a voltage source does not exist.
Hi Al,
Define Current source, sounds a little semantic to me.:)

Explain the case of a Spark Gap, with an applied voltage, no current will flow across the spark gap until the PD across the gap exceeds the break-down voltage of the air, then electron current flows across the gap.

So the PD is applied first, and then the current is created.
Without the PD there is no current flow.

E
 

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
Hi again,
thank you for the very detailed reply.
If you still have a problem agreeing with any of this
No - I have absolutely no problem agreeing with your explanations.
However, I still have a few questions, which I would like to address below.

.............but once we open the switch we provide a step change in current through the resistor.
As far as I can see, all the detailed explanations which follow in your contribution refer to a votage step only, correct?

Nothing happens by pure magic. If there is a field present it must have gotten there through some mechanism. The mechanism I believe is wave mechanics.
Considering the resistor to be a simple wire, the wave travels down the wire and starts to establish a static field,
I assume that the source of the mentioned wave that "starts to establsh a static field" is a voltage source, right?

Since the field does not establish immediately, that gives us an opportunity to figure out what happens just before that, and to do that we need to look at very very short time periods such as immediately after the source is applied.
Again, I assume that “source” refers to a voltage source, right?

At t=0+ the field starts to build, and in the simpler view the voltage starts to build and the current starts to build.
...............
...............
How do we get movement immediately rather than AFTER some force has been applied.
This is because pure inertia does not introduce any delay in movement. The movement occurs immediately as the force (as you prefer) is applied.
From the above I conclude that the "force" is equivalent to the E-field and that this force is the precondition for the movement of charges - although there is no measurable time delay between both effects, right?
If this conclusion is correct, I agree of course.

Kind regards
 

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
If the objective is to provide a beginner with a basic understanding of the relationship between current and voltage, the best advice I have to offer is: Don't be fixated with either model. Both models are used in circuit theory and analysis.
Yes - I agree.
For circuit analysis we are always using models - for example: Idealized voltage and current sources, even the simple R is an idealized model only.
However, as far as I understand the title of this thread, we are discussing the physics behind these models.
 
Top