Hi,OK - after reading the first two posts, I have the following question:
Without taking into account the timely behaviour of the individual effects (field build-up, voltage function, current function) - is the following simple statement incorrect?
A necessary precondition for the movement of charges within a conductor (definition of current) is the existence of an electric field in the conductor.
Thus, the voltage across a resistor is clearly the cause of the corresponding current.
Without this voltage (and the associated electric field), there is no force that can cause the movement of charges.
Wrong ? Or to simple ?
* Added later: I think, it this context also the following question arises:
From the physical point of view - does something like a "current source" really exist? Or is a device we call "current source" nothing else than a voltage source with a large source resistance (static or dynamic).
Hi,Nice reasoning but then what is a solar panel? Voltage or current source..
Hi,Voltage causes current vs current causes voltage. It's the chicken and egg problem.
Ohm's Law was based on observation:
I = V / R
The corollary is:
V = I x R
But as @MrAl says, Ohm's Law does not provide cause-and-effect. It states the mathematical relationship between current and voltage.
Rather than debating cause-and-effect, you have to go to the fundamental principles of EM theory where both the electric field and magnetic field coexist.
Hi,The voltage is an abstraction. It is the forces between charges that cause the current to flow. The field is also an abstraction.
Hi,If you consider the tiny bits of wire, you'll end up with electromagnetic field, which is something that the Maxwell equations tell us that are simultaneous. And we can understand why, the magnetic field is the rotation of the electric field, and vice-versa. This question would be "which derivative comes first?" when dealing with Maxwell equations, which makes no sense.
Also, as we can interpret magnetic fields (generated by electric charges) as charges having length contraction or time dilation, we see that it's just only one thing.
Hi,Unless the current is induced in the conductor by a varying external magnetic field. Ultra-simplistically and guaranteed to piss off somebody - *In this case* the field creates the current, and the current "creates" the voltage.
or something like that.
Note that the logo for the IEEE is the right-hand rule: wire, field, and current.
ak
Hi,To properly answer this question, you must start at the beginning.
All electrical generation starts with emf, the first form of electrical energy is always current, from current comes voltage. (potential difference)
Hi,Keep in mind that a field differential can cause two points to have a voltage potential across them, even without current flowing, e.g. the plates of a capacitor.
Current flow through a conductor will also cause a voltage difference. This being due to resistance in the conductor.
Hi,A corresponding example would be nice....
By the way - when I speak about "current" in this thread, I am referring to a "classical" current within an electrical circuit and NOT about carrier separation/movement within a voltage source.
(In an answer above I could read "...what is a solar panel? Voltage or current source.."
Answer: Of course, it is a voltage - as a consequence of charge separaton !)
Let me state the following:
The statement "current through a resistor R causes a voltage across R" raises a logical problem.
(1) Lets take the following example:
A (nearly) ideal voltage source V0 is connected to two resistors in series (R1, R2).
So we can say that
V2=I*R2 and V1=I*R1.
In words (assuming I causes V) we could say that both voltages V1 and V2 are caused by the current I - and, as a consequence, also the sum of both: V0=V1+V2.
Final result: The voltage V0 is caused by the currentI I. Really?
Remember - the example has started with Vo being the source of everything that has happened.
Here is another example:
A voltage source drives a current through a potentiometer I=V0/Rtotal
Does it make sense to say that the voltage in part A (R1) or part B (R2) of this device would be caused by this current?
Hi,For some reason they decided to change “potential difference” to voltage thereby hiding its true meaning. Typically we still say current instead of amps. Cassels Popular Science, a book published in the early 1900s explains the analogy between a head of water and a potential (voltage) difference and current and the flow of water. At an early age this helped me have a “light bulb moment” when I realized how to make a low voltage bulb turn on with a battery. The head of water makes the current flow, not the other way around.
Hey there Eric,hi,
I see it the same way as Jerry, Potential Difference, not the 'word' Voltage.
PD is the prime mover of Electrons, which we name as Current
E
Why do you say "it is not what we are looking for"?Hi,
Well it might be too simple because the voltage does not get across the resistor all by itself all of a sudden, the field has to build up across the resistor (or wire) first. But even before that, we have to connect a voltage source of some type to the resistor. In non-electrical terms we might say that the act of connecting the voltage source is the 'cause', but is not what we are looking for. We are looking at the infinitesimally short time after the voltage source is connected and then take it from there: what happens next.
For my opinion, the question regarding cause-and- effect is a complete other one than the "one-comes-first rule".Since it seems right that the field and the charges act simultaneously, it is probably still best just to show them how Ohm's Law works and explain that there is no real one-comes-first rule, but we can 'think' of it as either one or the other comes first as is convenient.
Hello again,Why do you say "it is not what we are looking for"?
Remember, your question was simply:
"Does a Current Through a Resistor Cause a Voltage Across That Resistor or Does a Voltage Across a Resistor Cause a Current To Flow Though It?"
To answer the question, I think it is really not necessary to look at infinitesimally short times after connecting the source.
* Question 1: Can we measure a potential difference (voltage) without connecting a resistor between the two nodes of the voltage source ? YES!
* Question 2: Can we measure any current through a resistor witout connecting a voltage source? NO !
(And we are able to explain WHY a voltage (resp. a corresponding E-field) is necessary to allow the movement of charged carriers within the conductive element.)
How can we deny that the voltage is the cause of the current?
For my opinion, the question regarding cause-and- effect is a complete other one than the "one-comes-first rule".
Simple example:
If we suddenly drop a body with mass from a certain height, it will move toward the Earth.
The reason is clear: gravity.
Question: Is there a measurable delay between the cause (gravity) and the effect (the motion of falling)?
(By the way: A rule like Ohm`s law is nothing else than a function that relates one quantitty to two other quantities.
Such a formula can NEVER tell us something about cause and effect.)
In this context, Einsteins words just came into my mind:Hello again,
::::::::::::::::::::::::
In other words, you are still speaking too casually and assuming things that have already happened that can't happen without a different 'cause'.
I have explained that already in post#3:And as someone said, if we can look at a voltage coming first just because we connected a battery to a resistor and current began to flow, then what if we connect a current source to a resistor and see a voltage 'develop', does that mean current came first? How do you explain that if you firmly believe that the voltage comes first?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faraday's_law_of_inductionIn this context, can you present one illustrative example (circuit) for a constant current source wthout any driving voltage?
My personal rule: I do not blindly trust wikipedia.