Does a Current Through a Resistor Cause a Voltage Across That Resistor or Does a Voltage Across a Resistor Cause a Current To Flow Though It?

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
OK - after reading the first two posts, I have the following question:

Without taking into account the timely behaviour of the individual effects (field build-up, voltage function, current function) - is the following simple statement incorrect?

A necessary precondition for the movement of charges within a conductor (definition of current) is the existence of an electric field in the conductor.
Thus, the voltage across a resistor is clearly the cause of the corresponding current.
Without this voltage (and the associated electric field), there is no force that can cause the movement of charges.

Wrong ? Or to simple ?

* Added later: I think, it this context also the following question arises:
From the physical point of view - does something like a "current source" really exist? Or is a device we call "current source" nothing else than a voltage source with a large source resistance (static or dynamic).
Hi,

Well it might be too simple because the voltage does not get across the resistor all by itself all of a sudden, the field has to build up across the resistor (or wire) first. But even before that, we have to connect a voltage source of some type to the resistor. In non-electrical terms we might say that the act of connecting the voltage source is the 'cause', but is not what we are looking for. We are looking at the infinitesimally short time after the voltage source is connected and then take it from there: what happens next.

I believe the wave starts to propagate down the wire and changes the surface charges into a gradient, but that takes time, and so at the very ends of the wire (or resistor leads) only those local charges begin to move until the wave gets down (and up) the wire, and then it may reflect back, then reflect back again and again until it settles into what we usually think of as a meaningful DC current.
However, going that far is probably already too far. Before the exact moment of the connection, we see static fields between the wire and the voltage source, even though they are not yet connected. Once connected, those fields collapse and the fields along the wire (as weak as they might be before connecting) start to change, but it must still be locally first.
The key point though I think is that as we bring the battery closer and closer to the wire without connecting, the fields are already changing, even though it may be very little. Once the connection is made, at that very instant, things begin to change faster in the ends of the wire.
If we consider the initial distance between the battery terminals and the wire to be nearly zero (but not zero yet) it could be that the field has already changed a lot, so we have to assume some finite distance that is something reasonable like maybe 0.1 inch (maybe more) and then zero time to connect it to the wire. Then we can say that locally the charges start to change, but I think they start to change immediately there is no delay. One of the reasons for the lack of a delay is because both the terminal (actually two terminals) and the end of the wire are at the exact same 3d point in space. In other words, the charges begin to accelerate at the moment of contact, although we do have to assume the above separation rules apply.

So I think that is the bottom line. As soon as the field becomes greater at a point (x,y,z) the charges begin to move, and the field got there by us moving the battery (or perhaps closing a switch) not by wave propagation. That's what it appears to be anyway.

We might consider one other idea. That is the idea of the rest mass of the electron. If we consider electron flow to be current, then we have to move electrons or at least have them move. This is interesting I think because when we push a mass like a car or a brick, it seems to not move right away, it compresses very slightly first and eventually the entire mass feels the force and moves. With zero sticking friction we don't get any delay before it starts to accelerate, unless it compresses a little first and then only part of the mass moves at first and then the rest follows. From what I understand about quantum physics though, an electron cannot be compressed, and that means that there must be no delay when the field interacts with it for the very first time.

But then we have the rules we use and hand to people just entering the field where we don't want to get into advanced physics yet. Since it seems right that the field and the charges act simultaneously, it is probably still best just to show them how Ohm's Law works and explain that there is no real one-comes-first rule, but we can 'think' of it as either one or the other comes first as is convenient.
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
Nice reasoning but then what is a solar panel? Voltage or current source..
Hi,

Well, we were not really looking at solar panels yet because that is a different element than a wire or resistor. The solar panel works by sunlight knocking electrons out of an already present internal field. It should be obvious that the sunlight moves first before it hits anything. Compare to the wire, I think that would be sort of similar to when we first connect the battery to the wire. That's not exactly the same, but now instead of the battery moving first the photons in the sunlight move first. Those are different issues i think.
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
Voltage causes current vs current causes voltage. It's the chicken and egg problem.
Ohm's Law was based on observation:
I = V / R
The corollary is:
V = I x R

But as @MrAl says, Ohm's Law does not provide cause-and-effect. It states the mathematical relationship between current and voltage.

Rather than debating cause-and-effect, you have to go to the fundamental principles of EM theory where both the electric field and magnetic field coexist.
Hi,

I believe that is a good summary. Since we were looking at cause and effect though that's what I was looking at in post #22 where the field changes due to the movement of the battery and etc., etc.

It seems that there is no way to find that the electron has any delay in movement once the field changes and is at the same point as the electron, so I am pretty much convinced that the two happen simultaneously (even considering the mass of the electron and it's inertia of rest).
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
The voltage is an abstraction. It is the forces between charges that cause the current to flow. The field is also an abstraction.
Hi,

Well I am not sure it does any good to say that everything is an abstraction, because everything probably is :)
But something has to be real I think, and we think of the field as real and the electron as real.
I tried to tie this all together in post #22 but you can review that and see what you think.
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
If you consider the tiny bits of wire, you'll end up with electromagnetic field, which is something that the Maxwell equations tell us that are simultaneous. And we can understand why, the magnetic field is the rotation of the electric field, and vice-versa. This question would be "which derivative comes first?" when dealing with Maxwell equations, which makes no sense.
Also, as we can interpret magnetic fields (generated by electric charges) as charges having length contraction or time dilation, we see that it's just only one thing.
Hi,

That's interesting too. See post #22 and see what you think about all that. I was trying to get to the basis for what is happening.
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
Unless the current is induced in the conductor by a varying external magnetic field. Ultra-simplistically and guaranteed to piss off somebody - *In this case* the field creates the current, and the current "creates" the voltage.

or something like that.

Note that the logo for the IEEE is the right-hand rule: wire, field, and current.

ak
Hi,

Check out post #22 and see if you still think that one creates the other. It gets a little tricky because we are looking for the most elemental reason for current and voltage in a wire, and also what is simpler for someone just entering the field and also simpler for us in the more normal course of analyzing circuits.
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
To properly answer this question, you must start at the beginning.

All electrical generation starts with emf, the first form of electrical energy is always current, from current comes voltage. (potential difference)
Hi,

Well we really have to dig deep for this. See post #22 and think about that.
It seems that one does not come before the other ever.
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
Keep in mind that a field differential can cause two points to have a voltage potential across them, even without current flowing, e.g. the plates of a capacitor.

Current flow through a conductor will also cause a voltage difference. This being due to resistance in the conductor.
Hi,

There seems to be no true cause-and-effect there (see post #22).
We are not considering static fields either, except at the very start of some experiment. The plates of a capacitor are not the same thing that belongs in the category of static electricity or a static electric field. Also, the voltage did not get there all by itself, something in the past must have gotten that voltage to change or at least, in better words, accompanied that change in voltage.
Notice I find it impossible to say that something 'got' that voltage to change, because that also implies some cause-and-effect.
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
A corresponding example would be nice....

By the way - when I speak about "current" in this thread, I am referring to a "classical" current within an electrical circuit and NOT about carrier separation/movement within a voltage source.
(In an answer above I could read "...what is a solar panel? Voltage or current source.."
Answer: Of course, it is a voltage - as a consequence of charge separaton !)

Let me state the following:
The statement "current through a resistor R causes a voltage across R" raises a logical problem.

(1) Lets take the following example:
A (nearly) ideal voltage source V0 is connected to two resistors in series (R1, R2).
So we can say that
V2=I*R2 and V1=I*R1.
In words (assuming I causes V) we could say that both voltages V1 and V2 are caused by the current I - and, as a consequence, also the sum of both: V0=V1+V2.
Final result: The voltage V0 is caused by the currentI I. Really?
Remember - the example has started with Vo being the source of everything that has happened.

Here is another example:
A voltage source drives a current through a potentiometer I=V0/Rtotal
Does it make sense to say that the voltage in part A (R1) or part B (R2) of this device would be caused by this current?
Hi,

Yes in trying to reason this out some examples are good.

It only makes sense to talk about cause and effect when we want to talk more casually and say that "the voltage across the resistor developed a current through it" or the opposite. That can't be true (post #22).

Maybe this goes back to what I started to think some years ago, that voltage is not 'real' and current is not 'real' in some sense (don't worry about this too much though).
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
For some reason they decided to change “potential difference” to voltage thereby hiding its true meaning. Typically we still say current instead of amps. Cassels Popular Science, a book published in the early 1900s explains the analogy between a head of water and a potential (voltage) difference and current and the flow of water. At an early age this helped me have a “light bulb moment” when I realized how to make a low voltage bulb turn on with a battery. The head of water makes the current flow, not the other way around.
Hi,

Well please review post #22 and see what you think. It seems that neither actually 'causes' the other because they are due to something else entirely: the field. Even that is not entirely true though, because even the field is simultaneous with the voltage and current.
So this means that at t=0+ exactly, and because this is so physical we also have to consider the place in space that this happens which would be a point (x,y,z), we see the field, the voltage, and the current, change at the very same moment at that point. (BTW, t=0+ is one instant just after t=0).
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
hi,
I see it the same way as Jerry, Potential Difference, not the 'word' Voltage.
PD is the prime mover of Electrons, which we name as Current

E
Hey there Eric,

Please review post #22 and see if you still think the same. I know it's a little longer but this takes some very detailed explaining :)
 

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
Hi,
Well it might be too simple because the voltage does not get across the resistor all by itself all of a sudden, the field has to build up across the resistor (or wire) first. But even before that, we have to connect a voltage source of some type to the resistor. In non-electrical terms we might say that the act of connecting the voltage source is the 'cause', but is not what we are looking for. We are looking at the infinitesimally short time after the voltage source is connected and then take it from there: what happens next.
Why do you say "it is not what we are looking for"?
Remember, your question was simply:
"Does a Current Through a Resistor Cause a Voltage Across That Resistor or Does a Voltage Across a Resistor Cause a Current To Flow Though It?"

To answer the question, I think it is really not necessary to look at infinitesimally short times after connecting the source.
* Question 1: Can we measure a potential difference (voltage) without connecting a resistor between the two nodes of the voltage source ? YES!
* Question 2: Can we measure any current through a resistor witout connecting a voltage source? NO !
(And we are able to explain WHY a voltage (resp. a corresponding E-field) is necessary to allow the movement of charged carriers within the conductive element.)
How can we deny that the voltage is the cause of the current?

Since it seems right that the field and the charges act simultaneously, it is probably still best just to show them how Ohm's Law works and explain that there is no real one-comes-first rule, but we can 'think' of it as either one or the other comes first as is convenient.
For my opinion, the question regarding cause-and- effect is a complete other one than the "one-comes-first rule".
Simple example:
If we suddenly drop a body with mass from a certain height, it will move toward the Earth.
The reason is clear: gravity.

Question: Is there a measurable delay between the cause (gravity) and the effect (the motion of falling)?

(By the way: A rule like Ohm`s law is nothing else than a function that relates one quantitty to two other quantities.
Such a formula can NEVER tell us something about cause and effect.)
 

Thread Starter

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,887
Why do you say "it is not what we are looking for"?
Remember, your question was simply:
"Does a Current Through a Resistor Cause a Voltage Across That Resistor or Does a Voltage Across a Resistor Cause a Current To Flow Though It?"

To answer the question, I think it is really not necessary to look at infinitesimally short times after connecting the source.
* Question 1: Can we measure a potential difference (voltage) without connecting a resistor between the two nodes of the voltage source ? YES!
* Question 2: Can we measure any current through a resistor witout connecting a voltage source? NO !
(And we are able to explain WHY a voltage (resp. a corresponding E-field) is necessary to allow the movement of charged carriers within the conductive element.)
How can we deny that the voltage is the cause of the current?



For my opinion, the question regarding cause-and- effect is a complete other one than the "one-comes-first rule".
Simple example:
If we suddenly drop a body with mass from a certain height, it will move toward the Earth.
The reason is clear: gravity.

Question: Is there a measurable delay between the cause (gravity) and the effect (the motion of falling)?

(By the way: A rule like Ohm`s law is nothing else than a function that relates one quantitty to two other quantities.
Such a formula can NEVER tell us something about cause and effect.)
Hello again,

You are jumping over details like an Olympic runner jumping over hurdles :)
In other words, you are still speaking too casually and assuming things that have already happened that can't happen without a different 'cause'.

If you don't have time to read this in its entirety, then skip to the last paragraph.

For your question 1:
When we connect a meter to measure voltage, the very act of connecting the meter is something to consider. We DO NOT simply connect a voltmeter to a battery, it's not that simple. As the leads of the voltmeter come closer and closer to the battery, the field changes. Once the leads touch, the field changes more than it did before so it might be considered more abrupt.
NOW we can talk about if the voltage or current comes first. We don't want to talk about connecting the meter because that is a separate issue.
Another point though is that the meter is not magically measuring voltage. It has to draw current from the battery to do that, and there is most likely a series resistor to scale the voltage read from the meter.

Cause-and-effect is the same as which one comes first. This is a strict rule in physics. If one 'causes' the other, it has to come first and the 'effect' has to come after that, and that implies a time delay. When we drop an object, letting go of it is the cause but the drop in height and the speed happen at the same time.

We want to narrow this down to which comes first, the exact question we have been talking about. Does voltage come first, or does current come first. The answer is that they both start at the same time. If we have a circuit that has a voltage appear at t=1.230000000 seconds, then the current starts at t=1.230000000, and if we could measure down to 1e-12 we would still see them start at the very same time.
The only nuance is how the field works. The field is very small to start with, then gradually increases and the closer it gets the more it increases.

To think about the voltage first or current first issue, it seems convenient to talk about there being a sudden transition when the field suddenly increases much more than before, even though it may be more gradually in real life. We can then say that once the gap is closed and direct contact is made, that is when the 'experiment' starts; what happens next.

If you like you can think about a SPST switch closing very quickly. Once the voltage is applied (via our mechanical assistance) then we ask if the voltage comes first or the current comes first. It seems like the voltage comes first when we look at it very simply, but we are not talking about how the voltage got there, we are talking about what happens at the moment of contact at the exact 3d space position (like at the ends of the wire). This is a different issue than us placing the battery in a certain spot.
What happens at the moment of contact is the current ramps up, which means it starts immediately. It may be a very small current but the idea is that since it starts immediately it is present at the same time as the voltage, even though it seems like we should call it zero. This makes it seem like the voltage comes first.

This actually does come up with a physical force too though. The inertia (at rest) makes it seem like the object should not move right when we apply the force, but there is no delay there either. This can be shown mathematically. Inertia just means it takes longer to build up to a certain speed with a given force. That may not be intuitive at first either. Sticking friction is the only thing that can cause a delay in the movement (or some counter force of course).

Now if you wish to continue to state that the voltage comes first because we apply the battery by hand and the voltage was always present and the current was not, then that's up to you. In what I believe is the pure physics view though the voltage is not present until the moment of contact and that's when things start to happen. If we have a system with no voltage and then we bring a voltage to that system, that's when we start the analysis not before. We know a static voltage can exist but we also forget that a tiny, tiny leakage current also exists.

We can also look at inductance but this just makes the discussion more complicated. It appears that when we apply a voltage across an inductor that there is no current at first, then the current builds up. But in theory the current starts right away. We can think of it as zero in practical circuits, but it's a little more complicated than that.

Here is something interesting. If we look at a voltage applied to a resistor, or a current applied to a resistor, we see the following two forms:
[1] I=E/(R*s)
[2] E=R*I/s
both of these are when we take a battery and connect a resistor across it, or connect a resistor across a current source. So what are the *time* expressions...
[1] I=E/R
[2] E=R*I
That's kind of interesting because the *time* expressions do not contain time 't' they are static. This is the case when the voltage or current is connected to the resistor in zero time which is what we assume when we connect a battery to a resistor for example.

This is why I was pushing Ohm's Law, because it shows the relationship not a cause and effect. That's the simplest view.

And as someone said, if we can look at a voltage coming first just because we connected a battery to a resistor and current began to flow, then what if we connect a current source to a resistor and see a voltage 'develop', does that mean current came first? How do you explain that if you firmly believe that the voltage comes first?
 
Last edited:

LvW

Joined Jun 13, 2013
2,062
Hello again,
::::::::::::::::::::::::
In other words, you are still speaking too casually and assuming things that have already happened that can't happen without a different 'cause'.
In this context, Einsteins words just came into my mind:
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler"

Is it really so complicated as outlined by you?

Would you please answer the following question?
* What is wrong with the following simple statement:
* For a current to flow through a resistor R, a force must act on it, which is generated by the electric field inside the resistor. The necessary condition for the existence of this field (and thus its cause) is an externally applied voltage.

Maybe it's because English isn't my native language and I can't fully follow your explanations - but I'm having trouble finding in your long reply a clear answer to the question you have posted.
* Does a voltage across R allow current to flow through R, or is it the other way around?
* Or is this a “chicken-and-egg” problem?

And as someone said, if we can look at a voltage coming first just because we connected a battery to a resistor and current began to flow, then what if we connect a current source to a resistor and see a voltage 'develop', does that mean current came first? How do you explain that if you firmly believe that the voltage comes first?
I have explained that already in post#3:
"From the physical point of view - does something like a "current source" really exist? Or is a device we call "current source" nothing else than a voltage source with a large source resistance (static or dynamic)."

That means: I think, such a circuit we call current source is in fact a voltage source which acts upon the series connection of a (static or dynamic) very large source resistance and a load.

In this context, can you present one illustrative example (circuit) for a constant current source wthout any driving voltage?

Thank you and regards
 
Top