I am trying to understand why I'm not getting the same answer of using a certain method for solving circuits. For the following example, the switch opens at t = 0, I am to find the capacitor voltage at t>0.

The first method I tried was to write the differential equation for the capacitor voltage and find the LaPlace transform of it :
\(frac{1}{2}frac{d^2v}{dt}+frac{3}{2}frac{dv}{dt}+v=\0\) => \(V(s)=\frac{12s+28}{3(s+1)(s+2)\) => \(v(t)=frac{16}{3}e^(-t)-frac{4}{3}e^(-2t)\)

However, representing it in the s-domain leads me to another equation:
\(V(s)=frac{-8s-24}{3s(s+1)(s+2)\) => \(v(t)=[frac{16}{3}e^(-t)-frac{4}{3}e^(-2t)-4]u(t)\)

Moderators note : removed the plain tags to show the latex

 

Sorry, bad latex :
Using differential equation:
\(\frac{1}{2}\frac{d^2v}{dt}+\frac{3}{2}\frac{dv}{dt}+v=0\) =>\(V(s)=\frac{12s+28}{3(s+1)(s+2)\) => \(v(t)=[\frac{16}{3}e^-^t-\frac{4}{3}e^-^2^t]u(t)\)
Using s-domain representation:
\(V(s)=\frac{-8s-24}{3s(s+1)(s+2)\) => \(v(t)=[\frac{16}{3}e^-^t-\frac{4}{3}e^-^2^t-4]u(t)\)
As you can see similar answers, but the second one includes -4V. I don' t know why...

 

[accidental second post, please ignore/remove]

 

Sorry, bad latex :
Using differential equation:
\(\frac{1}{2}\frac{d^2v}{dt}+\frac{3}{2}\frac{dv}{dt}+v=0\) =>\(V(s)=\frac{12s+28}{3(s+1)(s+2)\) => \(v(t)=[\frac{16}{3}e^-^t-\frac{4}{3}e^-^2^t]u(t)\)
Using s-domain representation:
\(V(s)=\frac{-8s-24}{3s(s+1)(s+2)\) => \(v(t)=[\frac{16}{3}e^-^t-\frac{4}{3}e^-^2^t-4]u(t)\)
As you can see similar answers, but the second one includes -4V. I don' t know why...

Hello,

Had to edit my reply extensively because i read your schematic wrong the first time.

The voltage they are asking for is the voltage across the ORIGINAL cap in the original circuit, so for the second circuit that means the voltage across BOTH the cap and the initial current generator for the cap. This means your second drawing is not correct because you must show the cap voltage as being across both of those elements. If you try to solve for the voltage across the cap alone in the second circuit you'll get a -4 in the result because of that IC generator.

Try that and see if you get the right result. I dont see how you could get this wrong now though

BTW a more direct IC generator for the inductor is a stepped current source.

 

Hello,

Had to edit my reply extensively because i read your schematic wrong the first time.

The voltage they are asking for is the voltage across the ORIGINAL cap in the original circuit, so for the second circuit that means the voltage across BOTH the cap and the initial current generator for the cap. This means your second drawing is not correct because you must show the cap voltage as being across both of those elements. If you try to solve for the voltage across the cap alone in the second circuit you'll get a -4 in the result because of that IC generator.

Try that and see if you get the right result. I dont see how you could get this wrong now though

BTW a more direct IC generator for the inductor is a stepped current source.

Thank you so much, it helps clear up some misunderstandings for me.