How so? "Better" depends on the OP's requirements and, in any case, his circuit doesn't work and mine does.Your "padding" resistors are only 1K, not 10K as shown in the diagram. You'll get a better result using the 10K resistors.
My comment was directed to the TS. Without the 10K padding resistors, much of the pot's rotation will be wasted in dead zones.How so?
You might also try tweaking your padding resistors to ensure you're getting 1/3 and 2/3 Vcc at the ends of your pot's travel.Anyway... I'm not satisfied with the result: yes, it's true, now i can go from no light to about full brightness.... but all the brightness change is concentrated in the first half of potentiometer. Even with a small rotation i get half of the brightness and it's very hard to set a desired low brightness setup.
As intended? So you'd damn us all by your inability to distinguish between red and orange?My comment was directed to the TS. Without the 10K padding resistors, much of the pot's rotation will be wasted in dead zones.
Which dead zones are you talking about?
This may all be moot. I thought I read his resistors as brown-black-red (1K) but the red band might be orange (10K) as intended.
I don't understand the attitude. I was merely pointing out a potential source of his problem based on his photos. Many have built that circuit with good results and I'm sure our TS can get good results also.As intended? So you'd damn us all by your inability to distinguish between red and orange?
The two circuits are _not_ identical."his circuit doesn't work and mine does."
The two circuits are identical electrically in that one side of the pot is used to charge the capacitor and another to discharge it. The diodes act to steer the charge and discharge current.
We don't know why the ops circuit didn't work but we know for sure it is not due to the schematic.
Saying the same thing over and over doesn't really help you defend your position.The two circuits are _not_ identical.
Mine works, Luca's doesn't.
Yup, you're right; I overreacted. Sorry about that...Saying the same thing over and over doesn't really help you defend your position.
Laying out facts and reason with sound logic does.
by Jake Hertz
by Jake Hertz
by Jake Hertz
by Duane Benson