Hi All,

This is seem to be a challenge to me.
Can anyone let me know is there any possibility that i can convert MOSFET to BJT with all their functionality remaining the same.
PLS do the needful

 

Regarding the conversion of MOSFET to BJT I found in one thread saying by adding a zener diode we can convert the same... But I am not very sure of that solution.
Pls do help me

 

Will be waiting for th valuable replies.
Thanks

 

Can you replace a pig with a cow?

Can you replace a vacuum tube with a BJT?

Circuit, circuit, circuit.

Show your circuit!

 

Can you replace a pig with a cow?

Great analogy. Without more detail, most folks would say no. But there will be times when you can. It all depends on the details.

 

Great analogy. Without more detail, most folks would say no. But there will be times when you can. It all depends on the details.

No - I don`t think so.
I think, no special considerations - with regard to details - are necessary to give the answer: No.
Remember: The question was "with all their functionality remaining the same"
Of course, you can replace a MOSFET in an amplifier circuit with a BJT to do - in principle - the same job: To amplify. However, as far as I understand, this was not the question.

 

...no special considerations - with regard to details - are necessary to give the answer: No.

I'm inclined to agree, but without the context of what the OP was really asking about, we can only guess that we understand the question. A cow is not a pig. Both can be roasted over a fire to make a feast.

 

No - I don`t think so.
I think, no special considerations - with regard to details - are necessary to give the answer: No.
Remember: The question was "with all their functionality remaining the same"
Of course, you can replace a MOSFET in an amplifier circuit with a BJT to do - in principle - the same job: To amplify. However, as far as I understand, this was not the question.

There are simple cases, such as driving a relay or an LED, where a BJT or a MOSFET will work equally well.
The real meaning of "all their functionality" is the key to this question.