Can you transmit video at 30 mhz?

Thread Starter

Man10

Joined Jul 31, 2018
206
can you transmit live video at 30 mhz? The resolution is 100 lines. Each line consist of 100 pixels. No color, instead a black and white image. A video compression method that only transmit differences in frames is used.
 

joeyd999

Joined Jun 6, 2011
6,513
can you transmit live video at 30 mhz? The resolution is 100 lines. Each line consist of 100 pixels. No color, instead a black and white image. A video compression method that only transmit differences in frames is used.
Grok says:

**Yes, easily.**

### Quick calculation
- **Resolution**: 100 × 100 = 10,000 pixels per frame.
- **Frame rate**: Assume 30 fps for live video (not specified; lower rates make it even easier).
- **Bit depth (B&W/grayscale)**:
- 8-bit grayscale: ~80,000 bits/frame → **2.4 Mbps** uncompressed.
- 1-bit (black/white, possibly dithered): **300 kbps** uncompressed.
- **Differential/interframe compression** (“only transmit differences”): This is classic motion-compensated or delta encoding. For typical scenes it often yields 10×–100× reduction (or more on mostly static content). Worst case (every pixel changes every frame) is still only the uncompressed rate above.

### RF bandwidth
A 30 MHz channel supports far more than needed:
- Even at a modest spectral efficiency of ~1 bit/s/Hz (simple modulation), you get ~30 Mbps.
- Practical schemes (QPSK ~2 bit/s/Hz, 16-QAM ~4 bit/s/Hz, etc.) give higher throughput.
- Analog B&W video of this tiny resolution would need well under 1–2 MHz of baseband bandwidth (standard NTSC-style video uses ~4.2 MHz for ~480 lines with far more horizontal detail).

So the raw data rate is tiny relative to 30 MHz of available spectrum, and the differential compression reduces it further. Practical systems (amateur radio ATV, low-rate digital video links, security cameras, etc.) routinely do higher resolutions or better quality in far narrower channels.

**Caveats** (none of which prevent it):
- Frame rate, exact bit depth, and scene motion affect the average rate.
- Regulatory channel masks, modulation choice, error correction, and range/SNR matter for a real radio link, but 30 MHz is ample headroom.
- Latency of the differential codec should be low for true “live” use.

In short, this is a very low-demand video stream by modern standards.
 

MrChips

Joined Oct 2, 2009
35,299
can you transmit live video at 30 mhz? The resolution is 100 lines. Each line consist of 100 pixels. No color, instead a black and white image. A video compression method that only transmit differences in frames is used.
Please note, pay attention to units.

You meant 30 MHz, not 30 mhz

m = milli = 10⁻³
M = mega = 10⁶

The difference between m and M is 12 orders of magnitude.

Edit: 9 orders of magnitude.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
can you transmit live video at 30 mhz? The resolution is 100 lines. Each line consist of 100 pixels. No color, instead a black and white image. A video compression method that only transmit differences in frames is used.
Not at 30 mhz. Now, if you're talking 30 MHz, that's different.

But, even then, the question is what do you mean by 30 MHz. Is that the carrier frequency? Or is that your allowed signal bandwidth?
 

ronsimpson

Joined Oct 7, 2019
4,884
When I was at Sony I say prototypes of video over phone lines. The resolution was low. Maybe close to your 100x100. They used compression. Probably slow, very slow. If the person stood still and talked the video was good. If the person jumped around the compression lost it. You are asking 30Mhz, they were well under 5Khz.
 

AnalogKid

Joined Aug 1, 2013
12,294
Back in the day, broadcast-legal, full-motion, full-color, 640 x 480 analog video was modulated on a 7.06 to 10 MHz FM carrier for recording and playback on videotape.

Before that, 4.2 MHz monochrome video was modulated on a 4.28 to 6.80 MHz FM carrier. This sounds like it violates Shannon and Nyquist but it didn't, thanks to a very linear FM modulator designed by a young Ray Dolby.

ak
 
For comparison purposes;
Apollo 11’s broadcasts of the surface of the Moon were 320x200 B&W at non-interlaced 10 frames per second. Required bandwidth was approximately 500 KHz using pure analog video.
 

N5KS

Joined Apr 17, 2016
12
It would depend on if you want to transmit over wire/light guide or over the air. If over the air, check your government agency in charge of the radio spectrum. If otherwise, it can be done.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
Everyone seems to be assuming that the TS is talking about having 30 MHz of bandwidth available, as opposed to operating in the 10 m (30 MHz) band of the spectrum. The TS has done a post-and-run and won't answer the question of which it is. He is very possibly limited to a very narrow signal bandwidth, but there's no way to know unless he provides a lot more details about which specific part of the spectrum he is using and who has regulatory authority where he is.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
At that frequency you'd be better off transmitting a gif image ...
Why?

I'm certainly not a GIF expert, so there may be capabilities that I'm unaware of that would make it a good choice. If so, I'd love to hear about them.

Based on my limited understanding, GIFs are not very suitable for streaming video (which is what the TS is trying to transmit). So a certain number of frames would have to be packed into a file and then the file transmitted, which would incur additional latency. Plus, each file would have to have a color table. For 8-bit grey scale. that would be 768 bytes right there before any data was included. And if the differences from one frame to the next span the entire frame, then it can't take advantage of partial-frame updates. In this case, each frame would have to be fully-encoded since GIF treats each frame independently. Also, if the image is a photograph (from a camera of some kind), then there might not be enough repetition to achieve meaningful compression using LZW compression.

The TS gives indication of the frame rate or of the nature of the scene, specifically how much might change per frame. So there is no way to estimate the bandwidth that is needed (even if they were to bother to answer the repeated question of how much bandwidth they have).

Also. what do they mean by "black and white image"? Do they truly mean monochrome (two colors, namely black and white)? Or do they mean gray scale? If gray scale, how many bits of gray?

Do they need lossless compression?
 

Ya’akov

Joined Jan 27, 2019
10,365
A classic 525 line NTSC video channel is 6MHz. That's for the entire AM video signal and FM audio. The video alone was only 4.2MHz—and that's a color signal.

480 lines of the signal were for the picture, the rest with vertical blanking. Horizontally, it was about 330 equivalent lines of detail horizontally and 29.97 fps.

So even if you used an analog encoding you could easily transmit at 30MHz (@WBahn that's how I read it as well, 30MHz carrier). The smaller digital version should require much less bandwidth.

The question is why? What are you trying to do?
 
The video alone was only 4.2MHz—and that's a color signal.
Also for a plain monochrome signal.

it was about 330 equivalent lines of detail horizontally and 29.97 fps.
A true monochrome signal with no color subcarrier could come in at 400 lines before the modulator. The rule of thumb was 80 lines of resolution per MHz of bandwidth. The camera signal systems easily exceeded 6 MHz; the limiting factor was the pickup tube.

And of course, with a pure mono signal there were huge increases in both vertical resolution (15750 lines/sec versus 15734), and temporal resolution with a frame rate of 30.00 fps. Huge.

ak
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
A classic 525 line NTSC video channel is 6MHz. That's for the entire AM video signal and FM audio. The video alone was only 4.2MHz—and that's a color signal.

480 lines of the signal were for the picture, the rest with vertical blanking. Horizontally, it was about 330 equivalent lines of detail horizontally and 29.97 fps.

So even if you used an analog encoding you could easily transmit at 30MHz (@WBahn that's how I read it as well, 30MHz carrier). The smaller digital version should require much less bandwidth.

The question is why? What are you trying to do?
The issue is what is the available bandwidth. For instance, in the U.S. 10 meter band, the entire allocated spectrum for amateur radio, for all purposes, is 1.7 MHz. But that is broken into subbands for different purposes. For analog images, the subband is 100 kHz wide and for digital data the subband is 80 kHz wide. But the FCC limits most digital transmissions to a bandwidth of 2.8 kHz, which is based on the intended use of the spectrum for telephony.
 

Ya’akov

Joined Jan 27, 2019
10,365
The issue is what is the available bandwidth. For instance, in the U.S. 10 meter band, the entire allocated spectrum for amateur radio, for all purposes, is 1.7 MHz. But that is broken into subbands for different purposes. For analog images, the subband is 100 kHz wide and for digital data the subband is 80 kHz wide. But the FCC limits most digital transmissions to a bandwidth of 2.8 kHz, which is based on the intended use of the spectrum for telephony.
Yes. If the question is not theoretical but practical, the answer taking the regulatory reality into account is, "no."

But while I am often the one to bring up the regulatory prohibitions in such a discussion, this seemed so obvious I didn't mention it.

So you are completely correct—practically this is impossible.
 

WBahn

Joined Mar 31, 2012
33,340
Hello,

One of the systems to transmit pictures on ham radio bands is Slow Scan TV:
https://www.essexham.co.uk/sstv-the-basics

Bertus
Which is almost certainly not useful for the TS since they want to transmit live video. Without knowing what they need, there's no way to know. Since they won't tell us....

If they want to transmit 100x100 at 8-bits of gray at 30 fps, they have a raw data rate of 2.4 Mbps. That's going to be hard to get into the allocated bandwidth if they are operating in the 10 m U.S. amateur band. But if SSTV will work for them, then that's not a problem because it was developed specifically to work within the 2.8 kHz signal bandwidth constraint. But transmitting a 128x128 grayscale image using SSTV takes about 8 seconds per frame and is probably not what the TS would be willing to call "live video", but, again, we just don't know.
 
Top