Electric field - magnetic field

Thread Starter

linhvn

Joined Nov 6, 2024
297
Can someone explain these fields by making analogy or compared to something physically visible, these fields are quite abstract to me?
 

BobTPH

Joined Jun 5, 2013
11,463
Can someone explain these fields by making analogy or compared to something physically visible, these fields are quite abstract to me?
Perhaps that is because it is just that, abstraction. It is a useful mathematical model that allowed us to do calculations that were otherwise impossible at the time. It only works over statistically large systems of particles, whose actual behavior is described by quantum mechanics, which may itself be an abstraction.
 

sparky 1

Joined Nov 3, 2018
1,218
The 2 fields, electric and magnetic are perpendicular. All the electrical laws show different aspects.
Putting a cart before the dog is an analogy of ignoring prior knowledge.
Maxwells fluid analogy, mathematicians wanted something better. Thankfully some rejected the steam engine analogies.
3D Comsol simulations give relevant information that supports practical applications
 

kaindub

Joined Oct 28, 2019
176
I was a professional engineer for 40 years. I knew about E and H fields, but I never understood them well. Maxwells equations had me baffled.
However I never found a situation where I needed to apply this stuff. In order for my head not to explode, I just acknowledged that such stuff existed, and moved on to the next problem.
I'm not trying to be funny. Its just that the application of E and H fields is not in the realm of the practicing engineer.
 

Curt Carpenter

Joined Jun 25, 2018
42
To make E & H more "visible" and real, let me suggest the (magnet+iron filings) experiments for H and (battery+teledeltos paper) experiments for E. A little google searching should turn up more information and a few videos for both.
 

sparky 1

Joined Nov 3, 2018
1,218
Emil Lenz formulated Lenz law and Fleming much later taught his students the right hand rule.
Fleming would pass a copper wire through a C shaped magnet showing current direction. Lenz and angular momentum was ahead of it's time.
Those who worked with the basic experiments of an electric generator could better grasp the dynamo field concept.
Lorenz who mastered mathematics was asked to interpret all prior mathematical knowledge that had accumulated.
He reiterated by saying the Magnetic field wraps around moving current.

lec10.dvi
 
Last edited:
Top