LED in rush current

Thread Starter

funguy

Joined Oct 31, 2023
43
If I have 10 LEDs in series controlled by a CCR at 100 mA and 12volts would the calculation be derived from Vf-3.3V and supply of 12 Volts and number of LEDs. 3.3 x 10=33
33x12=396mA?

Granted I do have these LED circuits in parallel of each other
 

ronsimpson

Joined Oct 7, 2019
4,647
I do not understand. Can you make a picture/drawing?
You have 10 LEDs in series. 3.3V each, you need 33V for current to flow.
I do not understand 12Volts.
I do not understand 396mA.
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,463
In addition to the fact that you cannot run 10 3.3V LEDs in series from 12V, LEDs is series draw the same current as a single LED, the current does not add.
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,463
The premise of that calculator is completely bogus. The inrush current to an LED driver has nothing to do with the constant current it produces in steady state. The inrush current depends on the size of capacitors and the resistance in it’s AC to DC converter.
 

dl324

Joined Mar 30, 2015
18,220
First you say the LEDs are in series, then you end with saying they're in parallel. Which is it?

  1. Why do you care about inrush current?
  2. What is the current capacity of the power source?
  3. How can we calculate current without knowing what resistor value(s) you're using?
the actual accuracy of this because it seemed a little off
You haven't given us enough information to determine current or why you're concerned about inrush current.
 

Thread Starter

funguy

Joined Oct 31, 2023
43
The premise of that calculator is completely bogus. The inrush current to an LED driver has nothing to do with the constant current it produces in steady state. The inrush current depends on the size of capacitors and the resistance in it’s AC to DC converter.
Sorry its being boosted to 36V
 

ronsimpson

Joined Oct 7, 2019
4,647
You have ten 3.3V LEDs, then the voltage will be about 33V. (because the 3.3 is not accurate and changes with temperature the 33 could be 36 to 30)
I think you have a constant current driver (power supply) so each LED will have about 3.3V and 100mA. In series the voltage adds up while the current is 100mA.
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
27,186
Several things first. Where did the 3.3 volts figure come from?? That is not a typical forward voltage for most LEDs, and so the number is suspect, unless the data sheet for the LEDs states that is the voltage at 100 mA. And whatever the forward voltage is, it certainly does change with temperature.
If you have a number of strings of ten LEDs connected in parallel and you are operating them all at the maximum rated current, then the current would be 100mA multiplied by the number of strings.
LEDs do not exhibit any inrush current, so that is not a consideration.
If the intended supply voltage is 12 volts, you will not get much light from a string of 10 LEDs in series. POSSIBLY putting FOUR leds in series across 12 volts will give you quite a bit of light, and the current will be a bit less than the 100mA. So I suggest trying them four in series first.
But if this is for an automotive application then the voltage source will frequently exceed 13.4 volts and so a way to limit the current will be required. That could be a series resistor or an actual current regulator circuit.
 

Audioguru again

Joined Oct 21, 2019
6,826
The LED Inrush Current article is rubbish.
They say when three 3V LED are in series and are powered directly from 12V then the inrush current is "9V x 12V= 108mA".
Actually, the current will be the maximum amount the 12V power supply can produce and will explode the LEDs.

3.3V is typical forward voltage of a blue or white LED. Some of the LEDs might have the minimum voltage of about 3V and others might have the maximum voltage of 3.6V. The current MUST be limited by a series resistor or other current limiting circuit.
 

ElectricSpidey

Joined Dec 2, 2017
3,312
I have been building lighted displays for decades and never once considered LED inrush current.

Sometimes I feel like the coyote in those roadrunner cartoons expecting all of my project to suddenly fail when I realize I'm over the cliff. (did everything wrong according to the internet)
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,667
If I have 10 LEDs in series controlled by a CCR at 100 mA and 12volts would the calculation be derived from Vf-3.3V and supply of 12 Volts and number of LEDs. 3.3 x 10=33
33x12=396mA?

Granted I do have these LED circuits in parallel of each other
Hi,

Are you saying you have several strings of 10 LEDs in series, and connecting all those strings in parallel?
 

MisterBill2

Joined Jan 23, 2018
27,186
Hi,

Are you saying you have several strings of 10 LEDs in series, and connecting all those strings in parallel?
That is what I understood the TS to be stating: Strings of ten LEDs in series, connected in parallel.
AND, for the unlimited current situation, the initial inrush current spike ends when the first LED in the string "fuses"'
For LEDs operated within their specified current, the inrush ends when the current reaches the other end of the string. Thus it is very short and difficult to detect.
 

Ya’akov

Joined Jan 27, 2019
10,226
As said above, its all about the driver... and that cackulator looks garbage to me... what does volts x volts even mean?

Some real science on this subject....

Modelling of Inrush Current Surges—LED Strip Drivers Case Study
It‘s really worse than you make it. The formula (shown at the bottom of the page) is:
\[ I_C = SSC\ \times\ 100\ \times\ D \]
Where SSC is Steady State Current and D is the number of drivers. In other words, it uses a blind coefficient of 100 for any driver. So, if I have an LED driver that can provide 10A, my calculated inrush is 1000A!
 

Thread Starter

funguy

Joined Oct 31, 2023
43
It‘s really worse than you make it. The formula (shown at the bottom of the page) is:
\[ I_C = SSC\ \times\ 100\ \times\ D \]
Where SSC is Steady State Current and D is the number of drivers. In other words, it uses a blind coefficient of 100 for any driver. So, if I have an LED driver that can provide 10A, my calculated inrush is 1000A!
Thank you
 

MrAl

Joined Jun 17, 2014
13,667
It‘s really worse than you make it. The formula (shown at the bottom of the page) is:
\[ I_C = SSC\ \times\ 100\ \times\ D \]
Where SSC is Steady State Current and D is the number of drivers. In other words, it uses a blind coefficient of 100 for any driver. So, if I have an LED driver that can provide 10A, my calculated inrush is 1000A!
Yeah I thought that was funny too. Such is the state of some web information.
 

tonyStewart

Joined May 8, 2012
231
For LEDs rated at 3.3V @ 100 mA and using a 12V supply, the calculator is not rubbish, only misunderstood. I chose 3x3.3V= 9.9V
1706195623101.png

So at best you can use 9 LEDs 3 in series and 3 in parallel but I would add a 1 ohm resistor in series with each 3S string to prevent thermal runaway which drops 0.1V only but enough to minimize the effects of -4mV/'C rise in junction temperature rise. Thus (12V-10V)/0.1A = 20 Ohms (* 0.1A = 2W) (instead of 21 ohms) so use a 5W resistor or four 5 Ohms 1W in series (derated for power by 50%) or four 80 ohms 1W in parallel or three 1A diodes in series to get a ~ 2.1V drop. This biggest variable is the Vf=3.3V on each LED, which could be as low as 3V. So your datasheet will help tell us.

This is more like what you want. With 22 Ohms will draw > 200 mW @ 120 'C so use a 1/2W R or multiple R's to share power.

1706196839130.png
 
Last edited:

Irving

Joined Jan 30, 2016
4,996
OK, that bit makes sense, except the diagram is 3S4P not 3S3P. But that's not inrush current, that's just normal operating current. It was the inrush current calculator we were referring too.
 
Top