This is the discussion thread for the upcoming second installment in The Neophytes Guide to Hand Soldering. After a year, I am finally working to get this part posted and you can help!
The format of the post is an answer to the question “what should I buy?” along with additional information about “extra” tools, etc. This is not about solder, flux, and the like which will be in the third part—rather about irons and whatever else might be needed.
An excerpt:
Another excerpt:
So, if you could take a little time and let us listen in to you giving the best advice to yourself that would be really helpful. Breifly (or not) answer the four questions—
Once you’ve answered these questions, please tell us which tools you’ve settled on to fit the bill. You might have more than one of something (e.g.: portable vs. fixed use), that’s fine. Imagine you are giving yourself advice on what to buy. It would be great to organize it into three categories:
As I said solder, flux, and other consumables will be in part 3 or elsewhere but if you want to mention them that’s fine. You can be as detailed or cursory as you think is worth your time but it would be especially appreciated if you’d include:
Again, I appreciate anything you can add, so don’t skip answering if you don’t want to do that much work, just answer as much as you are willing. I consider your time valuable and your “donation” of it generous, no matter how much you choose to give.
Thanks for reading and I do hope this can provoke some discussion that will help diversify the opinions expressed in the blog post when I make it live.
The format of the post is an answer to the question “what should I buy?” along with additional information about “extra” tools, etc. This is not about solder, flux, and the like which will be in the third part—rather about irons and whatever else might be needed.
An excerpt:
One of the most controversial topics in the realm of hand soldering is tools. Opinions about this area run strong and deep. They vary considerably based on a person’s technical background and experience, available funds, and even their focus of their interest in the hobby of electronics.
It would be very helpful indeed if you’d be willing to answer a few questions about your own situation and what you have found to be best for you. A part of this entry will be to help people decide on what to buy considering who they are and what they hope to do.Another excerpt:
If someone asks ‘what do I need to buy for electronics hand soldering?’ they will get nearly as many answers as the number of people asked. It is very hard to find “authoritative“ information of just what is the “right” answer to this question. The truth is, there are many correct answers and they are most easily understood if we forget getting the “right” one.
Avoiding what amounts to dogma, the proper response to this question must take several things into account:
- Who is asking
- What they will be soldering
- Where they will work
- Why they are doing it
So, if you could take a little time and let us listen in to you giving the best advice to yourself that would be really helpful. Breifly (or not) answer the four questions—
Who are you? That is, are you a lover of tools for their own sake, or a strongly practical person for whom tools are just a means to the end you have in mind—or some combination.
What do you solder? Are you working on through-hole, SMD (new, rework, &c), wires and connectors, &c.—or whatever combination or other thing you solder.
Where do you work? Do you have a dedicated bench, a shared workbench with other hobbies, kitchen table squatter’s rights, a live out of your backpack lifestyle? Where do the tools you’ve settled on find their ideal environment. Of course, you might have more than one of these.
Why do you solder? This is probably less important for those of you answering (thank you) than a cold question from a visitor to AAC. This is because it is mostly meant to distinguish solderers-by-choice from those forced to do some soldering they otherwise have no interest in (e.g.: a repair they have no intention of repeating). But, if you have something to add to this question, please do!
Once you’ve answered these questions, please tell us which tools you’ve settled on to fit the bill. You might have more than one of something (e.g.: portable vs. fixed use), that’s fine. Imagine you are giving yourself advice on what to buy. It would be great to organize it into three categories:
- Essentials (can’t work without it)
- Enhancements (work better with it, an essential once you own it)
- Extras (not needed but nice to have)
As I said solder, flux, and other consumables will be in part 3 or elsewhere but if you want to mention them that’s fine. You can be as detailed or cursory as you think is worth your time but it would be especially appreciated if you’d include:
- Specific makes and models
- Approximate costs
- Links to vendors, datasheets, &c
- Images useful for illustration (with source links if possible)
Again, I appreciate anything you can add, so don’t skip answering if you don’t want to do that much work, just answer as much as you are willing. I consider your time valuable and your “donation” of it generous, no matter how much you choose to give.
Thanks for reading and I do hope this can provoke some discussion that will help diversify the opinions expressed in the blog post when I make it live.