Variacs are dangerous ?

Thread Starter

Hextejas

Joined Sep 29, 2017
187
Or so I have been warned. I saw a picture of one like this and wondered why. Something to do with not having an isolation xformer. Some variac do, but big $$$$. Price restricted.
I had planned to take the output of 3V to a breadboard someway and didnt see any bare wires laying around with more than 3V. So, where is it going to bite me ? Is it that there is a potential for the full mains voltage to be present on the case ?
And thanks, I didn't buy one but I want to know why.

s-l1600.jpg
 

dl324

Joined Mar 30, 2015
18,220
Is it that there is a potential for the full mains voltage to be present on the case ?
Yes. An autotransformer typically uses a single winding. If that winding fails, you can get the full input voltage applied to the load.

One of the moderators posted in one of your earlier threads about isolated autotransformers being available. Think it was @bertus, but I've never seen one.

Do yourself a favor and just go to a second hand store and buy an AC wall wart. 12VAC is a common voltage and is safe to work with.

Or, as I posted in your other thread, mount a typical transformer in a box (with a power switch), so line voltage won't be exposed.
 

tindel

Joined Sep 16, 2012
939
Variacs are not isolated from earth. The variac pictured can put out 130V ac, referenced to earth ground. An isolation transformer is not referenced to earth making circuits safer to work on because you have to touch two nodes of the circuit to be shocked (you only need to touch one node of the circuit to be shocked when referenced to earth because you're usually also referenced to earth).

Failures of variacs happen also. And can kill you dead.

At 3Vac output, you're probably okay, but it still needs to be isolated to meet forum TOS.

Bottom line is that you need galvanic isolation to know that you're relatively safe - but still don't get both hands on a live high voltage surface.
 

MaxHeadRoom

Joined Jul 18, 2013
30,562
Variacs are Very useful devices, but as pointed out, you need to be aware of the devices limitation as to Galvanic isolation.
I would not be without mine, but those that use these are generally aware of safety issues, if your power socket is wired correctly, when plugged in, the Variac output socket should have the common or neutral side retained and in common with the originating 15a outlet it is plugged into, but it pays to confirm this.
Max.
 

Bernard

Joined Aug 7, 2008
5,784
An open winding failure would be very rare, not using a proper plug is where problems crop up. User plugs in a 2 narrow blade AC line cord connecting to a low V rectifier. No problem .
Then Murphey rears his ugly head & OP touches circuit ground & a earth grounded case-- Ouch.
 

spinnaker

Joined Oct 29, 2009
7,830
For all of the reasons already stated, don't use a variac for a low voltage step-down transformer.
Go to a second hand store and buy a wall-wart with the suitable low AC voltage.
I never considered second hand stores for salvaged parts for projects. Seems like a good idea. Of course I have enough wall warts around to last a couple of life times of projects. ;)
 
Last edited:

Thread Starter

Hextejas

Joined Sep 29, 2017
187
Ok, makes a lot of scary sense and I did buy a 9v AC, wall wart. The store where I bought it also had a variac with an isolation xformer and it was a large and heavy beast. The box was probably 1 1/4 feet to a side.
Which makes me wonder why it was so ginormous and my desktop dc power supply and the wall wart are so small.
Apparently they are safer than the variac. How can they build the safety into those little cases and not into a variac.
Every time I turn the page or ask a question, I generate an endless number of new questions.
Sheesh
 

shortbus

Joined Sep 30, 2009
10,050
I personally don't see the fear of working with AC. Guess it's because that's where I started with electrical things, AC. Or maybe you are still thinking about the Edison vs Tesla current war times? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_the_currents

Both can hurt you, but only if you do something stupid. You just need to play/work safe. If that wasn't the case we would all be living like the Amish.
 

ebeowulf17

Joined Aug 12, 2014
3,307
I personally don't see the fear of working with AC. Guess it's because that's where I started with electrical things, AC. Or maybe you are still thinking about the Edison vs Tesla current war times? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_the_currents

Both can hurt you, but only if you do something stupid. You just need to play/work safe. If that wasn't the case we would all be living like the Amish.
Although there's a big difference between knowing what you're comfortable working near yourself vs knowing what to advise a noob to try. If I was face to face watching someone new, I could correct mistakes and keep them safe. Guiding them through the web I'm much less confident.
 

AnalogKid

Joined Aug 1, 2013
12,052
I don't think this has been mentioned yet. A variac is a power transformer with the coil exposed so a wiper arm can slide across it. It is a simple structure that does not hold mechanical tolerances well with use. 3 Vac is 2.5% of the input voltage, possibly below the adjustability limit for some models. Trying to get a stable 3 Vac out of a line powered variac is difficult, and going back to that exact spot for repeatability would be a challenge.

ak
 

dendad

Joined Feb 20, 2016
4,635
My Variac arrived with the active (240V here in Oz) wired to the cold end! Definitely a no no!
I rewired the lead to fix it.
Variacs are an extremely useful device but not the thing to generate 3VAC to use directly. Putting aside the safety issues, just think what happens as you are working on your 3VAC powered project and accidentally bump the Variac knob. It WILL happen!
Use an isolation step down transformer please.
 

Reloadron

Joined Jan 15, 2015
7,862
I had planned to take the output of 3V to a breadboard someway and didnt see any bare wires laying around with more than 3V.
I have to strongly agree with AnalogKid:
I don't think this has been mentioned yet. A variac is a power transformer with the coil exposed so a wiper arm can slide across it. It is a simple structure that does not hold mechanical tolerances well with use. 3 Vac is 2.5% of the input voltage, possibly below the adjustability limit for some models. Trying to get a stable 3 Vac out of a line powered variac is difficult, and going back to that exact spot for repeatability would be a challenge.
You would do well to just buy a simple little 6V CT (Center Tapped) transformer. If you just want for example 3.3 VDC buy a 5 volt wall wort and a 3.3 volt low dropout regulator that meets your current demand.

Ron
 

AnalogKid

Joined Aug 1, 2013
12,052
:) Absolutely. The match up reminds me of days gone by and the Rose Bowl games between OSU and USC.
My dad was at the 68 Rose bowl, the one when we beat OJ for the title. 50 years later, if it weren't for the playoffs we'd be playing USC in the Rose Bowl, and I'd be there.

ak
 

Reloadron

Joined Jan 15, 2015
7,862
My dad was at the 68 Rose bowl, the one when we beat OJ for the title. 50 years later, if it weren't for the playoffs we'd be playing USC in the Rose Bowl, and I'd be there.

ak
Exactly! Before they added all sorts of things to college ball. That's pretty cool with your dad. I never went to a bowl game but my parents lived in Worthington, north of campus and my dad would get OSU tickets. I made a few OSU home games.

Ron
 
Top