Hi! I just discovered AAC thanks to a post on Hacker News. Great stuff! I've only begun exploring, but here's a suggestion.
At the bottom of the Thyristors page it says, "A positive pulse applied to the gate of an SCR triggers it into conduction." Wouldn't it be better to specify, "positive with respect to the cathode"? Experienced people easily assume this, but assumptions aren't appropriate in an educational setting.
More worrisome, the MOSFET page begins with two diagrams showing how a depletion region is established by making the gate positive with respect to the substrate. But then we see two diagrams with no connection to the substrate at all!
In discussions elsewhere I've often seen the MOSFET described as a symmetrical device, and IMO this theoretical point deserves an unhurried explanation so it can be firmly established and understood. Heck, I'm not sure I fully understand it myself! I realize (as stated later) that, in discrete MOSFET's, the substrate is connected to the source, but really MOSFET's are four terminal devices.
For once I'd like to see them discussed as such! (with due respect to the efforts of folks here and elsewhere). The assumption that substrate and source are connected should be carefully avoided until after the basics are established.
Can the page be improved so it clearly explains the 4-terminal theory first, and only deals with the 3-terminal assumption after? I've seen a bunch of internet references that failed to do so -- and, sadly, a university-level textbook, too.
cheers, and thanks
Jeff
At the bottom of the Thyristors page it says, "A positive pulse applied to the gate of an SCR triggers it into conduction." Wouldn't it be better to specify, "positive with respect to the cathode"? Experienced people easily assume this, but assumptions aren't appropriate in an educational setting.
More worrisome, the MOSFET page begins with two diagrams showing how a depletion region is established by making the gate positive with respect to the substrate. But then we see two diagrams with no connection to the substrate at all!
In discussions elsewhere I've often seen the MOSFET described as a symmetrical device, and IMO this theoretical point deserves an unhurried explanation so it can be firmly established and understood. Heck, I'm not sure I fully understand it myself! I realize (as stated later) that, in discrete MOSFET's, the substrate is connected to the source, but really MOSFET's are four terminal devices.
For once I'd like to see them discussed as such! (with due respect to the efforts of folks here and elsewhere). The assumption that substrate and source are connected should be carefully avoided until after the basics are established.
Can the page be improved so it clearly explains the 4-terminal theory first, and only deals with the 3-terminal assumption after? I've seen a bunch of internet references that failed to do so -- and, sadly, a university-level textbook, too.
cheers, and thanks
Jeff