I was initially looking at a similar circuit where the latch pin would need to stay high. The disadvantage of that is that the momentary switch needs to be held for a couple of seconds to let the arduino turn on and set the pin high. The advantage of the circuit that cozendey posted was that it did not rely on the latch pin to keep it on and so the button press could also be short. I was able to get the circuit working that relied on the latch pin (we'll call that the sghioto circuit), but I couldn't get the cozendey circuit to work. Cozendey had a video demonstrating it and it made sense to me, so I was just assuming that I hooked it up wrong on the breadboard (although I checked it several times over). The sghioto circuit is not bad and I can use it if I need to, but I do think the cozendey circuit is more ideal for my use case. I do appreciate your input and your changes definitely take me from a state of "not working" to "working", which is very helpful.