I'm looking for help with a combined reverse and overvoltage protection circuit.
The IC I'm protecting has an absolute maximum input range of -0.3 to 26V. Typical Vcc is 12V. I'd like to cap Vcc at 18V and prevent any reverse voltage. In both cases below, circuit activation will blow a fuse/CB in the supply line.
-----
I'm familiar with the standard SCR/zener-based crowbar circuit for overvoltage, but I'm wondering if it's possible to make it bidirectional by substituting a TRIAC for the SCR [see image below: TRIAC.png].
It appears that the TRAIC gate will have to see ~1.3V before turning on, so with reverse voltage applied, my IC's Vr limit will be exceeded by 1V.
-----
Another alternative I'm considering is the standard SCR crowbar with a parallel Schottky diode in reverse bias [see image below: SCR-Schottky.png].
Many 10A-rated Schottkys [like this] seem to have a Vf of ~500mV, which also exceeds my IC's reverse limit, although not as much.
-----
Questions:
1. Will these two circuits work as I've drawn them?
2. Am I correct in my assessment that both solutions exceed my IC's Vr limit?
3. If so, are there other options that will protect better?
4. Is C1 required with the TRIAC?
5. How do I calculate proper values for R1 and C1 in these circuits?
6. Is it correct to say that overvoltage cutoff = Vtrigger + Vzener?
7. Are 8-10A rated SCR/TRIAC sufficiently robust to blow a 3A fuse/CB without failing?
Thanks.
The IC I'm protecting has an absolute maximum input range of -0.3 to 26V. Typical Vcc is 12V. I'd like to cap Vcc at 18V and prevent any reverse voltage. In both cases below, circuit activation will blow a fuse/CB in the supply line.
-----
I'm familiar with the standard SCR/zener-based crowbar circuit for overvoltage, but I'm wondering if it's possible to make it bidirectional by substituting a TRIAC for the SCR [see image below: TRIAC.png].
It appears that the TRAIC gate will have to see ~1.3V before turning on, so with reverse voltage applied, my IC's Vr limit will be exceeded by 1V.
-----
Another alternative I'm considering is the standard SCR crowbar with a parallel Schottky diode in reverse bias [see image below: SCR-Schottky.png].
Many 10A-rated Schottkys [like this] seem to have a Vf of ~500mV, which also exceeds my IC's reverse limit, although not as much.
-----
Questions:
1. Will these two circuits work as I've drawn them?
2. Am I correct in my assessment that both solutions exceed my IC's Vr limit?
3. If so, are there other options that will protect better?
4. Is C1 required with the TRIAC?
5. How do I calculate proper values for R1 and C1 in these circuits?
6. Is it correct to say that overvoltage cutoff = Vtrigger + Vzener?
7. Are 8-10A rated SCR/TRIAC sufficiently robust to blow a 3A fuse/CB without failing?
Thanks.
Attachments
-
6.8 KB Views: 97
-
6 KB Views: 105
Last edited: