Art of Electronics Third Edition Exercise 3.16.

Thread Starter

MK14A

Joined Dec 10, 2025
3
1765396346275.png
How does the current-limiting circuit work?
Solved

How much load current does it allow?
Would need help with this one
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
32,702
If you understand how it works, then you should be able to what condition has to be met for it to limit the current.

Take you best shot to figure it out and present your work. We then have something to work with to try to help you spot anything that you are missing or doing wrong.
 

Thread Starter

MK14A

Joined Dec 10, 2025
3
If you understand how it works, then you should be able to what condition has to be met for it to limit the current.

Take you best shot to figure it out and present your work. We then have something to work with to try to help you spot anything that you are missing or doing wrong.
My best shot is this:
Ilim = Vbe/R5 = 0.7V/0.5V = 1,4A
Ilim - Is allowed current
0.7V - Is the voltage drop of the Q3 transistor
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
32,702
My best shot is this:
Ilim = Vbe/R5 = 0.7V/0.5V = 1,4A
Ilim - Is allowed current
0.7V - Is the voltage drop of the Q3 transistor
Sounds good. The actual limit will be slightly different, but that's the mechanism. As Q3 starts turning on, it shunts current around R2. It is the voltage across R2 that provides the gate-source voltage to turn Q2 on, so as Q3 turns on, Q2 is turned off. This is not a distinct on/off event, but a smooth transition over a fairly small range of currents. That range is in the ballpark of when the Vbe of Q3 is in the 0.6 V to 0.7 V range.

Note that you have a typo in your first equation -- it's 0.5 Ω, not 0.5 V. But kudos for tracking your units through your work.
 

Thread Starter

MK14A

Joined Dec 10, 2025
3
Sounds good. The actual limit will be slightly different, but that's the mechanism. As Q3 starts turning on, it shunts current around R2. It is the voltage across R2 that provides the gate-source voltage to turn Q2 on, so as Q3 turns on, Q2 is turned off. This is not a distinct on/off event, but a smooth transition over a fairly small range of currents. That range is in the ballpark of when the Vbe of Q3 is in the 0.6 V to 0.7 V range.

Note that you have a typo in your first equation -- it's 0.5 Ω, not 0.5 V. But kudos for tracking your units through your work.
Thank you!
 
Top