EU Brexit - UK

Status
Not open for further replies.

jpanhalt

Joined Jan 18, 2008
11,087
Is the popular vote binding?

Earlier in the week, I read a comment to the effect that the ultimate decision rests with Parliament. The pundit went on to say that it was extremely unlikely Parliament would not follow the popular vote. Here is one example: http://www.theguardian.com/politics...ng-brexit-lisbon-cameron-sovereign-parliament

Does anyone know with certainty whether the popular vote sets the decision in this instance or does Parliament have the ultimate say? That is, by comparison to the American electoral system, we have laws in place to ensure that the outcome is predictable, at least for the first ballot.

John
 

GopherT

Joined Nov 23, 2012
8,009
Well, the great part of Brexit is that those high maintenance vehicles imported from the UK will be cheaper for us Americans to buy (but will still be costly to maintain). And, oh the food! The crumbly tasteless crackers and scones - the types of things that you have to dip in your coffee so you can get them down without choking - those will be cheaper too!

The other good news that I just leaned this morning, a UK citizen who is renting a house in our neighborhood will have to go back to the UK if the exchange rate doesn't correct in the next 6-weeks. His company told him the budget for his delegation would be exceeded at the current exchange rate. This guy is a huge pain in the ass.

Thanks for voting, "leave".
 

ronv

Joined Nov 12, 2008
3,770
Well, the great part of Brexit is that those high maintenance vehicles imported from the UK will be cheaper for us Americans to buy (but will still be costly to maintain). And, oh the food! The crumbly tasteless crackers and scones - the types of things that you have to dip in your coffee so you can get them down without choking - those will be cheaper too!

The other good news that I just leaned this morning, a UK citizen who is renting a house in our neighborhood will have to go back to the UK if the exchange rate doesn't correct in the next 6-weeks. His company told him the budget for his delegation would be exceeded at the current exchange rate. This guy is a huge pain in the ass.

Thanks for voting, "leave".
:D
Also heard today that at least one Japanese automaker was going to move it's plant to the mainland to avoid the coming tariffs.
A lot of unknown issues.
 

jpanhalt

Joined Jan 18, 2008
11,087
I saw Post #247. All it states is that there is a petition. No reference, and most important , no link describing the legal status of such a petition.

What democratic republic would let a petition by 2 or 3 million people over-ride the vote by 10X that number the day before? Another op-ed said there is no established procedure for a petition to create a Parliament vote on a matter. The vote has been settled. Those who wanted to surrender their sovereignty to France and Germany lost. If the Parliament decides not to abide by that vote (as asked in my previous post), I suspect the carnage will be more than a few hundred points on the DJIA.

However, I did ask knowledgeable members of AAC in a previous post about what the terms of the referendum were. No answers, yet.

John
 
Last edited:

prof328

Joined Apr 15, 2016
10
I believe parliament has the final say, BUT they are obliged to follow the wishes of the electorate, which has been decided democratically.
I also believe the petition for a re-vote will be discussed, but I would think that will last about 5s as it is a nonsensical proposition.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top